Next-Gen PS5 & XSX |OT| Console tEch threaD

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've used shareplay from day one and let's not get into how my son is 12 and how everytime he gets a new game his friends don't have or vice versa thy immediately go to shareplay to pass the controlling virtually to eachother. Besides some minor image degradation here and there it works awesome. My son also uses it when there's hard bosses and thy need help thyll help eachother via shareplay. On top of tht in most games you can have someone join in on mp without having the game. Shareplay is a dope feature, which has a robust feature set within itself, very innovative, you'd be surprised how much use it actually gets especially amongst the younger crowd.

Also we know sony and it's pioneering of remote play from ps3/psp days tht later others copied. Thy always have goodies in store.

My 12yo also uses it with his friends. Not sure if seasoned gamers like ourselves would take the streaming compromise, but kids aren't connoisseurs.
 
I've used shareplay from day one and let's not get into how my son is 12 and how everytime he gets a new game his friends don't have or vice versa thy immediately go to shareplay to pass the controlling virtually to eachother. Besides some minor image degradation here and there it works awesome. My son also uses it when there's hard bosses and thy need help thyll help eachother via shareplay. On top of tht in most games you can have someone join in on mp without having the game. Shareplay is a dope feature, which has a robust feature set within itself, very innovative, you'd be surprised how much use it actually gets especially amongst the younger crowd.

Also we know sony and it's pioneering of remote play from ps3/psp days tht later others copied. Thy always have goodies in store.
I used shareplay quite a bit.
Helped some friends out when they got stuck or showed them some secret locations item location etc in several games.
Session is limited to one hour though and streaming quality and lag is a hit and miss.
But its a wonderful tool that not a lot of people use or dont know how to use.
 
My 12yo also uses it with his friends. Not sure if seasoned gamers like ourselves would take the streaming compromise, but kids aren't connoisseurs.

I literally played drive club via shareplay before I bought it and thought most of the time I was playing a disc game lol as long as the upload numbers are good it's golden. I was so surprised how good it worked.

And yeah I don't use it as much bcus I work and buy the games I want but if patents are anything to go by there is a new Sony patent tht literally lets you tailor and cut sections of a game to send to friends and let try out. Broooo shit like tht is dope forward thinking imo.
 
I used shareplay quite a bit.
Helped some friends out when they got stuck or showed them some secret locations item location etc in several games.
Session is limited to one hour though and streaming quality and lag is a hit and miss.
But its a wonderful tool that not a lot of people use or dont know how to use.

This was one of its main intentions and you hit it spot on. Think all those ppl tht give up on souls games bcus the bosses wreck them lol shareplay is a godsend for some.
 
mmh no - the OG xbox had a GPU with just a 1cm high Al heatsink, no heat pipe, and no dedicated fan - that's why.

System used a typical shroud with fans mounted to the external chassis, nothing exotic. Also, nothing unusual, in fact very typical in a space limited configuration (servers, etc.). Again the chips themselves weren't overheating, the solder was reflowing to some extent. If the problem was as simple to fix as a bigger case or a better fan, the problem would have been addressed very quickly. Unfortunately, MS was dead set on a single-model global manufacturing process, this made it a harder problem to solve than it needed to be (the US had no issues with lead solder at that point).
 
I wonder if the narrative thus gen will be about speed and how fast games load esp with pop in. If confirmed that Sony has a more powerful SSD, I wonder if the nrrative will be which game looks better but more leaning toward which one is faster and has less pop in now?
 
I wonder if the narrative thus gen will be about speed and how fast games load esp with pop in. If confirmed that Sony has a more powerful SSD, I wonder if the nrrative will be which game looks better but more leaning toward which one is faster and has less pop in now?

I think this upcoming gen will focus more (like most gens) on who has the prettier and better exclusives. Ppl want to see if Microsoft can now hang with Sony now tht thy have a few more devs under their belt. But if there is a big discrepancy between ssd and rt solutions bet your life the warriors will cling to those too lol
 
Last edited:
Before I leave for the day I'll remember that the back in 2012 two numbers and two numbers only were floating around 1.2 and 1.8. And they turned out to be right on the money (except when MS up-clocked to 1.3 at the last minute 'cause the OG X1 was shit)

The two numbers we see floating around this time are 12 and 9.2. Until reveal, I'm just going to go with what history (in the era of infinite communication) teaches us.

Can't recall where I read, butt apparently some devs said back when the PS4 had 4GB RAM, the Xbox One was.... more powerful?

Quite weird, unless i'm wrong, it would likely match, as the 4GB GDDR5 is way faster than DDR4, what the XO had to help was the ESRAM which was faster than GDDR, but there was only 32MB. So I would suppose the extra 0.54 TFLOPS the PS4 coupled with the faster bandwith would cover the extra RAM the Xbox One had at that point.
 
Can't recall where I read, butt apparently some devs said back when the PS4 had 4GB RAM, the Xbox One was.... more powerful?

Quite weird, unless i'm wrong, it would likely match, as the 4GB GDDR5 is way faster than DDR4, what the XO had to help was the ESRAM which was faster than GDDR, but there was only 32MB. So I would suppose the extra 0.54 TFLOPS the PS4 coupled with the faster bandwith would cover the extra RAM the Xbox One had at that point.
It wasnt more powerful in the typical sense it just had more ram before it got upped to 8GB on ps4. The xb1 also used DDR3 not DDR4.
 
Last edited:
I think this upcoming gen will focus more (like most gens) on who has the prettier and better exclusives. Ppl want to see if Microsoft can now hang with Sony now tht thy have a few more devs under their belt. But if there is a big discrepancy between ssd and rt solutions bet your life the warriors will cling to those too lol
Im more wondering about third party titles, other than MS shooting themselevs in their foot multiple times before the gen started, lots of DF analysis was about resolution, I wonder now the system being potentiialy so close if it will be about how fast the games load and who has less pop in etc.
 
Confidence, dingleberry
Well. That confirms it then doesn't it. L. O. L.

Box . Check.
Picture of Apu. Check.

Duh must be da most powerful duh.

Forget stuff that might actually mean that obviously, like flops, clock speed and exotic tech.

Nope it's all about the box and Apu picture in dumb dumb land.
 
Last edited:
This was one of its main intentions and you hit it spot on. Think all those ppl tht give up on souls games bcus the bosses wreck them lol shareplay is a godsend for some.
Haha exactly. I had to help a buddy of mine with genichiro in sekiro. Nearly split my ass in half trying to beat him with his shitty upload speed.
But yes its called share play for a reason. Sharing the frustration of souls games hahaha.
For real this feature is a god send and i like helping my bros out.
 
A bigger box allows a more efficient cooling solution, the more efficient the cooling system the higher the clocks.

Do you really think MS are going to move away form the One X tech, with the specialty cooling system, to just an empty case and a fan perched on top? Phil Spencer has said that the design of the case was down to a mandate of performance over aesthetics? I predict the X will be the most powerful, the PS5 will be in the "good enough" range.
No it doesn't, you can have a big box yet an absolute terrible cooling. The Xbox Series X design is tall with an opening on the top with a fan at the top. Cool air is pulled in from opening at the bottom creating a partial pressure, hot air rises from the bottom to the top. It's an easy effective way to cool the whole system in a simple design. The size of the box is just there to contain everything otherwise why not go bigger?
 
Nothing wrong in copying. Sony has excellent engineers and their board design has always been good. Microsoft cooling solution is vastly different from Sony when it comes to PS4/Pro and Xbox/X. That is the reason why XboxO is quieter. Better is relative these days, both have their advantages and disadvantages.
My only issue with this is the spec for the Xbox one x was announced around the same time as Sony unveiled the pro. How would MS copy Sony if they already had their target specs and roadmap to release?
 
My only issue with this is the spec for the Xbox one x was announced around the same time as Sony unveiled the pro. How would MS copy Sony if they already had their target specs and roadmap to release?

They absolutely didn't and people who say otherwise instantly lose all credibility. It's really that simple, to be frank.
 
Last edited:
You can feel the electricity in the air. I hope we don't go full console war, but once the specifications are out and the differences between the two consoles are known we probably can't avoid it.

What will happen? Are the consoles going to be extremely similar in all regards? Is one going to be more powerful in terms of raw GPU performance? Does one have the better RayTracing? Is the SSD speed going to be a huge deal? How will Xboxs stance on no exclusive games in the first 2 years play into this? Could PS exclusive games easily outweigh the Xbox Series X if it were to happen that the latter is more powerful?

I also wonder if something completely unexpected happens. Like way bigger than we can think of right now.
 
No it doesn't, you can have a big box yet an absolute terrible cooling. The Xbox Series X design is tall with an opening on the top with a fan at the top. Cool air is pulled in from opening at the bottom creating a partial pressure, hot air rises from the bottom to the top. It's an easy effective way to cool the whole system in a simple design. The size of the box is just there to contain everything otherwise why not go bigger?

What does the word "allows" mean? Ffs what a post 😂
 
Well. That confirms it then doesn't it. L. O. L.

Box . Check.
Picture of Apu. Check.

Duh must be da most powerful duh.

Forget stuff that might actually mean that obviously, like flops, clock speed and exotic tech.

Nope it's all about the box and Apu picture in dumb dumb land.

I'm sorry this is going to be hard for you.
 
My only issue with this is the spec for the Xbox one x was announced around the same time as Sony unveiled the pro. How would MS copy Sony if they already had their target specs and roadmap to release?
The board design is from PS4. Compare OG board design to the X. I think they took inspiration from there. Great engineers copy or however the cliche goes and ain't nothing wrong with that.
 
Last edited:
There was suspicion whether it was hardware RT like rtx or forced hardware RT like something else using the navi cu.

Do you trust pr talks? Like what did he really mean? Or is their cutesy diagram clear enough?
Because there was a github leak that shows ps5 sdk did not have rdna2 RT

The Github leak also lines up with further GPU testing results that Komachi has posted on Twitter though, plus leaks from a Taiwanese gaming forum. As R R600 was saying, ray-tracing would require a different block enabled for the tests; the clock testing was for regression purposes, there wouldn't be a reason to enable the ray-tracing for those particular tests.

Hence why it wasn't listed. Doesn't mean RT isn't on the chip.
 
You can feel the electricity in the air. I hope we don't go full console war, but once the specifications are out and the differences between the two consoles are known we probably can't avoid it.

What will happen? Are the consoles going to be extremely similar in all regards? Is one going to be more powerful in terms of raw GPU performance? Does one have the better RayTracing? Is the SSD speed going to be a huge deal? How will Xboxs stance on no exclusive games in the first 2 years play into this? Could PS exclusive games easily outweigh the Xbox Series X if it were to happen that the latter is more powerful?

I also wonder if something completely unexpected happens. Like way bigger than we can think of right now.

I'm excited for a scenario where they're both extremely similar, but have key differences that amount to almost nothing in terms of actual games. I want to see people online that are counting rays of light shining between leaves of a tree.
 
I'm sorry this is going to be hard for you.
Not as hard as holding a conversation based in reality is for you.


Let's just get this straight though. I'm not saying the Xbox isn't more powerful, it maybe for all we know, what I'm saying is your reason for it is dumb as fuq.
 
Last edited:
System used a typical shroud with fans mounted to the external chassis, nothing exotic. Also, nothing unusual, in fact very typical in a space limited configuration (servers, etc.). Again the chips themselves weren't overheating, the solder was reflowing to some extent. If the problem was as simple to fix as a bigger case or a better fan, the problem would have been addressed very quickly. Unfortunately, MS was dead set on a single-model global manufacturing process, this made it a harder problem to solve than it needed to be (the US had no issues with lead solder at that point).

These are the OG heatsinks - the one with the copper base and heatpipe on the left is the CPU one - the one on the right is the GPU one. (Nowadays I've seen better on DRAM)

Clue : the og GPU sink is a POS
PF0PKio.jpg


This is the V2 sink for the GPU that fixed the problem - it add an additional cooling element, and a heat pipe
X2rL38B.jpg


But that wasn't all - even though the 360 had two fans they drove a single duct, with the GPU cooling part having a very narrow constriction, meaning it was easier for the airflow to completely bypass the GPU and instead cool the CPU sink.. why there wasn't a divider in the ducting I cannot explain.

This is the RROD fix in place - you can see that the V2 GPU sink now has a heatpiped extension that sits in the air path of the CPU sink ..

v0cbbkh.jpg


The break did happen at the solder, but it wasn't the solder's fault, and there are two obvious unexplained stupids with the original design of the cooling.

imo looks like incompetence as there were two obvious mistakes
 
This doesn't make sense. How many people actually watch State of Play?

Between NA and EU (official YouTube not counting mirror channels sharing the same videos), over 1 million views... now if they decide to show PS5 content and announce it ahead of time. I expect 10 times that amount.

Look how excited people got over a logo. A LOGO.
 
A state of play would be extremely limp. We need a live event with all the spectacle that comes with it, we need Cerny, Yoshida, Ryan, and a bunch of third parties on stage.

Fuck, we only get this once every 7+ years, it better not be a friggin' SoP
 
You can feel the electricity in the air. I hope we don't go full console war, but once the specifications are out and the differences between the two consoles are known we probably can't avoid it.

What will happen? Are the consoles going to be extremely similar in all regards? Is one going to be more powerful in terms of raw GPU performance? Does one have the better RayTracing? Is the SSD speed going to be a huge deal? How will Xboxs stance on no exclusive games in the first 2 years play into this? Could PS exclusive games easily outweigh the Xbox Series X if it were to happen that the latter is more powerful?

I also wonder if something completely unexpected happens. Like way bigger than we can think of right now.

Worse case scenario (which I'm expecting) is that Xbox is 20-25% powerful in terms of TFlops .. but this is (i think) the smallest difference ever between competing consoles (actually gamecube/PS2 might be close but they're also so different..)

Not sure how I feel about a difference - like wiser people have said "some place like Digital Foundry will have to pause a game, zoom in 300% and count who has the most blades of grass" .. which is what I expect to difference to be ..

still e-penis size though

Let's just get this straight though. I'm not saying the Xbox isn't more powerful, it maybe for all we know, what I'm saying is your reason for it is dumb as fuq.

I mean we've had a year of detailed tech leaks .. that seemed reliable .. plus now a die shot of a 400mm2 that matches expectations of those leaks.
 
A state of play would be extremely limp. We need a live event with all the spectacle that comes with it, we need Cerny, Yoshida, Ryan, and a bunch of third parties on stage.

Fuck, we only get this once every 7+ years, it better not be a friggin' SoP
Do we really? What we need is a longer state of play that covers everything. About 1 hour and 30 minute long. Where cerny talks about HW and the rest about games. The name ps5 will do the rest and people will watch everything and get hyped.

Media will get to cover everything at a later date. Think about it. If the logo gets so much attention a youtube video or live video presentation will do the same.
 
What if they fit in a teaser showing tiny parts of the PS5 and then a reveal date during the super bowl? :messenger_face_screaming:

Now I'm just imaging a cocky-ass move that only Sony could pull off.

No official PS5 reveal, no games shown yet, just a 15-30 second super-bowl spot that shows us the box, name, price, release date, and "pre-order now".

It won't happen, but I'd honestly still be hyped about that.
 
Last edited:
xool xool , the lead-free solder was introduced very late in the development process (literally months before the unit hit production. Lead solder units created prior, had no reflow issues. Even production models had no issues with critical temperatures. That's all I can tell you.

Band-aid fixes were attempted to avoid reflow.

Sorry to derail the topic, LOL
 
Not as hard as holding a conversation based in reality is for you.


Let's just get this straight though. I'm not saying the Xbox isn't more powerful, it maybe for all we know, what I'm saying is your reason for it is dumb as fuq.

My reasons;
Both have access to the same tech.
MS are on the back foot after X1 launch.
Sony have no incentive to go over the top.
MS have talked nothing but power and "best place to play" for 4 years.
MS show off a controversially massive case, out of the blue, and stating the design team were mandated on performance over looks.
And yes a photo of the SoC for all to see.
The latter two appear to be a show of confidence.
Lastly the 12/9.5 that's all over. Where there's smoke there's fire.

If that's as daft as fuq then call the loony bin and book a room for Milky Wibble!
 
I mean we've had a year of detailed tech leaks .. that seemed reliable .. plus now a die shot of a 400mm2 that matches expectations of those leaks.
Do you seriously believe ps5 is 3 tflops down on Xbox because some web searcher found a document with absolutely no context telling you that?

Despite the fact that every single leak says they are virtually the same power?

If you believe ps5 is 9.2 tflops then you also believe Phil was using creative math skills and the 12 tflops he was refering to was a gcn equivelant value and the Xbox is actually similarly powered and under 10 tflops.

Xbox cannot be 12 tflops and ps5 9.2 and both be similar in power, with ps5 with a slight advantage like Osiris and other leakers have said.

Only way that could possibly happen is if Microsoft royally fucked up another part of the console. I don't believe that is possible but if you do then fair play to you.
 
My reasons;
Both have access to the same tech.
MS are on the back foot after X1 launch.
Sony have no incentive to go over the top.
MS have talked nothing but power and "best place to play" for 4 years.
MS show off a controversially massive case, out of the blue, and stating the design team were mandated on performance over looks.
And yes a photo of the SoC for all to see.
The latter two appear to be a show of confidence.
Lastly the 12/9.5 that's all over. Where there's smoke there's fire.

If that's as daft as fuq then call the loony bin and book a room for Milky Wibble!

giphy.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom