I'm currently playing it and damn, so much potential but I've spent like 70% of time reading and watching the live action than the wandering around... Sometimes I shoot stuff btw.
I think it's too cinematic and try to be anything but a game so hard that it bores me, the lore and story are good though, but when I have to read like 5 pages of text of a diary again after reading 2 pages of something else... Hmmm damn, it gets too tedious and heavy no matter how much I like the story.
Thanks God they came out with Control, the way they made this game so restrictive in every possible way and left every possible narrative to text and video is just awful, so much potential lost... And the thing is that skipping text and movies feels like losing on 80% of the experience so I'll just keep doing so, I'm on Act 5 anyway so I appreciate it doesn't overstays it's welcome.
I'm coming from 80+ hours of Sekiro and wanted something more relaxing but damn it gets pretty boring too frequently considering I want to play a GAME that feels like a game, not walk 40 seconds and read for about 2 to 6 minutes a wall of text, repeat, fight for 1 minute and then watch a 30 minutes TV show.
It's a good thing this approach was rejected by players, I wouldn't like the industry going this path, but like with From software games, almost no other devs could replicate this level of quality anyway, I'm somehow enjoying it for the story, I'm just too disappointed this came from the same minds that made Alan Wake and Control.