NeoGAF Arcade Stick Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wired said:
As mentioned I'm having some seconds thoughts about my HRAP purchase, what are your guys thoughts about which type of stick is preferable? I know that in the end it's down to personal preference but I'd really appreciate any input you might have. Part of the problem is that I haven't been in an arcade in a decade so I have no idea how these sticks actually feel, hell the only stick I've used with some type of frequency is whatever is in the Dreamcast stick. I'm basically a stick virgin people.

Anyway if I gather things correctly the HRAP EX-SE has a Seimitsu LS-32, which I guess is a bit stiffer and has a smaller deadzone than whatever Sanwa stick is in the SF4TE (JLF)? Well, ok but how would you say this translates into real world use, am I going to have to break my arm of using the HRAP or something?

*sigh* Please don't laugh at my obvious distress
Click to expand...
EX-SE is phenomenal. No worries.
 
FSLink said:
I talked about the Mayflash adapter earlier in this thread. :P
Just press Home + L to switch the L and R buttons to digital instead of the default "analog" and it'll work without having to make a column dead.

Mapping is still weird on the PS3, but not really a problem with remapping in-game.
Click to expand...

Thank you very much for the info despite my inability to read =)

_dementia said:
EX-SE is phenomenal. No worries.
Click to expand...

I second this, and I'd imagine many others would as well. Here's a review I wrote on it:
http://www.amazon.com/review/R3UVBE...e=UTF8&ASIN=B002FKYPU4&nodeID=&tag=&linkCode=
I didn't know as much about sticks then as I do now (I now know what a Sanwa lever feels like, I've now owned a SFIV TE, and I also know that the EX-SE's lever is soldered, boo), but I stand by what I wrote. It still is the best unmodified stick I've ever owned. And I LOVE the LS-32 series. There are three of them installed within my apartment right now, and I'm ordering another today. =) So put those second thoughts away and just enjoy the stick when it arrives!
 
Really having trouble with my Street Fighter IV TE stick. I finally pulled it out of the box last night and tried playing through Arcade mode. Couldn't pull off a Ryu fireball 80% of the time. Several times while walking back / blocking, I would suddenly start jumping back instead. Is the square gate really superior to the rest?

I know I'm not used to it yet but if my ability to pull off one of the simplest moves went backwards, I'm thinking of changing out the gate. I'm definitely no expert with modifying (I wouldn't know the first step) or the lingo but with the stick being so loose, are there any better options?
 
I'm unsure of your level of stick experience, but: if the looseness is the big problem, I'd recommend a Seimitsu LS-32-01 lever...they're the opposite of loose. If you feel like the gate might be the bigger issue, ordering a GT-Y gate is cheap and easy (LizardLick is OOS right now...a few days should fix that problem).

http://www.lizardlick.com/Seimitsu-LS-32-01_p_422.html
http://www.lizardlick.com/Sanwa-GT-Y-Octagonal-Restrictor-Plate_p_242.html

Installing either is very easy, requiring just a screwdriver, some time, and perhaps the ability to look up tutorial pics/videos. =)
 
Thanks guys, after I wrote my last post I got sick and tired of the whole thing so I went to bed and forced myself to sleep. When I woke this morning the stick had shipped, so problem solved ;)
 
It's a better idea to learn how to use a stick before going out and changing parts. It's not an easy transition if you're used to pads. Practice makes perfect.
 
Kronotech said:
Really having trouble with my Street Fighter IV TE stick. I finally pulled it out of the box last night and tried playing through Arcade mode. Couldn't pull off a Ryu fireball 80% of the time. Several times while walking back / blocking, I would suddenly start jumping back instead. Is the square gate really superior to the rest?

I know I'm not used to it yet but if my ability to pull off one of the simplest moves went backwards, I'm thinking of changing out the gate. I'm definitely no expert with modifying (I wouldn't know the first step) or the lingo but with the stick being so loose, are there any better options?
Click to expand...

Swap out the square for an octogonal one. Think of it as a training wheel thing.

Also, it takes 5 minutes. I never touched a stick before and I did it, no problem.
 
_dementia said:
It's a better idea to learn how to use a stick before going out and changing parts. It's not an easy transition if you're used to pads. Practice makes perfect.
Click to expand...

Yeah, come to think of it... you could consider replacing either the gate or the entire stick, but perhaps try to use what you've got at least until you figure out whether the problem is the looseness or the gate.
 
Perfect information. Thanks everyone.

I'll practice a bit more with the one I have until MvC3 comes out. If I'm still not comfortable, I'll look at swapping.
 
Yeah. Never having actually played the SSF4 style TE sticks, is there a reason why other games seem to stick to the old style TE stick? Are the SSF4 style sticks less comfortable? More expensive to produce?
 
1. TE-X: So big it cuts off circulation from your legs

2. SE-S: Slim SE, Flat panel, TvC Parts, $50

please and thank you :)


*edit*

Forgot to mention: Madcatz needs to seimitsu up their stuff.
 
I'm selling my baby today and need a (smaller) replacement ASAP. Thinking SE, but the build quality on my TE left a lot to be desired (rusted screws that never came in contact with hand/enviro moisture, loose nut in the middle/bottom, scratch prone plastic etc.). So I'm hesitant to buy another that I know is of even lesser quality. I have a bunch of Sanwa buttons, octagonal gates, aluminum bat tops etc., so whatever I get, I'd like it to accommodate the parts I already have.

Any recommendations?
 
I feel silly asking it here, but based on the OP I couldn't find much information about what the best entry-level fighting stick is. There is a big amount of modding information though. :-P

I've gathered that you would either want to get the Mad Catz TE or the Hori Real Arcade Pro 3 to have a nice feeling stick.

Would it be a good idea to go for either one depending on which I find cheaper?
I'm planning on playing MvC3.

I'm in Germany so I probably have to get one from ebay or play-asia.
 
DaCocoBrova said:
I'm selling my baby today and need a (smaller) replacement ASAP. Thinking SE, but the build quality on my TE left a lot to be desired (rusted screws that never came in contact with hand/enviro moisture, loose nut in the middle/bottom, scratch prone plastic etc.). So I'm hesitant to buy another that I know is of even lesser quality. I have a bunch of Sanwa buttons, octagonal gates, aluminum bat tops etc., so whatever I get, I'd like it to accommodate the parts I already have.

Any recommendations?
Click to expand...
The EX-SE is built like a tank.
 
yyr said:
Alright, I want someone to tell me that I'm not crazy.

I've ordered two sets of Seimitsu buttons from LizardLick so far... a set of PS-14-G snap-ins, and a set of PS-14-GN screw-ins. To me, both sets feel similar to one another, but different than the Seimitsu buttons that came pre-installed in my HRAP EX-SE. They also make a different sound when pressed. The ones in the EX-SE make a much louder sound (hard to describe, but I want to say "hollow"). Visually, they differ a bit as well; when installed, the black ring visible around the plunger is flat on the EX-SE's buttons, and rounded on the ones I ordered.
Click to expand...

I ordered another set of PS-14-G buttons from LL and it arrived yesterday. These buttons look and feel the same as the buttons pre-installed in my EX-SE.

Upon closer inspection of both the buttons and the specs on LL's site, it would appear that when I ordered Aqua Blue PS-14-Gs awhile back, I didn't actually receive PS-14-Gs. What I got seems to be a snap-in version of the PS-14-GNs...the feel and shape are the same. I'm happy with these buttons anyway, but if someone is looking to order PS-14-Gs because of the shape or feel, I figured it wouldn't hurt to make you guys aware of this.

SapientWolf said:
The EX-SE is built like a tank.
Click to expand...
It is, and it's a great stick, but unfortunately
1) it's not smaller, and
2) the LS-32 is soldered in, so if you'd prefer a Sanwa lever you'll need to get the tools out.

The SE *is* a great choice if you plan to replace the stock parts anyway, but the 360 version is getting harder to find/more expensive at the moment. The PS3 version is still inexpensive at Amazon.
 
DaCocoBrova said:
I'm selling my baby today and need a (smaller) replacement ASAP. Thinking SE, but the build quality on my TE left a lot to be desired (rusted screws that never came in contact with hand/enviro moisture, loose nut in the middle/bottom, scratch prone plastic etc.). So I'm hesitant to buy another that I know is of even lesser quality. I have a bunch of Sanwa buttons, octagonal gates, aluminum bat tops etc., so whatever I get, I'd like it to accommodate the parts I already have.

Any recommendations?
Click to expand...
As mentioned above, SE is not bad at all.

If you're looking for something else and you're feeling adventurous I'd recommend an Agetec DC stick and modding it for modern consoles. It has quite a lovely sized, well-constructed shell.
 
one of the comments on SRK (yeah i know) put it best:

"the price [of the TvC stick] going down due to perceived inferiority is nothing but a win for me."
 
Chavelo said:
THAT... is sex.

And I want some sex.

You selling on the internetz or just locally?
Click to expand...


Sold it to a friend of mine that lives in Michigan. He already paypal'd me the loot. :(

Thanks for the recommendations. Looks like I'll cop an SE then. They're a lot cheaper. I didn't find the TE to be worth the extra $$.
 
I guess people forgot when other gaming companies used the same arcade stick body for 5+ years before changing it.

The TE has only been around 2 years.
 
^
At least step up the build quality, better materials etc. I had a number of issues with my TE-S in that dept.
 
MarkMan said:
I guess people forgot when other gaming companies used the same arcade stick body for 5+ years before changing it.

The TE has only been around 2 years.
Click to expand...
When you get the arcade stick right, no reason to change the design. Just curious why use the Round 2 TE design instead of the S style since the MvC2 used Round 1 design.
 
We all saw it coming, but I was personally expecting much better:

mvc3dec13h01.png


http://shoryuken.com/content/mad-ca...t-edition-fightstick-marvel-vs-capcom-3-3461/
 
Good idea for the graphic, but making collages out of different styles is always a bad idea and this is a bad example why.

Im also tired of the TE shape, something new would be better.

Ether way, I hope it sells well.
 
hey got a problem with my SE.
I replaced the stick and buttons with Sanwa and after a little while of playing, the kick buttons go out.

What do you think the problem is? Doesn't seem like they're getting loose but I always just push the connectors back in just in case and it'll work again for a few games.

Anyway to get them tighter? or should I replace anything?

Thanks in advance
 
toneroni said:
hey got a problem with my SE.
I replaced the stick and buttons with Sanwa and after a little while of playing, the kick buttons go out.

What do you think the problem is? Doesn't seem like they're getting loose but I always just push the connectors back in just in case and it'll work again for a few games.

Anyway to get them tighter? or should I replace anything?

Thanks in advance
Click to expand...

Do more than one of the kick buttons stop working at the same time?
Is it the same button(s) every time, or does it differ?
Are you making sure that you slid the plastic cover(s) over the quick disconnect(s) once you reconnected the button(s)?
If you post the answers to these questions, maybe we can get a better idea of what's going on.

Regarding the MvC3 TE:
I wonder if the hate for the SFIV Round 2 case simply stems from the fact that people just aren't big on that shape. I know it hasn't been overused; I just am really not big on those corners. I feel like they make the stick seem bigger and bulkier than it is...which some might like, but I do not. I haven't seen the new SSF4 TE-S stick in person so I can't judge for sure whether I like that shape better, but based on photos it looks more appealing to me.
Also, I can't help but wonder about the possibility of the 5000 units selling out. I could guess several reasons why this might not happen... and as many of you know, the BlazBlue TE is still available and easy to find.

1) If the TE sticks were throwaway junk, maybe more would sell as replacement... but because they're so durable and use good, replaceable parts, most gamers don't need more than one. Even if every button broke at once, it'd be cheaper to just replace the buttons.
2) If you play fighting games seriously enough to warrant spending $100 or more on a TE, there's a good chance you already bought one (or an HRAP).
3) It is common knowledge that other models (like the vanilla SF4 R2 TE) have the same shape and the same parts, yet are cheaper.

Of course I don't wish for any product to be a flop (unless it shouldn't be on the market in the first place). But I feel that the asking price is too expensive considering the above factors.
 
The MvC3 stick is fine, I was just kind of hoping it would be different enough to justify yet another stick, whereas it's basically like my round 2 with a mvc3 decal on it. As an owner of several TEs already I know i'm probably not the target audience, but if madcatz targed me and people like me they might sell more sticks!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

TR Octopus Arcade stick review; its not cheap but damn is it the best
13
951
Spukc replied
If PlayStation is successful at selling their own Fight Stick what Arcade type games would you like to see make a comeback or be created?
2
52
469
phant0m replied
Arcade Archives 2
46
2K
krumble replied
2025 add Neogaf members on Steam the thread.
2
69
3K
OverHeat replied
  • Poll
NeoGAF Official Game of the Generation Thread [Midgen Edition] (WINNER: Elden Ring)
Community Poll  2 3
138
2K
Touch fuzZy. get BizZay replied
Top Bottom