• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

November Wrasslin' |OT| flipvember qdl flipvember

Zach

Member
You missed Punk and Roman.

Punk

In-Ring-9
Promo-8
Look-6

Roman
In-Ring-8
Promo-6
Look-10

One Hot Take deserves another.

You're missing Owen Hart and Razor Ramon too. And you'd need two slots for each. For Owen, you'd do Hart Foundation and Post-Bretxit and for Razor you'd do WWF and nWo.

oso4576.png


Okay, I'm done. I can only make so many people angry over nothing in one day.
 

Zach

Member
Cena only a 6 for promo and look? C'mon son!

I have limited knowledge of his promo work. What I've seen is okay. And if it wasn't for his shorts, I'd probably bump him up to a 7 or 8 in look. But I can't get over the shorts.

worst list ever

get your biased ass outta here, HHH is more than an average 6

I don't understand how I'm biased. If I thought Triple H was better, I'd rate him higher.
 
I have limited knowledge of his promo work. What I've seen is okay. And if it wasn't for his shorts, I'd probably bump him up to a 7 or 8 in look. But I can't get over the shorts.



I don't understand how I'm biased. If I thought Triple H was better, I'd rate him higher.
The shorts aren't great I'll give you that, otherwise I think he has a great look. As for promos I'd say he's the best in WWE right now, aside from maybe Heyman. He's definitely the best wrestler at giving promos.
 

Zach

Member
You know, basky boy, I think I've seen H wrassle at an 8 and look an 8 (probably both at Royal Rumble 2000), but the problem is that's about .01% of the Triple H I've seen. His in-ring maybe should be bumped up to a 7 overall. But his look? Probably not. And certainly not his promo. God, they're really bad, actually, from what I watch. Droning, really. But at least he shows some confidence. It's just not entertaining. Maybe I should bump that down. >_>
 

imBask

Banned
You know, basky boy, I think I've seen H wrassle at an 8 and look an 8 (probably both at Royal Rumble 2000), but the problem is that's about .01% of the Triple H I've seen. His in-ring maybe should be bumped up to a 7 overall. But his look? Probably not. And certainly not his promo. God, they're really bad, actually, from what I watch. Droning, really. But at least he shows some confidence. It's just not entertaining. Maybe I should bump that down. >_>

His looks are very debatable though because he changed a lot over the years

Hunter was a 9
Beardless HHH was a 5
Handlebar HHH was a 7 or 8
Jean jacket HHH was a 10
bald HHH is an 8

etc
 

Kaladin

Member
HBK's promo being a 5 is the biggest travesty. He was on fire during his early DX run and he cut some fire promos later too. He's an 8 at least.
 

Menome

Member
A - NeoGAF VinceMcMahon
B - SomewhatGroovy
C - Sweeney Tom
D - Professor Beef because I still have beef
D-Minus - Zach
F - OwensIsNow
 

Zach

Member
HBK's promo being a 5 is the biggest travesty. He was on fire during his early DX run and he cut some fire promos later too. He's an 8 at least.

You are some dramatic mothers. And coked-up Shawn Michaels was not enjoyable. Talk about droning on and on. God, his hilarious tough guy voice. Amazing.
 
He looks like a more handsome, wetter, maybe-just-as-pudgy-who-knows-because-of-all-the-clothes 1999 Big Bossman. I think he could look a lot better with more wrassle-y gear.

EDIT: OH MY GOD DATA WEST HAS BEEN WATCHING ME.
He's handsome but his body really underwhelms.

But if we're living in the world where Ric Flair is a 9/10 look then sure, Roman can be an 8
Fair points, although I still think even with the vest he has a look that doesn't make his push too shocking.

Seth has a decent look, Ambrose is basically nowadays a Discount McPoyle's Brother.
 

Zach

Member
I don't know if Rude deserves a 10 on Look. He may be a 9. I'm sorry!

You know who does score a 10, though? Guess before you click, Data, you rascal!

Sid Vicious.
 

Syder

Member
Roman is Hollywood handsome, far better looking than The Rock, but his overall look is detracted from by the vest and by the fact that he really isn't that well built or toned. If to get a 10 you need to look as close to being the archetypal WRASSLEMAN as possible then Roman is a 7.
 

Zach

Member
Roman is Hollywood handsome, far better looking than The Rock, but his overall look is detracted from by the vest and by the fact that he really isn't that well built or toned. If to get a 10 you need to look as close to being the archetypal WRASSLEMAN as possible then Roman is a 7.

He looks good there. Are we sure he looks like that, though? I'm guessing he'd ditch the top if so.
 
I'm back. And better than ever!

Caught up on Survivor Series. That was an unbelievable swerve. I honestly thought it was some Jeff Hardy / Sting shit. But the PPV was trash. WWE has no idea how to book their heels and faces.

Their best reactions come from the best heels (AJ and Y2J). Seriously, AJ is untouchable right now.
 
Top Bottom