Finished it a few nights ago. Thought the show was interesting as all hell for the first few episodes, but by the time the bootleg Steve Rogers shows up with his horrible New Yawk accent, the show definitely started to decline. Killgrave, who seemed like an absolute terror in the beginning, was rendered nothing more than a confused and scared little boy who was never loved. His mind control power being explained as a virus felt akin to midichlorians. Leave some mystery. This is a world with mutants, right? Not everyone has to be the result of some freak science experiment gone wrong.
But lets talk about the protagonist: Jessica, a day drinking private eye who has a penchant for sarcasm and exuding an "I'm so over all this" attitude. The typical antihero. I'm a big Ritter fan mainly after discovering her on Breaking Bad, so I'm not going to fault the actress (maybe I'm biased), but there was really nothing about this character that carried the show. Her background and why she's so messed up only goes so far. Her "powers," could make up for that, but that was even less interesting than the character herself. I used to collect Marvel Hero trading cards as a kid, and those cards were great because they assigned a numerical value to certain attributes: e.g. strength, flight, speed, stamina, etc. I feel like Jessica would be on the low tier in almost every category. Probably above the Punisher, but def below everyone else. I mean, she's super strong, but not so strong that she can perform any real incredible feats...unless you consider bending a metal pipe (Luke Cage can attest to this) an incredible feat. Hell, she got hit by a van and went down like a sack of potatoes. Would've been much more intrigued had she quickly reached out a hand and stopped the van with enough force to cause the driver to be ejected from his seat and hurt. Plus, she almost always got her ass kicked in the fight scenes. WTF is this? What's the point of superpowers if everyone can give her business? Even her foster-sister Trish put Jess on her ass. C'mon now.
Speaking of Trish, she and every other supporting character were all kinda boring. I grew to hate Trish's subplot because it meant more screen time for bootleg Steve Rogers. I really hope that guy never shows up again. "I gotta kill Killgrave, so that means I gotta kill Jessica! RAWRRRRR!" WTF?
Trinity was alright...I guess. They had so little confidence in her plot that they made sure to have her assistant parade around in blouses that seemed to get more and more revealing of her bosom as the season went on (not complaining btw). Malcolm was far more interesting as a junkie then as a support group leader. Once he got clean it's like they didn't know what to do with him. "I'm moving because I need to get away from you, Jessica...even though you helped me get clean and saved my life!" The creepy twins felt like what someone that isn't from New York envisions New Yorkers to be like. "Hey, lets makes twins that are basically grown children and live together and bake while wearing nothing but their underwear because New Yorkers are weird, amirite?" Luke Cage....hmmm.....did he ever say anything? Was he just there to wear tight clothing and stare stoically at the camera? I can't remember one line of his other "DO WHAT YOU GOTTA DO!" before reverting back to zombie Cage.
The action scenes were nowhere near as good as DareDevil's, and I went into the show thinking/expecting as much, but I hoped the "noir" aspects would compensate for that. Really go for something approaching "Silence of the Lambs" in the MCU. Well, they started off hinting at that, but by the end that quickly fell by the wayside in favor of some weird cat and mouse game that basically always ended with Kilgrave saying"Everyone here will kill themselves if you touch me." Damnit. They could've really done something with his character. After he basically told a kid to go in a closet and pee on herself, I thought they were just getting started with his depravity. I expected some dark and disturbing scenes between him and Jess or Hope, showing what he did to them. Instead, he was made to be a petulant child that always got his way and never learned right from wrong. As for the sex scenes in general, well, they were equally lame for me. "Oh, Jess and Luke are banging so hard they broke the bed because super heroes go hard! tee hee!" And what is this, Fox? Sex scenes where the blanket is magically attached to the woman's chest or where the woman leaves her shirt on feels very much like a network tv trope from the 80's. Might as well have the theme from "Moonlighting Strangers" playing in the background. If the actresses don't want to show their bodies in that way, fine. Don't have a "sex scene." Mad Men did this better than any other show that comes to mind at the moment. I'd rather a scene where the characters are getting dressed after the fact then something that feels like network television.
By the time I got to episode 10, which should've been called stab town, I was dying laughing at how bad it had become. Thankfully the conclusion all but assures there'll be a new antagonist next season, but I really don't know where they can go with this show. Jessica doesn't really seem to have the ability to handle herself in a fight, her powers are very underwhelming and the show appears to be afraid to be as noir as I thought it would. I told a friend of mine I was hoping for Kraven and/or Callisto for season 2, but without the right writers those characters would be wasted on this.
It was a 6/10 for me.