Support NeoGAF

[adamsapple]

come on snake, you can do it !

 

[_Alkaline_]

I think what's disappointing is that TOS2, despite being on a much more popular platform that TOS1, is actually performing worse than its predecessor.

TOS1 sold around 320K so hopefully TOS2 will eventually reach similar numbers. But with such a sharp drop-off like this week, it's doubtful.

 

[EDarkness]

I think what's disappointing is that TOS2, despite being on a much more popular platform that TOS1, is actually performing worse than its predecessor.

TOS1 sold around 320K so hopefully TOS2 will eventually reach similar numbers. But with such a sharp drop-off like this week, it's doubtful.

I don't understand this. The Tales series is not in the same state it was back then. They're basically running it into the ground with a new Tales game every few months. Unless there is something outstanding about the game, I don't see it putting up those kinds of numbers. They should give it some time to breathe, or maybe release one Tales game a year or something. To be honest, I'm surprised it sold as much as it has.

 

[Jaruru]

I don't understand this. The Tales series is not in the same state it was back then. They're basically running it into the ground with a new Tales game every few months. Unless there is something outstanding about the game, I don't see it putting up those kinds of numbers. They should give it some time to breathe, or maybe release one Tales game a year or something. To be honest, I'm surprised it sold as much as it has.

I think the game is selling fairly well. agree with you here, how many Tales of games have they announced recently? they're on every platform...

 

[Galactic Fork]

I don't understand this. The Tales series is not in the same state it was back then. They're basically running it into the ground with a new Tales game every few months. Unless there is something outstanding about the game, I don't see it putting up those kinds of numbers. They should give it some time to breathe, or maybe release one Tales game a year or something. To be honest, I'm surprised it sold as much as it has.

I'm not too bothered by lots of tales. They're all mostly so unrelated to each other, that it's not like they're actually a franchise. Seems more like a naming scheme than a series. I look at Tales like those monthly trashy paperback romances.

 

[Narcosis]

I think the game is selling fairly well. agree with you here, how many Tales of games have they announced recently? they're on every platform...

And the problem isn't necessarily that they are on every platform, but that it appears they are stretching themselves so thin that all of the current Tales games releasing now or in the near future look like they aren't as good a quality as they could be.

 

[Vinnk]

I can try to check the available stock of ToS2. As of Monday, it was not sold out anywhere (except the smallest shop).

 

[_Alkaline_]

I don't understand this. The Tales series is not in the same state it was back then. They're basically running it into the ground with a new Tales game every few months. Unless there is something outstanding about the game, I don't see it putting up those kinds of numbers. They should give it some time to breathe, or maybe release one Tales game a year or something. To be honest, I'm surprised it sold as much as it has.

Well, that is true. It was just my reasoning as to why some may be disappointed with these numbers.

But I agree that the market is oversaturated with Tales games and the series is losing its appeal.

 

[Rezbit]

6. [NDS] Mario Kart Wii (Nintendo) - 28,000 / 1,535,000

MIND BLOWN

 

[ZealousD]

I think what's disappointing is that TOS2, despite being on a much more popular platform that TOS1, is actually performing worse than its predecessor.

A successor can be outsold by the original for many variety of reasons. Platform is one of them, but it's not the only one.

Would you have expected FFX-2 to outsell FFX? Probably not. And it didn't.

 

[Jiggy]

Well, that is true. It was just my reasoning as to why some may be disappointed with these numbers.

But I agree that the market is oversaturated with Tales games and the series is losing its appeal.

Well, I'm not sure about "losing its appeal," but each game individually should (I think) logically be treated as less of an event, as Joshua's posts in the last thread demonstrated (here and here), since people only have limited time and/or money to play so many.

But yeah, I'm not disappointed by its sales even though I'm really looking forward to playing ToS: DotNW myself. It's primarily supposed to be aimed squarely at people who enjoyed ToS and wanted a storyline sequel--which should be enough to automatically cut its sales down to an extent. It can only draw upon a certain percentage of ToS buyers and maybe a smaller audience of extra people new to the series or new to the Symphonia universe in particular.

Of course, maybe one could say that ToS: KoR should be able to reach closer to the mark of ToS on GC because it's actually drawing upon the combined audiences from ToS on GC and ToS on PS2... I guess I might somewhat see that.

 

[Osuwari]

6. [NDS] Mario Kart Wii (Nintendo) - 28,000 / 1,535,000

would be fun if MKDS had the opposite typo.

 

[Phife Dawg]

Pretty slow week all around. ToS drops sharply so it probably won't have the good legs (for an RPG at least) of ToS GC.

MIND BLOWN

Well it's in the Top 10 games of the first half of 2008! :lol

No. 9 to be exact.

No offense to the OP but why dont we get the details that we used to get with cheese? BTW why doesn't he make these anymore?

Cheese is moving to Japan - he had a parser which did most of the work. You can't expect cvx to do all that work by himself. If you want to contribute feel free to do so.

Wii Fit has legs. Looks like for sure now it will outsell MHP2G

That was never in doubt.

 

[Tenbatsu]

Bio Hazard 0 Wii release today! Yeah! Yeah! Yeah?

 

[The_lascar]

 

[Terrell]

Wow, Nanashi no Game actually charted in the Top 10? Color me shocked.

 

[cvxfreak]

No offense to the OP but why dont we get the details that we used to get with cheese? BTW why doesn't he make these anymore?

I apologize for not being on top of the threads like Cheese did.

Cheese is in the process of moving to Japan and has no time. But, when he is able, he'll be running through the threads and updating the information as usual.

It takes a LONG time to manually do it the way he did, and time-wise it's not worth it to do it manually when he'll replace it in due time. If anyone translated games 11 - 40, PM me and I'll place the list in the OP. Thanks!

 

[hirokazu]

ブレーク

That's what first came to mind, but the other transliteration is better.

Go go Metal Gear!

 

[JoshuaJSlone]

What's the longest the same PS3 game has held onto the top 10? Does MGS4 hold that title yet?

By Famitsu's count, Hot Shots Golf 5 was for 3-4 weeks. The last section was one of their two-week periods, making distinguishing weekly ranks difficult.

Looking at Media Create from the same period... they have it in the top 10 for 4 weeks. So MGS4 ties that.

 

[Neomoto]

Band Brothers and ToS2 did good. Overall a pretty slow week though

Wii Fit has legs. Looks like for sure now it will outsell MHP2G

Wii Fit had always outsold MHP2G in total sales.

 

[JoshuaJSlone]

Overall a pretty slow week though

Sub-50K made me wonder how low things really get. So I made this query to display (from Famitsu data) the #1s of each week from lowest to greatest. Same caveats as ever: only systems from PS2 on, and multiple weeks combined into one are exempt.

Most of the lower weeks are from the 2001-2003 period. There are two weeks from 2007 in the sub-50K camp, though, 10-15 at 39K and 05-21 at 40K.

Wii Fit had always outsold MHP2G in total sales.

Media Create and Famitsu disagree on this. You can see from the numbers at the top that MC has Wii Fit with the lead, but on Famitsu...

 

[ivysaur12]

Ugh...

ToS2 is going to suffer the same fate as DQS. Undershipped (or underordered), and by the time more are shipped, used copies are already coming out.

DQS was also like a 10 hour game, so hopefully this will be a little different.

 

[Yoshichan]

I kind of hate to state the obvious but if you hate media create then why bother coming in the thread?

Because I want to check if MGS4 is placed where it should be (top 3). It's incredible how dumb it looks with it selling less than a mil.

 

[schuelma]

ToS sales aren't great, but I don't think they are disappointing given this has been positioned as a spin off from the start.

2ch watchers..and Famitsu numbers yet?

 

[Version 3.0]

Because I want to check if MGS4 is placed where it should be (top 3). It's incredible how dumb it looks with it selling less than a mil.

Ever heard the phrase "Don't kill the messenger"?

 

[JoshuaJSlone]

Because I want to check if MGS4 is placed where it should be (top 3). It's incredible how dumb it looks with it selling less than a mil.

 

[Cheesemeister]

Greetings from Japan. J-GAF, I am one of us. I'm fairly settled in here, but wouldn't you know it, I get a rotten headache and cough right when I get here.

If you guys would like me to take up the reigns again, I may be able to at least provide the OP contents. I'll be on the trains or in class when the weekly data goes live, so that's a no-go unless people want threads posted automatically without any copy-editing.

Anyways, it didn't look like too many people missed the translations and presentation. *shrug*

 

[hirokazu]

I wish I knew what I was looking at At least from the URL it seems like sales data for MGS2 and MGS3?

 

[Hammer24]

Anyways, it didn't look like too many people missed the translations and presentation. *shrug*

They did, even if they didn´t explicitely mention it...

 

[hirokazu]

They did, even if they didn´t explicitely mention it...

Yes, yes we did. Please take the reins again! No offence to whoever's OPing these threads right now (cvxfreak, good job filling in ), but I much prefer the CheeseMeister style.

 

[Fischbrot]

No first day sales today?

 

[JoshuaJSlone]

I wish I knew what I was looking at At least from the URL it seems like sales data for MGS2 and MGS3?

Yeah; I put in the labels for MGS2 and MGS3, but this morning I've also been tinkering with the line generators themselves to make shorter URLs since that massive Tales comparison yesterday seemed to be bursting at the seams. Looks like I unintentionally busted label back-compatibility. Should be fixed now, unless the older one is cached.

 

[Parl]

No first day sales today?

Nope, no first day sales, just like most non-Fridays.

 

[Frillen]

Anyways, it didn't look like too many people missed the translations and presentation. *shrug*

I think most people miss them, including me

 

[Vilix]

MGS4, hang in there. Let's hope that it will slowly crawl to approximately 630k.

What are those MGS LTD numbers again?

 

[Phife Dawg]

Greetings from Japan. J-GAF, I am one of us. I'm fairly settled in here, but wouldn't you know it, I get a rotten headache and cough right when I get here.

If you guys would like me to take up the reigns again, I may be able to at least provide the OP contents. I'll be on the trains or in class when the weekly data goes live, so that's a no-go unless people want threads posted automatically without any copy-editing.

Anyways, it didn't look like too many people missed the translations and presentation. *shrug*

Get well soon.

And now you're just fishing for compliments. I think CoolTrick's banned, so there's not even one guy who didn't miss your excellent work.

 

[Minsc]

Greetings from Japan. J-GAF, I am one of us. I'm fairly settled in here, but wouldn't you know it, I get a rotten headache and cough right when I get here.

If you guys would like me to take up the reigns again, I may be able to at least provide the OP contents. I'll be on the trains or in class when the weekly data goes live, so that's a no-go unless people want threads posted automatically without any copy-editing.

Anyways, it didn't look like too many people missed the translations and presentation. *shrug*

It is definitely missed, even if I'm not a common poster in these threads, I did enjoy the organization and usefulness of the layout you provided when reading them.

I don't know if thread length is any indication, or maybe it's just slower times, but the threads seem shorter without your OP too!

 

[schuelma]

Any Famitsu leaks yet?

 

[Captain Smoker]

Any Famitsu leaks yet?

Yes, finally. ^^

PSP: 52.000
DSL: 49.000
Wii: 46.000
PS3: 17.000
PS2: 11.000
360: 3.200


1. Daigasso! Band Brothers DX (NDS) 46.000 [168.000]
2. Initial D Extreme Stage (PS3) 44.000 [44.000]
3. Derby Stallion DS (NDS) 34.000 [181.000]
4. Nanashi no Game (NDS) 31.000 [31.000]
5. Wii Fit (Wii) 26.000 [2.288.000]
6. Tales of Symphonia 2: Dawn of the New World (Wii) 26.000 [177.000]
7. Mario Kart Wii (Wii) 20.000 [1.546.000]
8. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of Patriots (PS3) 19.000 [596.000]
9. Super Mario Stadium Baseball (Wii) 16.000 [102.000]
10. Monster Hunter Portable 2nd G (PSP) 15.000 [2.316.000]

11. Hisshou Pachinko Pachislot Series Vol. 12: CR Neon Genesis Evangelion ~Shito Hutatabi~ (PS2) 15.000 [65.000]
12. Mobile Suit Gundam: Operation: Troy (X360) 13.000 [43.000]
13. Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kizuna Vol. 1: Tatari (NDS) 12.000 [54.000]
14. Super Robot Wars A Portable (PSP) 11.000 [127.000]
15. Wii Sports (Wii) 11.000 [3.021.000]
16. Jikkyou Powerful Pro Yakyuu Portable 3 (PSP) 11.000 [211.000]
17. Beautiful Letter Training DS (NDS) 10.000 [314.000]
18. Meccha Taiko Drum Master DS: Adventure in Seven Islands (NDS) 7.800 [226.000]
19.
20. Wii Play (Wii) 7.400 [2.410.000]
21. Mario Kart DS (NDS) 7.000 [3.119.000]
22.
23. Dragon Ball Z: Burst Limit (PS3) 7.000 [118.000]
24. Sengoku Basara X (PS2) 6.900 [34.000]
25. New Super Mario Bros. (NDS) 5.900 [5.215.000]
26. Ratchet & Clank 5 (PS2) 5.300 [5.300]
27. Pokémon Diamond/Pearl (NDS) 5.100 [5.511.000]
28. Disgaea: Prince of the Demon World and the Red Moon (NDS) 5.000 [20.000]
29. We´re Fossil Diggers (NDS) 4.900 [158.000]
30. Family Trainer (Wii) 4.800 [82.000]

xx. L no Kisetsu 2: Invisible Memories (PS2) 4.400
xx. Riku to Johan: Kaeta Nimai no E (NDS) 2.900
xx. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (Map Download Special Limited Edition) (PS3) 1.100
xx. Ninja Gaiden Sigma (PlayStation 3 the Best) (PS3) 1.000
xx. Enchant Arm (PlayStation 3 the Best) (PS3) 840
xx. Boku no Natsuyasumi 3 (PlayStation 3 the Best) (PS3) 590

 

[schuelma]

Yes, finally. ^^

Thanks!

 

[test_account]

Thanks for the numbers everyone!

I wonder what happend to the Ratchet & Clank interest in Japan by the way. Ratchet & Clank 4's first week was 88,497 (thanks Joshua ) while Ratch & Clank 5's first week is 5,300.

EDIT: Or is R&C5 the port of R&C: Size Matters for PSP? If so, the PSP version sold 127,724 (LTD that is, first week is 39,529) so maybe people know that it is a port (i think it is atleast?) and that most people who are interested in Ratchet & Clank have already played the the PSP version.

EDIT2: Or maybe the PS2 in general has lost quite some interest compared to how it was before. Ratchet & Clank 4 was released in late 2005, so its about 2.5 years ago compared to when Ratchet & Clank 5 was released. Maybe people were much more interested in PS2 back in late 2005 when Ratchet & Clank 4 was released compared to when Ratchet & Clank 5 was released.

 

[PetriP-TNT]

Thanks for the numbers everyone

I wonder what happend to the Ratchet & Clank interest in Japan by the way. Ratchet & Clank 4's first week was 88,497 (thanks Joshua ) while Ratch & Clank 5's first week is 5,300.

EDIT: Or is R&C5 the port of R&C: Size Matters for PSP? If so, the PSP version sold 127,724 (LTD that is, first week is 39,529) so maybe people know that it is a port (i think it is atleast?) and that most people who are interested in Ratchet & Clank have already played the the PSP version.

Yeah, it's the Size Matters-port.

 

[Captain Smoker]

Thanks for the numbers everyone

I wonder what happend to the Ratchet & Clank interest in Japan by the way. Ratchet & Clank 4's first week was 88,497 (thanks Joshua ) while Ratch & Clank 5's first week is 5,300.

EDIT: Or is R&C5 the port of R&C: Size Matters for PSP? If so, the PSP version sold 127,724 (LTD that is, first week is 39,529) so maybe people know that it is a port (i think it is atleast?) and that most people who are interested in Ratchet & Clank have already played the the PSP version.

Port of the PSP version:

"Ratchet & Clank 5: Gekitotsu! Dodeka Ginga no Mirimiri Gundan"
see: http://www.gamefaqs.com/console/ps2/data/944300.html

 

[schuelma]

I'm curious if the huge ToS dropoff is partly due to supply issues, or whether it really was just that front loaded. It might not even hit 225K now..

 

[Stumpokapow]

I wish I knew what I was looking at At least from the URL it seems like sales data for MGS2 and MGS3?

When you want to read a graph, a good place to start is the legend. It provides helpful hints to tell you what the lines represent. Next, you can read the axis markers to derive from context what each dimension of the graph represents. CHEAT CODE: The x-axis of a graph is often the measure of time!

Edit: I've since been informed that the legend was not properly displayed when you posted, so this post is no longer directed at you.

 

[test_account]

Yeah, it's the Size Matters-port.

Port of the PSP version:

"Ratchet & Clank 5: Gekitotsu! Dodeka Ginga no Mirimiri Gundan"
see: http://www.gamefaqs.com/console/ps2/data/944300.html

Ok, thanks for the info to both of you! Ok so the latest japanese version of Ratchet & Clank for PS2 got a "5" in its name, i didnt know that. I dont think the european or american version have a "5" in the title atleast. I guess the already releasedPSP version can be one reason why Ratchet & Clank 5 sold so much less the first week compared to Ratchet & Clank 4, but i dont know.

 

[Captain Smoker]

Btw. Diamond/Pearl back in the Top30. :lol

 

[Journeywalker]

I hate Media Create.

This post is so much more entertaining if I imagine that you're a stealth NPD shill attempting to turn the tides of Sales-Age opinion away from the willy-nilly world of free data provided by the Media Create. After all, if we truly valued data, it would have monetary value. Whereas Media Create whores out its data any schlub on the street, NPD is a high-class data escort service.

 

[FateBreaker]

That's a pretty decent accomplishment.

Why troll Symphonia 2? Did it somehow hurt your feelings?

you say it's a spin-off but then it's Symphonia 2? Anyway, I agree. I don't think sales are too impressive. Not bad, of course, but not that impressive either.

 

[Vinci]

What I don't understand is why people expected MGS4 to deviate largely from the sales of the prior games in the series. Even fans of the game call it a love letter to them, so if you're not a fan already where's the inherent appeal?