I've played 2 games without the patch and one with and here are my impressions:
First about graphics:
- Court graphics look more detailed, and lighting looks much improved. It's better than 2k15 for sure.
- Presentation this year is on point. The 2k game feels like a broadcast of an actual NBA game. They even have one of those player interviews in between quarters (the one where they're interviewed in a room somewhere before a game and then they play the clip)
- The level of detail in this game is crazy. I just shot a free throw with curry, and he has his mouthpiece out while shooting the free throw, then after hitting, he goes down the court with his mouth piece still sticking out, then puts it back in when he's about to play defense. I mean, that level of detail is just crazy.
Gameplay:
- Movement feels different, in a good way. Everything feels weighty, and not all to cartoony and janky. It definitely takes some getting used to, but so far I'm digging it.
- Controls are different, especially the post-game, which I am not yet used to. One thing I'm not liking so far? The quick options on the d-pad. Instead of assigning everything to the D-pad, they attached it to the right stick. Maybe I'm not just used to it yet, but it's not as intuitive, or as responsive as the quick options before.
- Defense this year is no joke, and feels better than previous years 2k games.
Quick stuff I didn't like:
- The quick pick and roll button (now assigned to L1) is a bit janky. I would hold L1 to ask for a pick, but sometimes it would take me multiple attempts to get this to initiate (Pick and roll/pop in general is much improved though and I feel the changes they made were intuitive, also asking the pick setter to choose a side is a great addition).
- The tutorial is bare bones, and you can forget about getting a more detailed tutorial about the changes they made this year. Which even as a veteran of 2k, i felt lost at times because I didn't know what the controls were.
- The commentary took a step back this year, it doesn't feel as organic as last year's. There are some exchanges where it feels good, but for the most part, it feels like Greg Anthony is just reading something off of a piece of paper, and not actually conversing with the other guys.
Stuff I'm still not sure of:
- Blocking. At times it feels right, and I'm getting more blocks in this game than 14 or 15, but sometimes i feel it's too easy. Other times, I feel great. Especially when I play good positional D and deny a weak shot at the rim.
- Rebounding. Need more time to assess this as I'm getting mixed results in the games that I played.
- I feel like I was in more control last year than this year, but I'm not sure if it's because I'm not used to the changes they made in the controls, or it's because of the way movement feels different.
TLDR: There's a lot to like, and this is definitely much better than 2K15. Defense is the one thing that feels much improved this year. Also, I don't play too many other sports games anymore, but I think this has every other game beat in terms of presentation and level of detail.