NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Hamburglar said:
So wtf is actually up with the moderation on this forum, as in what is and isn't allowed.
Could EL or a mod actually explain? My impression is along as you don't war, troll or post extremist, racist stuff, most things were ok.

I make a light-hearted joke thread about trump in off-topic of all places as it clearly didn't belong in politics and it gets instantly locked with some sarcastic comment and infraction bullshit.
It was hardly offensive, troll or even insulting towards trump or anyone who supports him, yet it gets called "shit posting" when it was far from it.
Biden routinely gets threads made about him for being senile etc (which he probably is) but they don't get locked.
Do mods put their personal political agender into their moderation - I find it bizarre that a mod would get easily triggered over this thread.

www.neogaf.com

As a Trump fan do you describe yourself as a Trumper or a Trumpeteer

Baring in mind in the Uk a trump means fart so if you’re a trumper that could be considered that you’re a farter.
www.neogaf.com www.neogaf.com

So what is actually allowed then?
Click to expand...
Spoken like a true Trumper.
 
Significant ban warning for console warring - report me
Click to expand...

for what? posting memes? i was banned for a meme (don't tell me multiple unless you mean multiple memes), removed from next gen thread for a meme, another post was deleted for? that's right another meme, it's not like i console war with other members

0e3.gif
 
Explosive Zombie said:
That's nice, didn't say anything inappropriate, I was wrong about mail-ins for Philly but I was basing that on what other reliable posters had said upthread, my biggest fault is trusting fellow posters, I guess.
Click to expand...
Your tone didn't match the threads, you misread the room, you brought shit to a cakefight.
 
notseqi said:
Your tone didn't match the threads, you misread the room, you brought shit to a cakefight.
Click to expand...

I mean, you're right but I also only posted so many times before being ejected and warned, not sure it was necessary, a simple "hey, cool off" would have been enough. I don't appreciate the warning, tbh, if there's anything you can lose your cool over it's witnessing this bs.
 
Explosive Zombie said:
I mean, you're right but I also only posted so many times before being ejected and warned, not sure it was necessary, a simple "hey, cool off" would have been enough. I don't appreciate the warning, tbh, if there's anything you can lose your cool over it's witnessing this bs.
Click to expand...
[Political comment about self-responsibility here]
 
So i got another warning and my post deleted here and i didn't even say anything about xbox, memes are not allowed and it's console warring now wtf is this bullshit?

www.neogaf.com

Watch Dogs Legion runs at dynamic 1080p on Series S.

Ubisoft recently announced some details on the next-gen enhancements coming to the likes of Watch Dogs Legion, Assassin's Creed Valhalla, Immortals Fenyx Rising, Riders Republic, Far Cry 6, Rainbow Six Siege, and For Honor. However, we were able to receive extra tidbits of information from...
www.neogaf.com www.neogaf.com
 
kretos said:
So i got another warning and my post deleted here and i didn't even say anything about xbox, memes are not allowed and it's console warring now wtf is this bullshit?

www.neogaf.com

Watch Dogs Legion runs at dynamic 1080p on Series S.

Ubisoft recently announced some details on the next-gen enhancements coming to the likes of Watch Dogs Legion, Assassin's Creed Valhalla, Immortals Fenyx Rising, Riders Republic, Far Cry 6, Rainbow Six Siege, and For Honor. However, we were able to receive extra tidbits of information from...
www.neogaf.com www.neogaf.com
Click to expand...

Can you tell us the content of the post besides just saying it was a meme?
 
kretos said:
it was something like this "i just came back from a ban so i won't say anything" followed by this gif

tenor.gif


this shit deserve a warning/ban?
Click to expand...

You were warned for console warring, then then reply with:

"i just came back from a ban so i won't say anything"

but then decided to say something with a meme thats very clearly not contributing to a meaningful conversation about the topic? You said plenty without words. It makes sense you were warned.
 
kretos said:
it was something like this "i just came back from a ban so i won't say anything" followed by this gif

tenor.gif


this shit deserve a warning/ban?
Click to expand...

It's an accumulating, my man. They regard you as on thin ice, I'd let go of the console warring all-together, even in ways like this if I were you. Get back to a point where you aren't considered a few posts from a ban, let some warnings expire and you can stop walking on egg shells but man if you value your account I'd just stop. Post about the things you like, that make you excited, post positively and be friendly, even if it means killing a part of you that wants to do stuff like this.

They're just consoles, they play games, not worth getting exiled from here over. Mods are far less likely to want to discuss being lenient with someone they've marked as on a "Significant ban warning". And, if you post in the fashion I'm recc'ing and make in-roads with other posters if the day does come they perm you, maybe you'll have people fighting for your return, maybe it'd even get overturned.

I really hope you think about all this, I don't like seeing people banned and in my estimation it's best to not argue these mod decisions if you're already on a downward spiral of warnings/temp bans. The moderation is CLEARLY based on patterns of behavior and what they're seeing is that you haven't changed yours enough, it might seem unfair because other people get away with what you don't but other people aren't doing it all the time, other people aren't on multiple warnings, other people haven't been temp banned.

It takes a bit of self reflection, you need to remove your ego from it. Trust me, you can be on a good path here if you do the things I advise.
 
I thought CrysisFreak was alright but some kind of switch got flipped today that would warrant a limited time ban and the 'america hate boner'-tag.
If there aren't any more infractions, which I would not be aware of, could you review the ban duration?
 
notseqi said:
I thought CrysisFreak was alright but some kind of switch got flipped today that would warrant a limited time ban and the 'america hate boner'-tag.
If there aren't any more infractions, which I would not be aware of, could you review the ban duration?
Click to expand...
"Fuck that incompetent and frankly gay maggot. Hope he dies a slow death. " That's a little more than "an American hate boner," I think.
 
Yeah, I'd prefer a temporary ban and mockery, unless it's a demonstrated long-term behavior, or the poster has a long history of not contributing and bad posting habits.

People sometimes say some incredibly stupid shit when they're mad, and a whole lot of people get mad on election night, especially during these unprecedented times.

My take. I get why that punishment was chosen, and don't have a problem with it.
 
Last edited:
notseqi said:
I thought CrysisFreak was alright but some kind of switch got flipped today that would warrant a limited time ban and the 'america hate boner'-tag.
If there aren't any more infractions, which I would not be aware of, could you review the ban duration?
Click to expand...

Agreed. Seemed like an OK poster for the most part. I get the reason for the ban in the moment, but to echo others, it's election time and everyone is a little riled up too say the least. Maybe a reappraisal?
 
Wishing a painful death on someone is ban worthy to me. Specially someone that did nothing to you. What's next? Off with his head posts? No way fam.
 
I like the idea of someone being able to walk back an angry, emotional, post made in poor judgement specifically when the anger is not necessarily target towards another user. Offer a public apology and be given a second chance. That said, when a violent wish or threat of violence enters the mix it becomes more difficult to give someone that chance.
 
WTF Taysan is permed? There's no way I am going to approve this

just because your president lost doesn't mean you should throw a fit! Be more rational and mature!
 
YCoCg said:
...did he get banned for shitting on Cyberpunk? Because that would actually be hilarious, out of all the things to get him on :nougat_rofl:
Click to expand...

I guess the ban mensage is quite on the point. The guy play passive here, but dude is quite a REE on the resetera. If you curious on what I'm talking about, just do a search on the resetera thread.
 
I say good ridance. I never like his two-face attitude. The Cyberpunk stuff was the reason I was wondering why he was even allowed here, since their witch hunt attitude shouldn't be supported or incentivated. Resetera is the perfect place for him since he likes doing that and not talking about games.
 
Last edited:
TaySan likes to try and derail threads. While other posters can certainly do that at times, the others at least will respond to people that reply to their comments. TaySan will hold a conversation in a thread with only themselves.

TaySan is often times more of a obstacle for other posters. That is the simple answer from my view.
 
Fake said:
If you curious on what I'm talking about, just do a search on the resetera thread.
Click to expand...
We have a ResetEra thread? Or are you asking me to look on ResetEra? I'm not sure I want to do either, I'm happy not dealing with militant trans professional victims.
 
Fake said:
I guess the ban mensage is quite on the point. The guy play passive here, but dude is quite a REE on the resetera. If you curious on what I'm talking about, just do a search on the resetera thread.
Click to expand...
Saber said:
I say good ridance. I never like his two-face attitude. The Cyberpunk stuff was the reason I was wondering why he was even allowed here, since their witch hunt attitude shouldn't be supported or incentived. Resetera is the perfect place for him since he likes doing that and not talking about games.
Click to expand...
Well said, he liked hearing himself talk alot.
Redshirt said:
What the fuck are you even talking about, tyler? you're such a stupid lil' bitch.
Click to expand...
That was a blatant account suicide if I ever saw one. Literally out of the blue.
 
SLoWMoTIoN said:
Well said, he liked hearing himself talk alot.

That was a blatant account suicide if I ever saw one. Literally out of the blue.
Click to expand...

Everyone showing up outta the blue from RetardEra for a Got'cha, also like hearing themselves talk. Tay is right at home with the rest of his smooth brained brethren.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Snow & White | Review Thread
Community  2
80
5K
GymWolf replied
Feliz Navidad |NEOGAF|
19
736
Pyramid Song replied
Dark/light mode Neogaf feature request
20
721
Danknugz replied
Major Reddit Forums Ban X Links
News  2 3 4 5
213
13K
Bitmap Frogs replied
Help with neogaf website functionality. Constant freezes
2
64
2K
Major Insano replied
Top Bottom