• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Microsoft Studios' creative director has some choice words about always-online

Busty

Banned
this is a direct warning to the game industy :

detectiveGAF is always watching
your every move is known to us
No matter how deep you hide something
we will find it .

We are Neogaf for we are many.

And because we have no skeletons in the closet of our own we are UNTOUCHABLE.

Well, just as long as that whole 'sharp knee' thing or 'Deadmeat sister thread' don't come back to haunt us.

*adjusts bow-tie*
 

tusken77

Member
passiveaggressivedefense.png

So gamers are genuinely concerned about this direction. Many here in the thread who have absolutely loved their 360 are saying they'll reluctantly turn their back on MS next gen. But in Giespeak it's a "group of people" wanting to "push a narrative." Polygon, if you don't want your site generally considered a joke or to regain at least a shred of credibility, you can begin by taking Twitter away from this guy.
 

Ikael

Member
Curiously enough, as far as I remember last time I used my cellphone, car o vaccuum cleaner, I didnt' need any big corporation authorizing me to use their products once I already paid for them because surprise surprise, when I spend my hard earned money into any of these items I own them, not BMW, Samsung or Philips.

I am the owner now and got to do whatever I damn please with them. Which is something that apparently irks Microsof, EA, and their ilk, which now are bossing the consumer around, gladly letting us merely borrow "their" products instead of buying them. These corporations trying now to pretend that they are offering a service instead of a product are fooling noone: make me able to pay on a month per month basis so I can cancel their "service" whenever I feel that it is being a piece of shit, rather than me paying 100% for it in advance. I am sure that these arrogant big developers and their 6 hours campaings triple AA games with less content, depth and meat than a Gameboy cartdrige will be thrilled if such a scheme would be implemented and people would be able to cancel their suscription to their "service" four days after they "buy" their games and finish them, yes.

"Always online" is an unethical, anti consumer practic, period. I paid for the game, I own the game, and thus I will play with it whenver I want to, not whenever their creators feels like. Fuck that shit and everyone that supports it.
 

Toki767

Member
Gee no surprise this thread is still going strong.
I was thinking though about something I'm sure most people in the Western world especially N. America take for granted, refrigeration.
How many people worry about it always being on? How many wonder when they shop for groceries for the week or two weeks or the month, think about if their refrigerator will stop working because the power went off for hours at a time. I'm not saying I agree or disagree with always on for a console, but the internet is quickly becoming less of a luxury and more of a utility.

A refrigerator only needs electricity. Durango would need electricity AND internet. It's comparing apples to oranges. Or in Orth's case, Durangos to vacuums.
 

Reiko

Banned
These days there are ways to find dirt on you from way in the past, stuff that you may not be able to delete or know that it exists. It's not just Twitter, though it's a lot easier there.

Yeah, Porn... Past crimes...

You name it.

The Internet can be your friend and worst enemy. Tread carefully.
 

MasLegio

Banned
So gamers are genuinely concerned about this direction. Many here in the thread who have absolutely loved their 360 are saying they'll reluctantly turn their back on MS next gen. But in Giespeak it's a "group of people" wanting to "push a narrative." Polygon, if you don't want your site generally considered a joke or to regain at least a shred of credibility, you can begin by taking Twitter away from this guy.

at first I did not understand the hate for Gies

but now I totally do

listening to Rebel FM will be much harder now
 

rdrr gnr

Member
I can only imagine what happens when California wakes up. The story is reddit is still massive (over 7,000 comments). And since the IGN article went up, there have been 400 comments. Good Lord.
 

Reiko

Banned
I'd say having dozens of articles posted about some tweets you did, thousands of comments including mocking as well as a meme is - in total - undeserved. I feel we're blowing this way out of proportion.

Step outside of GAF for a moment...

This PR disaster is hitting multiple sites. It's not just us now.
 
These days there are ways to find dirt on you from way in the past, stuff that you may not be able to delete or know that it exists. It's not just Twitter, though it's a lot easier there.
Twitter seems to be the catalyst that causes Detective GAF (or whoever) to dig. Not having a Twitter account is a good way to keep your head down.
 

slider

Member
I'd say having dozens of articles posted about some tweets you did, thousands of comments including mocking as well as a meme is - in total - undeserved. I feel we're blowing this way out of proportion.

When you say "blowing this" do you mean his statements or the bigger issue?

The problem is his actions/comments are inextricably linked to the always online issue. So the outrage is snowballing. People like drama so there's no easy way back I'm afraid.
 
I'd say having dozens of articles posted about some tweets you did, thousands of comments including mocking as well as a meme is - in total - undeserved. I feel we're blowing this way out of proportion.
Yeah, a company representative mocking people for where they live and being a snarky ass to consumers who don't like the idea of dealing with their (potentially) shitty business practices is something people should just let happen.

Dude was being an asshole and is getting called out for it. He's getting exactly what he deserves.
 
Twitter seems to be the catalyst that causes Detective GAF (or whoever) to dig. Not having a Twitter account is a good way to keep your head down.

A lot of people still use it responsibly and appropriately, especially corporations.

Just seems like the rest of them use it as 'ranter' and forget the world is watching.
 

MasLegio

Banned
Curiously enough, as far as I remember last time I used my cellphone, car o vaccuum cleaner, I didnt' need any big corporation authorizing me to use their products once I already paid for them because surprise surprise, when I spend my hard earned money into any of these items I own them, not BMW, Samsung or Philips.

I am the owner now and got to do whatever I damn please with them. Which is something that apparently irks Microsof, EA, and their ilk, which now are bossing the consumer around, gladly letting us merely borrow "their" products instead of buying them. These corporations trying now to pretend that they are offering a service instead of a product are fooling noone: make me able to pay on a month per month basis so I can cancel their "service" whenever I feel that it is being a piece of shit, rather than me paying 100% for it in advance. I am sure that these arrogant big developers and their 6 hours campaings triple AA games with less content, depth and meat than a Gameboy cartdrige will be thrilled if such a scheme would be implemented and people would be able to cancel their suscription to their "service" four days after they "buy" their games and finish them, yes.

"Always online" is an unethical, anti consumer practic, period. I paid for the game, I own the game, and thus I will play with it whenver I want to, not whenever their creators feels like. Fuck that shit and everyone that supports it.


yup, that sums it up pretty good. How anyone wants to defend the practise of these corporations baffles me. My faith or some people in games media is very very low.

The corporate apologists make me truly sick to my heart and soul
 

wildfire

Banned
This was up on the Reddit conversations. Insight into Adam's personality?


This guy has a serious behavior problem.

Personally I think he should be only fired if always online feature is true, because MS would be spending a bunch of money hiring PR and marketing people to spin it as something good and he is undoing all of their hardwork before they can even start presenting it.

If its not true he shouldn't be fired because this incident will be nothing more than an ignorable bad memory in few months.

Regardless of it being true or not MS needs to issue a public apology for his behavior while representing their name on a public forum.

On top of that even if always online doesn't happen he still needs to be punished but I'm really unsure what would be the appropriate response. Suspend him with docked pay?
 

SmokedMeat

Gamer™
Always online, paying to play our purchases online, and anti-used...all of this will be forgiven and forgotten once we see the first trailer of Master Chief running around hitting switches in the former sci-fi series Halo for Durango.
 
A refrigerator only needs electricity. Durango would need electricity AND internet. It's comparing apples to oranges. Or in Orth's case, Durangos to vacuums.

I understand this, my comment is meant to convey that we do not think daily if our electricity will be down. Eventually we will feel the same, if most of us already do not about internet connectivity. I do not want a console that will be useless if my internet is down any more than I want the food I paid for to spoil in a refrigerator with no electricity.
 
passiveaggressivedefense.png


He is being a lot more passive agressive about it all, but damn, this guy seems to never fail to live up to expectations.

I think it's endemic of just how crap both the community and the press have gotten that someone going on a twitter rant is 100% for sure conformation of something and leads to massive meltdowns and hundreds of posts saying this is a for sure thing.
 

Mindwipe

Member
Gee no surprise this thread is still going strong.
I was thinking though about something I'm sure most people in the Western world especially N. America take for granted, refrigeration.
How many people worry about it always being on? How many wonder when they shop for groceries for the week or two weeks or the month, think about if their refrigerator will stop working because the power went off for hours at a time. I'm not saying I agree or disagree with always on for a console, but the internet is quickly becoming less of a luxury and more of a utility.

Yeah, but it's not just having an internet connection - it's about having an internet connection to Microsoft's servers.

The national grid doesn't tend to brownout whenever someone launches a high profile new model of fridge, and ultimately if they screw up for more than a few days they're obliged to fix it by law.
 

-PXG-

Member
This thread is 80 pages in less than 12 hours.......

Well... again.... If this thing really is always online, there is no chance in hell I'm buying it.
 
Is that Francis rant for real? I have seen another video of him losing it while being called fat online, but he can't be serious can he?
 

Rimfya

Banned
The content of these tweets is no longer the issue. Mainstream coverage of a negative narrative about MS' new console will become a massive problem if they don't kerb this soon. This could be Microsofts Sarah Pailin/Tina Fey moment -- where everyone has formed an opinion on you before you opened your mouth.
 
Or use it sensibly? Whenever I use the business Twitter account I think about Tweets for a while before posting them.
Well yeah, I'm not the kind of guy who would make fun of people who live in small towns. Same with that Penny Arcade thing with Ocean Marketing. I've never been a douchebag to anyone in my life, but still, the idea of spending your life building a career and it all comes crashing down in a day from a tweet or an email is a scary thought. I agree the answer is "don't be a dick". But it could also be "never say anything sarcastic or could be taken out of context."
 
Top Bottom