Eminem said:dude, stfu =(
People ALWAYS said the same exact thing about Elway. And where is he now? To many people the best QB of all time. At worst, 2nd or 3rd behind Montana/Marino. Does anyone think of him as a choker? No.
Manning will win at least one SuperBowl in his career. He is simply too good not to.
Actually, people said the same thing about Marino, too. Not only is Manning showing himself capable of putting up stats like Marino, but he also demands the spotlight. His contract is going to cripple that team under the cap. He's not going to win a Super Bowl any time soon. He might go down as statistically the best ever, but right now Marino isn't thought of as the best QB of all time in general and he's the best passer ever. It takes more. Peyton has been an all-around dick for a long time, we'll have to see if he settles down and is able to do what is needed for the team (Elway) or keeps insisting on doing it his way(Marino). I don't feel comfortable at all making the assumption that Manning will win a super bowl. He'll go down among the greats, barring an injury or a huge unexpected dropoff in production, but whether he's going to be seen as the best is impossible to project.