I don't know what to think of it. On one hand it seemed weird, like he already knew Melon was town. On the other, why would scum be that blatant when they're about to lynch a townie?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Legend of Zelda Mafia |OT| A Lynch to the Past
- Thread starter Sawneeks
- Start date
I don't know what to think of it. On one hand it seemed weird, like he already knew Melon was town. On the other, why would scum be that blatant when they're about to lynch a townie?
Trying to start a vote train against a town lynch, how scummy :>
I'm town too, AMA
-------------------------------------
Anyhow, when are we lynching Sophia?
If I'm remembering correctly, Price is Right had Magnum as a Neutral item thief.
I wasn't around for Star War's, but it looks like the thief role could be either alignment, really.
I'm at a loss with what to think today. My scum/SK read of CCS was wrong, and now my SK read of Stanley turns out wrong as well. At least I was pretty sure of Cabot being town, so I haven't been entirely wrong.
Looking at the Melon vote, we know of one confirmed town voting for her, that being Cabot. I'd wager at least one scum being among the rest. Splinter, Absolut, and Kyan at least have enough content out there to read through. Not much to consider with Magnum, though.
You are remembering correctly with The Price Is Right.
Of the people on the Melon vote, Kyan and Splinter were on Acohrs on Day 1. The othre two weren ot. Given the nature of the item in which Splinter received, it's unlikely he's scum. So that leaves AB and Magnum... hm.
On the Ty4on vote, there's myself and Terra as unconfirmed, with Nin being claimed town via Splinter.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
To be honest I'm more interested in the guys who weren't on the main wagons, Which would be Ynnek, Bronx, and Ty.
Well no. If I am correct with my speculation, town cannot lose today and we will always get a fifth day. Neutrals will vote to save their own skin, they should little care for who dies as long as it ain't them. Town and scum have little control over them.
There is a fair bunch of different possibilities now. I am assuming that there are three scum left and two neutrals, more townies obviously means the situation is better than speculated. In addition, I'll ignore those scenarios where kills miss or are manipulated:
(lynch-sk-scum = d5, t = town, n = neutral, sk = serious killer, s = scum, 0 = nobody, same.alignment = sk and scum pick same target [item thief or a townie])
t-t-t = 2-2-3
t-same.t = 3-2-3
t-t-n = 3-1-3
t-t-sk = 3-1-3
t-n-t = 3-1-3
t-same.n = 4-1-3
t-n-sk = 4-0-3
t-s-t = 3-2-2
t-s-n = 4-1-2
t-s-sk = 4-1-2
n-t-t = 3-1-3
n-same.t = 4-1-3
n-t-sk = 4-0-3
n-s-t = 4-1-2
n-s-sk = 5-0-2
sk-0-t = 4-1-3
sk-0-n = 5-0-3
s-t-t = 3-2-2
s-same.t = 4-2-2
s-n-t = 4-1-2
s-same.n = 5-1-2
s-n-sk = 5-0-2
s-s-t = 4-2-1
s-s-n = 5-1-1
s-s-sk = 5-1-1
I imagine I missed some possibilities. But the conclusion is clear: kill scum or the sk for the best set of outcomes.
He followed the kyanrute train that was getting some traction in the last hour.
Traction? A bait vote from cabot and Magnum's extremely panic-y reaction. No, there was no traction there.
Besides, the question was to Bronx, not to you. Why did you feel the need to answer it?
Why do you get so agitaded ? I think I struck a nerve with this. Interesting to say the least.
I responded because I wanted to chime in and put down my thoughts on it in order for Bronx to come in and say that it is plain false. But I guess I will have to keep waiting in that.
You misread my feelings just as you misread the votes on me at the end of yesterday. I was wondering what purpose your post served, since the votes on me yesterday were based on absolutely nothing. In addition, at best you can theorize why someone did what they did. Your post made it look like you knew the reason why Bronx kept his vote on me.
That's not what I intended, my bad but I would know that reason as much as you want to .
Woah. So you were the item giver ! Damn you mate ! With you saying I quit, does that mean you met your win condition?
Interesting.... why cabot on Night 3 given the way the deaths have been happening?
Nope, I give up my role and turn into a confirmed townie. Figured the role had minimum use as I'd either hit nk targets or scum
You trying to force a tie 'for the lulz' was extrememly scummy, though I realized eventually you had no chance of getting lynched. By the time I realized this, it was so close to the end that switching my vote to melon or ty would've made me look scummy.
And this does not even make sense to me. If your top scum were nin, stan and terra, why not switch to one of them then instead of the lead candidates that you did not seem to consider scummy?
To add to this, Bronx was just fine with being the odd one out voting nin for two days in a row. But then he takes the bait and sticks with it. Why did the conviction to see nin killed disappear so easily?
'Jokes on you, I was baiting you!'
Suuuuuuuuuuure.
I didn't change my vote because I found no reason to. Neither you nor nin had any chance of being lynched, so what difference did it make?
Oh, this is a good point
I find very interesting how usually when town is lynched, the next day we try to examine the ones that voted them. Yet today we've had multiple posters go "Actually, we shouldn't do any examination of those voters on melon at all! If anything, we need to focus on the ones that didn't vote for melon! Y'know...because!"
Why, it's almost as if there's a scum that voted for melon that the rest of their scummates are trying to protect.
Why, it's almost as if there's a scum that voted for melon that the rest of their scummates are trying to protect.
Well I did mention it, up to you if you believe me or not. The vote part is just uhhh. If you don't give any fucks about being consistent with your views, you are just making yourself look very scummy.
...Or we could look at the votes that tried to save scum on D1. Which is now down to you and Ynnek.
Between Absolut, Kyan, and Magnum I wouldn't be remotely surprised if there's scum on melon.
But D1 we lynched scum, and there's only 2 votes against that with unknown alignment.
Perhaps, instead of saying silly things like this, you should look up at the post where I already did look at the voters on melon.
Mods are slacking
https://soundcloud.com/ty4on/some-thoughts/s-Ph3fr
https://soundcloud.com/ty4on/some-thoughts/s-Ph3fr
Holy shit, can I get a transcript of that? Quality and noises are killing me
//I'm not a part of this game, this is just a very... interesting... way of trying to communicate
But it's nice hearing you
NopeHoly shit, can I get a transcript of that? Quality and noises are killing me
//I'm not a part of this game, this is just a very... interesting... way of trying to communicate
But it's nice hearing you
I can record more tho.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Please stand by.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Ty4on has quit being an Item Vendor and has become an Ordinary Non-Speaking Character (this means Vanilla Townie).
Keep playing, folks.
Well then... you just HAD to do that while I was typing up my list.
Alignments and roles of dead players:
I think that's everything important? If I missed any significant votes, let me know.
Alignments and roles of dead players:
- acohrs - Scum Ninja
- Sorian - Town Doctor
- Kawl - Town Watcher
- Natiko - Town Lover
- CzarTim - Town Lover
- Franconp - Vanilla Townie
- CCS - Vanilla Townie
- Melonrabbit - Vanilla Townie
- Cabot - Vanilla Townie
- StanleyPalmtree - Vanilla Townie
- Initially voted on CCS Day 1 but switched to Acohrs.
- No vote on Day 2
- Voted on Ty4on Day 3
- Initially voted on Sophia Day 1, but switched to Acohrs
- Voted on Stanley Day 2
- Voted on Sophia Day 3
- Mod-confirmed item giver and town aligned.
- Gave items to Natiko N1, Splinter N2 and cabot N3.
- Used day command "I QUIT"
- Initially voted on CCS Day 1, but unvoted exactly at the timer
- Voted melonrabbit on Day 2
- Voted melonrabbit on Day 3
- Voted on Acohrs Day 1
- Voted on CCS Day 2
- Voted on melonrabbit Day 3
- Received an item on Night 2 from Ty4on
- Used item on Night 3. Claims Nin is town.
- Voted on Acohrs Day 1
- Voted on Stanley Day 2
- Voted on melonrabbit Day 3
- Voted on CCS Day 1
- Voted on CCS Day 2
- Voted on Stanley Day 3
- Voted Acohrs Day 1
- No vote on Day 2
- Voted Ty4on on Day 3
- Claimed to be town by Splinter
- Voted CCS on Day 1
- Initially voted CCS on Day 2, but switched to Nin
- Voted Kyanrute on Day 3
- Claims to be vanilla town
- Replaced Pop-O-Matic; No Day 1 info
- Voted CCS on Day 2
- Voted Ty4on on Day 3
- Voted AbsolutBro on Day 1
- Voted AbsolutBro on Day 2, but unvoted and left with no vote.
- Initially voted Melonrabbit on Day 3, before switching to Kyanrute, before switching back to Melonrabbit.
I think that's everything important? If I missed any significant votes, let me know.
- Sophia, Ty4on, Splinter, Kyanrute, and Nin all final voted on a confirmed scum (Acohrs)
- Of the people above, Splinter and Kyanrute were on confirmed town Day 3 (Melonrabbit)
- Of the people above, Sophia and Nin were on a mod confirmed item giver Day 3 (Ty4on)
- Sophia and Magnum did not vote Day 2.
- AB and Ynnek have final voted all confirmed townies so far.
- Bronx has voted a confirmed townie (CCS), a cop-claimed townie (Nin), and an unknown (Kyanrute)
- Terra has voted a confirmed townie (CCS) and a mod-confirmed item giver. (Ty4on)
- Magnum has voted a confirmed townie (Melonrabbit), and two unconfirmed (Kyanrute and AbsolutBro)
So basically fuck everything I post that doesn't suit the narrative you have in your mind, correct?
Slow down. He made a fair point since claiming something does not mean shit
.It's fair to say that scum gets fake claims.