Support NeoGAF

[super funk]

Good to see Layton sticking around the top 5. I would love to see that game have Brain Training-like legs .

 

[daemonic]

11. (NDS, Nintendo) Animal Crossing Wild World

WHAT

I can't believe AC is still going. How much has it sold now?

 

[perfectchaos007]

01. (PS3, Bandai-Namco) Gundam Musou - 170,725 / NEW
02. (NDS, Banpresto) Super Robot Wars W - 139,311 / NEW

Ok, so if Famitsu said Robot Wars sold more than Gundam, but Media Create shows that Gundam actually outsold Super Robot Wars by 30,000+ that means the numbers we get could be off by at least 30,000! I don't know what to believe anymore...

 

[CKD5989]

Any Final Fantasy 3 numbers?

 

[Verano]

How come Gonintendo has a different chart than the one posted here....??

1. NDS - Super Robot Wars W, 178,500 *NEW
2. PS3- Gundam Musou, 176,000 *NEW
3. PSP - Monster Hunter Freedom 2, 163,250 (905,500)
4. NDS - Prof. Layton and the Mysterious Village, 40,750 (230,250)
5. Wii - Wii Sports, 40,250 (1,164,250)
6. NDS- Pokemon Diamond / Pearl , 33,000 (4,992,000)
7. NDS - New Super Mario Bros, 31,000 (4,397,500)
8. Wii - Wii Play, 30,500 (994,250)
9. NDS - Dragon Quest Monsters Joker, 29,750 (1,222,500)
10. Wii- Brain Training 2, 29,500 (4,370,250)

:O

 

[sphinx]

the most intriguing thing of all is that between 10 and 15 titles in that Top 30 have been there for months now.

I think it will take a LONG time before another console can match DS' software perfomance. Look at Hotel Dusk, Wario, Common Knowledge training, Nintendo just keeps adding titles with legs of steel.

On another platform, these 3 titles would have disappeared already.

Dr- Layton's legs, amazing. It's its 3rd week in the Top 5, isn't it?

 

[Galactic Fork]

WHAT

I can't believe AC is still going. How much has it sold now?

I'm pretty sure it's either in or close to the 4 million club...

 

[perfectchaos007]

How come Gonintendo has a different chart than the one posted here....??

1. NDS - Super Robot Wars W, 178,500 *NEW
2. PS3- Gundam Musou, 176,000 *NEW
3. PSP - Monster Hunter Freedom 2, 163,250 (905,500)
4. NDS - Prof. Layton and the Mysterious Village, 40,750 (230,250)
5. Wii - Wii Sports, 40,250 (1,164,250)
6. NDS- Pokemon Diamond / Pearl , 33,000 (4,992,000)
7. NDS - New Super Mario Bros, 31,000 (4,397,500)
8. Wii - Wii Play, 30,500 (994,250)
9. NDS - Dragon Quest Monsters Joker, 29,750 (1,222,500)
10. Wii- Brain Training 2, 29,500 (4,370,250)

:O

I think thats vg charts numbers

 

[Galactic Fork]

How come Gonintendo has a different chart than the one posted here....??

1. NDS - Super Robot Wars W, 178,500 *NEW
2. PS3- Gundam Musou, 176,000 *NEW
3. PSP - Monster Hunter Freedom 2, 163,250 (905,500)
4. NDS - Prof. Layton and the Mysterious Village, 40,750 (230,250)
5. Wii - Wii Sports, 40,250 (1,164,250)
6. NDS- Pokemon Diamond / Pearl , 33,000 (4,992,000)
7. NDS - New Super Mario Bros, 31,000 (4,397,500)
8. Wii - Wii Play, 30,500 (994,250)
9. NDS - Dragon Quest Monsters Joker, 29,750 (1,222,500)
10. Wii- Brain Training 2, 29,500 (4,370,250)

:O

That's the Famitsu list (with the unnamed site's numbers), and this thread is a Media Create chart thread. There's a difference.

 

[Link]

How come Gonintendo has a different chart than the one posted here....??

*crappy numbers*

:O

Oh, now you've done it. Bail out quick!

 

[Defuser]

Wow,only a 2k difference

 

[Jasoncheng]

Any Final Fantasy 3 numbers?

http://ex21.2ch.net/test/read.cgi/ghard/1173317769/11/

56　DS　FF3　3500　999000　90

 

[CoolTrick]

All the links and boxarts and such has gotten annoying and pretentious at this point, in the first post.

 

[Jokeropia]

How come Gonintendo has a different chart than the one posted here....??

1. NDS - Super Robot Wars W, 178,500 *NEW
2. PS3- Gundam Musou, 176,000 *NEW
3. PSP - Monster Hunter Freedom 2, 163,250 (905,500)
4. NDS - Prof. Layton and the Mysterious Village, 40,750 (230,250)
5. Wii - Wii Sports, 40,250 (1,164,250)
6. NDS- Pokemon Diamond / Pearl , 33,000 (4,992,000)
7. NDS - New Super Mario Bros, 31,000 (4,397,500)
8. Wii - Wii Play, 30,500 (994,250)
9. NDS - Dragon Quest Monsters Joker, 29,750 (1,222,500)
10. Wii- Brain Training 2, 29,500 (4,370,250)

:O

VGCharts guesses based on the Famitsu ranking.

http://ex21.2ch.net/test/read.cgi/ghard/1173317769/11/

56 DS FF3 3500 999000 90

Awesome.

 

[bgassassin]

*counts amount of Nintendo DS 3rd party titles are in the chart*

Wow, things are really going well for 3rd parties in Japan on the DS eh? DQM still has great legs and 9 titles are 3rd party compared to the 1 PSP game (the only game that charted unfortunately). But alas, as Tabris said 3rd parties will concentrate on PSP because of that 1 game and S-E will put priority in releasing CCFFVII, oh well.

Yeah. It seems like the DS prints money for anyone who uses it properly.

 

[Evlar]

Regarding Animal Crossing- It was at 3,843,000 the first week of January, and it's almost certainly over 4 million now.

EDIT: Lost a digit there.
EDITEDIT: Wow I screwed that up.

 

[Busaiku]

Wii Play and Final Fantasy III DS both probably cross 1 million this week.

 

[justchris]

It's weird, one of the most Nintendominated weeks this year, and Sony pulls the 1st & 3rd slots by massive amounts. The drop off from 3rd place to 4th is ~100k.

Gundam Musou did very well, not quite as well as I expected, but I guess that's a result of the low install base. We'll see tomorrow if it did well enough to really push hardware or not.

Prof. Layton has some really nice legs. Been in the top 10 since launch, even with major releases coming out in competition. It'll likely drop into the top 30 soon, but should hang around there for a while, could end up with nearly 500k sales by the end of the year.

Anyway, this is about as exciting as MC is going to be this month. No big releases for any of the competitors the rest of March that I can think of. April might be interesting though.

 

[A Link to the Past]

Didn't see it mentioned, so...

Pokémon Diamond and Pearl back into top 30 uncombined. Nice!

 

[Galactic Fork]

http://ex21.2ch.net/test/read.cgi/ghard/1173317769/11/

56　DS　FF3　3500　999000　90

And this week will do it. Hmm Are those Famitsu's or Media Create?

Edit: Nevermind, actually looking at the page you can tell it's media create!

 

[Jasoncheng]

And this week will do it. Hmm Are those Famitsu's or Media Create?

MediaCreate

 

[Jokeropia]

5+ million lifetime a likelyhood for NSMB, BT2 and AC:WW?

 

[sphinx]

56　DS　FF3　3500　999000　90

I know there were people that made bets about this game not crossing the 1 million mark.

Amazing how slowly the title crawled to that number, it's been in the 900,000s for months!

 

[CKD5989]

Nice

 

[jj984jj]

http://ex21.2ch.net/test/read.cgi/ghard/1173317769/11/

56　DS　FF3　3500　999000　90

13　Wii　FE　18000　93000　50
16　DS　Hotel Dusk　15000　155000　87
24　PS2　Higurashi　11000　91000　86
34　DS　Love & Berry　7000　903000　81
40　Wii　Zelda　6800　409000　91
49　DS　Puyo Pop Fever 15th Anniversary Edition　4900　123000　94
55　PS3　VF5　3700　67000　62
56　DS　FF3　3500　999000　90
58　DS　Luminous Arc　3400　42000　70
59　DS　Etrain Odyssey (Sekaiju no MeiQ)　3100　70000　81
86　Wii　Elebits　1800　52000　82

 

[Oblivion]

5+ million lifetime a likelyhood for NSMB, BT2 and AC:WW?

I wonder if NSMB will beat GTA when all is said and done and reclaim the throne.

 

[Galactic Fork]

5+ million lifetime a likelyhood for NSMB, BT2 and AC:WW?

Well... If AC Wii has some connectivity to the DS version, AC:WW could go way beyond.

 

[theultimo]

I know there were people that made bets about this game not crossing the 1 million mark.

Amazing how slowly the title crawled to that number, it's been in the 900,000s for months!

Its like they put a hard cap on 999,999, just for the fanbase :lol

 

[justchris]

01. (PS3, Bandai-Namco) Gundam Musou - 170,725 / NEW
02. (NDS, Banpresto) Super Robot Wars W - 139,311 / NEW

Ok, so if Famitsu said Robot Wars sold more than Gundam, but Media Create shows that Gundam actually outsold Super Robot Wars by 30,000+ that means the numbers we get could be off by at least 30,000! I don't know what to believe anymore...

Which is why we agree by convention to use Media Create numbers. Even if they're not always right, they're internally consistent, which is the most important thing when making comparisons.

 

[Busaiku]

Anyone happen to know how the Final Fantasy III DS remake compares with the original Famicom game?

 

[thingonaspring]

NDS - 22
WII - 5
PS2 - 1
PSP - 1
PS3 - 1

Thats gotta hurt

 

[KINGMOKU]

NDS - 22
WII - 5
PS2 - 1
PSP - 1
PS3 - 1

That paints a picture that no one on the planet could have predicted. EVER


That makes me ask the question;


27-30 titles in Japan are on a Nintendo console. Is Sony screwed in Japan? and I mean screwed.

 

[Verano]

In case no one saw the list I posted previously....
10. Wii- Brain Training 2, 29,500 (4,370,250)

 

[TopDreg]

Holy gawd. It seems like Gundam Musou achieved sell-out status. Still, it'll most likely go through the BD effect. I'm predicting that despite Gundam sales, PS3's only going to have, at most, a 20k boost. Just like Famitsu predicted. Chances are that the majority of people who bought Gundam Musou had already purchase a PS3 before.

Edit: Congrats to Sony on having their first-ever top 10 seller for the PS3 in a long ass time, and even highest ranking software now, in Japan. It was an uphill battle filled with countless land mines, but they finally claimed a piece of battleground for themselves. But, for how long will they stay up there?

Edit: Fixed again.

 

[AniHawk]

NDS - 22
WII - 5
PS2 - 1
PSP - 1
PS3 - 1

That paints a picture that no one on the planet could have predicted. EVER


That makes me ask the question;


27-30 titles in Japan are on a Nintendo console. Is Sony screwed in Japan? and I mean screwed.

JUST WAIT FOR LITTLE BIG PLANET

 

[Oblivion]

Btw, what's PS3's Ltd so far in Japan?

 

[Dave Long]

27-30 titles in Japan are on a Nintendo console. Is Sony screwed in Japan? and I mean screwed.

Sure looks that way. I'm just not sure how they can continue at $600 and make any kind of dent in the current trend.

They really need for PS3 to be successful in the US and Europe.

 

[schuelma]

Sure looks that way. I'm just not sure how they can continue at $600 and make any kind of dent in the current trend.

They really need for PS3 to be successful in the US and Europe.

Didn't you hear- PS3 won the console wars today. Duh

 

[perfectchaos007]

Brain Age has been in the top 30 for 94 weeks straight now. If it can stay for just 6 more weeks in that top 30, it will reach an epic 100 weeks of in the top 30. Unbelievable.

 

[OokieSpookie]

How come Gonintendo has a different chart than the one posted here....??

1. NDS - Super Robot Wars W, 178,500 *NEW
2. PS3- Gundam Musou, 176,000 *NEW
3. PSP - Monster Hunter Freedom 2, 163,250 (905,500)
4. NDS - Prof. Layton and the Mysterious Village, 40,750 (230,250)
5. Wii - Wii Sports, 40,250 (1,164,250)
6. NDS- Pokemon Diamond / Pearl , 33,000 (4,992,000)
7. NDS - New Super Mario Bros, 31,000 (4,397,500)
8. Wii - Wii Play, 30,500 (994,250)
9. NDS - Dragon Quest Monsters Joker, 29,750 (1,222,500)
10. Wii- Brain Training 2, 29,500 (4,370,250)

:O

Why the **** do you think?

 

[chibcicylist]

NDS - 22
WII - 5
PS2 - 1
PSP - 1
PS3 - 1

That paints a picture that no one on the planet could have predicted. EVER


That makes me ask the question;


27-30 titles in Japan are on a Nintendo console. Is Sony screwed in Japan? and I mean screwed.

Wait for Little Big Planet.

edit: ah, beaten.

 

[thingonaspring]

JUST WAIT FOR LITTLE BIG PLANET

thats what they said about vf5

 

[duderon]

In case no one saw the list I posted previously....
10. Wii- Brain Training 2, 29,500 (4,370,250)

Cool, thanks for the vgchart number

 

[Galactic Fork]

Anyone happen to know how the Final Fantasy III DS remake compares with the original Famicom game?

Same general plot, but they fleshed out the characters and evens a lot in the DS version. I think it's much better. Still very straight forward old school FF, but very well done.

 

[Segata Sanshiro]

Why the **** do you think?

Are you suggesting some sort of shadow Nintendo conspiracy rather than the actually-true explanation of GoNintendo using VGcharts' 'numbers', which were determined by extrapolating from the Famitsu top ten, which has Super Robot Wars in first?

 

[AniHawk]

thats what they said about vf5

This time I mean it though.

 

[TopDreg]

Are you suggesting some sort of shadow Nintendo conspiracy rather than the actually-true explanation of GoNintendo using VGcharts' 'numbers', which were determined by extrapolating from the Famitsu top ten, which has Super Robot Wars in first?

He needs Yamauchi's approval to disclose such.

 

[Error]

59　DS　Etrain Odyssey (Sekaiju no MeiQ)　3100　70000　81

oh man, dumb Atlus screwing up with the shipment

 

[Great Rumbler]

Sure looks that way. I'm just not sure how they can continue at $600 and make any kind of dent in the current trend.

To make matters worse, the PS3 is cheaper in Japan than any other region.

 

[Oblivion]

Are you suggesting some sort of shadow Nintendo conspiracy rather than the actually-true explanation of GoNintendo using VGcharts' 'numbers', which were determined by extrapolating from the Famitsu top ten, which has Super Robot Wars in first?

Dude, stop making fun of Sony.