Meh, I don't think BG2 aged that well, I think games like PST or Arcanum are more unique and original, if not as polished.
I didn't like DDOS because the writing was bad and the story/setting generic, I think that's fine for older games but I expect more interesting stuff from recent games.
Edit: not that Dragon Commander's writing was much better, but I thought the general concept was way more interesting.
edit: I'm guessing Expeditions Conquistador didn't make the list? One of the most overlooked recent rpgs.
I didn't like DDOS because the writing was bad and the story/setting generic, I think that's fine for older games but I expect more interesting stuff from recent games.
Edit: not that Dragon Commander's writing was much better, but I thought the general concept was way more interesting.
edit: I'm guessing Expeditions Conquistador didn't make the list? One of the most overlooked recent rpgs.