• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mod of War: Remastered

Ω
Staff Member
I just got mod'd for posting this



in the PS5 OT


CSIC3Ly.png


But which GoT thread would have been better? There is nothing in the last few pages related to GoT, the tweet didn't need it's own thread, I didn't know where to put it. Just a simple get hype post. Was I actually reported for this?

I wasn't in a rush, I just didn't know where to put it. Searched for GoT threads and there was nothing recent. Seemed releveant in a hot/trending Playstation thread

(edit: there is so much more I can say about the "rush to post" jab, like how many times I try to add something to an ongoing thread to consolidate discussion and 20 minutes later someone just copies it into a new thread anyway, but whatever.)



Hi Jare! Allow me to answer some of your questions, provide transparency with the situation, and give another perspective on the matter that you may find reasonable once explained.

There were plenty of threads in the past 2 weeks in the search. 2 created by you, yourself.


The simple form search:


Even a release announcement thread for those who possibly are still interested in what the game includes and want to get in on the preorder action:


While they are not on the front page, that does not mean they can't be bumped into topic. There are many pages for a reason, and with how fast things are starting to move now, I find myself going back 3 or 4 pages to read things I may have missed in gaming news.

Those threads are all within the past month, to as recent as just 2 weeks ago in the one you created, but the traction was not there due to all the Sony event rumors and buzz overshadowing in our current meta at the time. I think now would be a perfect time to bump your thread for a tweet. Something in which Kent Brockman, I mean IbizaPocholo IbizaPocholo does often and well.

Your post was indeed reported as well, but it was not malicious in nature, it was just reported as "off topic" due to those partaking in that |OT| wanted it to remain on topic to current known PS5 specific talk, in which I dropped a mod note here:


Due to some getting off topic yesterday, I had to clean it up a bit. Bait posts, trolling, and dropping PS4 game news. With that said, once the BC specifics are fully unveiled by Sony, and what enhancements that entails for their first party games on the PS5, then the thread would naturally migrate into that talk as well.

As for your edit about the slow down to post. As said many times on here, there is only so much we can fit in the notification message, nuance gets lost so for that I apologize. With that said, going through your post history I can pick out several occasions where you will post the same tweet or screenshot, in several different topics back to back, sometimes up to 3 times in a row in a span of the post timer. All we ask is at certain times relax a bit, and let one of the posts stand on its own. Then read the room on the current topic flow in the other threads before dropping that same type of post, in 3 different threads in a row. Otherwise it can give off the impression of thread spamming.

I hope that answers some of your questions and concerns.
 

Moogle11

Banned
Wow, there's so much I want to say. But, fuck it.

If the way I participate on GAF is a problem, or subpar (below standard, whatever), then I should be banned. I don't believe I did anything wrong.

Yeah, just take a break and get some air. This isn't a big deal. You make a valuable contribution to the site for sure as one of relatively few very active posters that actually posts a lot about GAMES and not consoles, sales, next gen predictions and other nonsense.

For this instance, maybe just make an individual thread for upcoming releases you're excited about and just bump them with minor news, tweets etc. instead of posting them in multiple threads or finding some thread that's not a great fit to post them in. From Mod of War's post it seems like they would be fine with that. Maybe just title the thread to indicate it's a general preview type for tweets, screen shots, new videos etc.--things that aren't necessarily threadworthy unlike some big new article or preview with a bunch of new details. I agree it's a bit awkward to bump a thread with a specific title just to share some mostly unrelated (other than being the same game) new tweet with a short video or screen shot or whatever--but I like seeing that stuff as someone that's not on Twitter etc.
 
Last edited:

Xaero Gravity

NEXT LEVEL lame™
Wow, there's so much I want to say. But, fuck it.

If the way I participate on GAF is a problem, or subpar (below standard, whatever), then I should be banned. I don't believe I did anything wrong.
Don't dwell on it, I don't think they meant anything malicious. Just take a breather, and if you're still upset I'll get CatLady CatLady to spend the evening with you. She's been lonely since the death of her hubby.
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
Wow, there's so much I want to say. But, fuck it.

If the way I participate on GAF is a problem, or subpar (below standard, whatever), then I should be banned. I don't believe I did anything wrong.

Stop it! You're a great poster and contributor, Mod of War: Remastered Mod of War: Remastered isn't saying you did anything wrong, just explaining you made a mistake. It's no big deal.

Please DO ignore the rambling of our resident lunatic, Xaero Gravity Xaero Gravity . When he's not marrying me off to Sony fanboys he's trying to pimp me out. :pie_roffles:
 
S

SLoWMoTIoN

Unconfirmed Member
Chunk you've been acting weird since yesterday. No need to be triggered over literally nothing. Please don't do that thing that you used to do or request a ban like a wuman.
 

Rentahamster

Rodent Whores
Stop it! You're a great poster and contributor, Mod of War: Remastered Mod of War: Remastered isn't saying you did anything wrong, just explaining you made a mistake. It's no big deal.

Please DO ignore the rambling of our resident lunatic, Xaero Gravity Xaero Gravity . When he's not marrying me off to Sony fanboys he's trying to pimp me out. :pie_roffles:
As long as that smarmy assburger stays in his lane and out of any hamster or otherwise rodent related services that are intimate in nature, I will maintain professionalism and not toilet paper his grandmother's house.
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
Stop it! You're a great poster and contributor, Mod of War: Remastered Mod of War: Remastered isn't saying you did anything wrong, just explaining you made a mistake. It's no big deal.

Please DO ignore the rambling of our resident lunatic, Xaero Gravity Xaero Gravity . When he's not marrying me off to Sony fanboys he's trying to pimp me out. :pie_roffles:

Oh word? Yo CatLady CatLady , how you do shawty!

Let’s watch movies and music videos together, slide that Gtag up in the DMs.
 
Last edited:
I requested that ban, why is it being used against me? What did I actually say that was wrong? Is it just that that thread is for people who hate the game, go to the OT if you want to be excited for it? Is that legitimately the idea because that's the idea the message gives off.
 

-Arcadia-

Banned
Woke up this morning to see NOLA_Gaffer ate a ban. Glad to see I wasn't alone in feeling like he was crippling discussions.

Mods are much cooler headed than me. I felt like he was non-stop blatantly antagonizing during some really emotionally charged conversations, and I wouldn’t have minded seeing him nuked.

Always glad to see someone get a chance to change, though. It’s one of the highlights of the moderation here, imo.
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
Mods are much cooler headed than me. I felt like he was non-stop blatantly antagonizing during some really emotionally charged conversations, and I wouldn’t have minded seeing him nuked.

Always glad to see someone get a chance to change, though. It’s one of the highlights of the moderation here, imo.

I didn't know he trolled Politics, but I've seen him troll in Gaming and it seems like he trolls both Xbox and PS . Maybe he just likes to troll.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom