• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NASA's Mars Science Laboratory |OT| 2,000 Pounds of Science!

Status
Not open for further replies.

dabig2

Member
That is like only 0.4% of the us military budget.

Heh, I love this one quote from Something Awful about the cost of the mission (in comparison to the increasingly failing F-35 program):

It's aerospace. 67 billion dollars got us a 150 million dollar plane that can't fly in the rain, has to spend a ton of time in maintenance for every hour in the air, and randomly kills its pilots by hypoxia. The F-35 has been about $400 billion to develop and will cost another $800 billion to operate, and what we know about it is that the software still doesn't work, the fuel dump can cause it to catch fire, the hud doesn't work, using the afterburner damages the aircraft, it may not survive lightning strikes, and the airframe doesn't meet spec.

For ~2.6 billion we're lucky the camera even works.
 

luoapp

Member
Heh, I love this one quote from Something Awful about the cost of the mission (in comparison to the increasingly failing F-35 program):

Holy shit. Never thought about it that way. Now just imagine if we let NASA design the next fighter aircraft.
 

Log4Girlz

Member
THIS MISSION WOULDN'T EVEN BE NOTICED ON THE MILITARY BUDGET. I mean seriously, if we spent the 2.5 billion not from NASA's budget but instead took it from a Military budget...THEY WOULD NEVER HAVE NOTICED. LOL
 

pr0cs

Member
And it's money very well spent. In an ideal world NASA would have enough money to send a mission like that to another planet every week.

I can't believe so much of the last 40 years was wasted in arms races and wars.
Humans should have been actually landing on Mars now instead of how much money was wasted fighting each other.

Either way I wish there was more excitement from this landing. I hope they make some fantastic new discoveries pushing humanity to want to continue space exploration.
 

Garryk

Member
I can't believe so much of the last 40 years was wasted in arms races and wars.
Humans should have been actually landing on Mars now instead of how much money was wasted fighting each other.

Either way I wish there was more excitement from this landing. I hope they make some fantastic new discoveries pushing humanity to want to continue space exploration.

One could argue that it would have taken us a lot longer to put a man on the moon if it hadn't been for the Cold War, but I agree with you that money could have been spent on much better endeavors.
 
microcosmologist.com-SETI-infographic.jpg
 

i-Lo

Member

I love you man, I really do for posting this. Truly puts our priorities so far in perspective.

Such a shame that there are not as many people influenced by things larger than life and science to invest in projects like SETI.

Also note that if evidence that life had once existed on Mars is found then SETI should get a new lease of life.


EDIT:

One could argue that it would have taken us a lot longer to put a man on the moon if it hadn't been for the Cold War, but I agree with you that money could have been spent on much better endeavors.

Yes, you're right. We need these catalysts. However, these should be one time events to change course of human history. Violent events do not or rather should not always necessitate technological advancement by leaps and bounds over a short period of time.
 
Hopefully with Curiosity we will get some amazing Footage from Mars in good quality, that might spike an intrest and that might lead to new funding from the Government.
 

Utako

Banned
http://www.microcosmologist.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/microcosmologist.com-SETI-infographic.jpg[IMG][/QUOTE]Sometimes I wonder what humanity could achieve if every endeavor were focused on a singular goal like finding intelligent alien life.

We would be a part of the Galactic Federation by now.

Instead, our singular focus is - and always will be - having sex, and preventing other people from having sex.
 
Personally, if we find life, I'm interested to see what the general consensus will be as to whether we can morally justify permanent human habitation on someone else's planet, even if they are billions of years removed from caring.
Considering what we've done on Earth....yeah no problem in the least.

I have no words...
My god it's beautiful , fuck I'll pay high taxes, get us to Mars with humans!
 

Bowdz

Member
THIS MISSION WOULDN'T EVEN BE NOTICED ON THE MILITARY BUDGET. I mean seriously, if we spent the 2.5 billion not from NASA's budget but instead took it from a Military budget...THEY WOULD NEVER HAVE NOTICED. LOL

It may be depressing, but that is one of big pluses with having the Air Force/DARPA starting to push space technology. The X-37B is very well funded and has been a resounding success (so much so that Boeing and the Air Force are considering developing a larger X-37C that would be capable of housing 7 astronauts) and the DARPA Falcon project (hypersonic Mach 21 vehicle capable of operating within the atmosphere) continues to push ahead with no funding constraints despite a few initial setbacks (a quick aside, the Mach 21 HTV vehicle needs to be able to withstand constant temperatures of 3,500 degrees Fahrenheit, which is 200 degrees shy of Curiosity's entry temperatures). Defense spending is a political juggernaut when it comes to receiving funding and a certain degree of cross pollination between NASA and the DoD would be a great thing to ensure space exploration maintains a solid level of funding.
 

Ether_Snake

安安安安安安安安安安安安安安安
We first landed on Mars 40 YEARS AGO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

And that was just 2 YEARS AFTER LANDING ON THE MOON!!!!!!!!!

And that was just 7 YEARS AFTER SAYING LET'S GO ON THE MOON!!!!!!!!!!!

So much wasted time since.
 

Parch

Member
So much wasted time since.
I was around for the first moon landing and did school reports on subsequent landings. We talked about what the first man on Mars mission would be like. Back then everybody was sure we'd see it soon.

Not gonna happen in my lifetime. Might not happen in your lifetime.
So much wasted time indeed.
 

Teknoman

Member
I was around for the first moon landing and did school reports on subsequent landings. We talked about what the first man on Mars mission would be like. Back then everybody was sure we'd see it soon.

Not gonna happen in my lifetime. Might not happen in your lifetime.
So much wasted time indeed.

Would be nice if there was some sort of global collaboration to get there.
 

Log4Girlz

Member
You know what would be cool? If we could guide a water comet to the surface of mars.

Well, that would take quite sometime. I'm wondering if when the singularity hits, if we can send an armada of robots over there and just fucking start producing water by altering the elemental composition of the surface :D
 

PantherLotus

Professional Schmuck
You might differentiate what you mean when you say singularity, since there are multiple uses, the most common being the beginning of the universe and the center of a black hole (see the space thread for discussions on how those might relate!).

I think you meant technological singularity and I know what you mean though.

Speaking of technological singularities, one of the more unsettling questions of the pursuit of alien civilizations is the assumption that eventually one of them would rely on self-replicating robots to prepare the way for their eventual migration and/or exploration. Now, I don't mean to hold our little mote of dust in the vast sea of the Milky Way in too-high regard, but ... why haven't we seen these robots yet? The galaxy is what, 4-5 billion years old? If they're out there, then either we've already seen them and didn't know it, we didn't see them, or they're not there. :\
 

Log4Girlz

Member
You might differentiate what you mean when you say singularity, since there are multiple uses, the most common being the beginning of the universe and the center of a black hole (see the space thread for discussions on how those might relate!).

I think you meant technological singularity and I know what you mean though.

Speaking of technological singularities, one of the more unsettling questions of the pursuit of alien civilizations is the assumption that eventually one of them would rely on self-replicating robots to prepare the way for their eventual migration and/or exploration. Now, I don't mean to hold our little mote of dust in the vast sea of the Milky Way in too-high regard, but ... why haven't we seen these robots yet? The galaxy is what, 4-5 billion years old? If they're out there, then either we've already seen them and didn't know it, we didn't see them, or they're not there. :\

Well, its a classic question "Where are the aliens?".

1. Through random luck, we are the first civilization capable of reaching the technological singularity. Unlikely but perfectly possible.
2. Speed of light in uncrackable and alien civilizations are far enough away that we never meet, even if there are billions across the cosmos.
3. They have arrived and are like totally cool and avoid contacting us to let us develop on our own.
4. They're already dead. Achieving singularity is always an mass extinction causing event. Unlikely but perfectly possible.
 
Well, its a classic question "Where are the aliens?".

1. Through random luck, we are the first civilization capable of reaching the technological singularity. Unlikely but perfectly possible.
2. Speed of light in uncrackable and alien civilizations are far enough away that we never meet, even if there are billions across the cosmos.
3. They have arrived and are like totally cool and avoid contacting us to let us develop on our own.
4. They're already dead. Achieving singularity is always an mass extinction causing event. Unlikely but perfectly possible.

5. Civilizations destroy themselves / are wiped out by extinction level events before achieving the technological ability for interstellar travel, and the same thing will happen to us.
 

danwarb

Member
Well, its a classic question "Where are the aliens?".

1. Through random luck, we are the first civilization capable of reaching the technological singularity. Unlikely but perfectly possible.
2. Speed of light in uncrackable and alien civilizations are far enough away that we never meet, even if there are billions across the cosmos.
3. They have arrived and are like totally cool and avoid contacting us to let us develop on our own.
4. They're already dead. Achieving singularity is always an mass extinction causing event. Unlikely but perfectly possible.

There's also time. A previous generation of star systems in this region could've been populated by civilizations beyond our imagination. Same goes for the next.
 

MJLord

Member
5. Civilizations destroy themselves / are wiped out by extinction level events before achieving the technological ability for interstellar travel, and the same thing will happen to us.

Wow, first post I saw this morning bummed me out, thanks buzzkillington xD
 

MNC

Member
Well, its a classic question "Where are the aliens?".

1. Through random luck, we are the first civilization capable of reaching the technological singularity. Unlikely but perfectly possible.
2. Speed of light in uncrackable and alien civilizations are far enough away that we never meet, even if there are billions across the cosmos.
3. They have arrived and are like totally cool and avoid contacting us to let us develop on our own.
4. They're already dead. Achieving singularity is always an mass extinction causing event. Unlikely but perfectly possible.

5. Civilizations destroy themselves / are wiped out by extinction level events before achieving the technological ability for interstellar travel, and the same thing will happen to us.
Just thinking about this, and looking around me gives me this insane sense of scale, we're such a tiny blot in the universe's big picture. My mind cannot comprehend!
 

Log4Girlz

Member
I lean towards either A. The vastness of space is just too vast or B. They're already here and just silently, invisibly observing.
 
Just thinking about this, and looking around me gives me this insane sense of scale, we're such a tiny blot in the universe's big picture. My mind cannot comprehend!

Rudimentary creatures of blood and flesh, fumbling in ignorance, incapable of understanding. There is a realm of existence, so far beyond your own you cannot even imagine it.

Your confidence is born of ignorance, the cycle cannot be broken. The pattern has repeated itself more times that you can fathom. Organic civilizations rise, evolve, advance and at the apex of their glory, they are extinguished.
 
Just thinking about this, and looking around me gives me this insane sense of scale, we're such a tiny blot in the universe's big picture. My mind cannot comprehend!

Not just a tiny blot in the size of the universe, but a tiny blot in time. Even if millions of civilisations manage to survive for millions of years, what are the chances of two neighbouring civilisations existing during the same tiny period of time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom