And for the record, the listTM is now OA/dragonz/Swamped with Ezekel as the honorary replacement. The trio is there because I feel out of all the candidates, they have contributed the least to the overall discussion. Something like low-riders, I'd describe. Ezekel does not make it into this group because he is like a hound dog and the argument for him would be that he would be faking it. He seems too eager for that, if scum were faking it, surely they would tone it down a bit.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Of Gods and Men [Mafia] | Ambrosia In Front Of Me
- Thread starter Royal_Flush
- Start date
I don't want us to completely stall while we wait for Blarg, so here are the hypothetical scum teams I'm currently looking at.
If Blarg claims Komena:
Lone_Prodigy (unlynchable)
Seath (100%)
OceanicAir (90%)
and 1 of Swamped, Kyan, Dragonz
If Blarg claims not Komena:
Seath (unlynchable)
OceanicAir (90%)
and 2 of Swamped, Kyan, Dragonz
We are allowed 1 more mislynch, I think, so the second case is kind of preferable.
I do struggle to reconcile Feng's claims with what Blarg is suggesting, but hopefully he'll have a proper explanation at some point.
Blarg, if you're working on a mega post can you keep it to 1 topic per post? Pls & ty
If Blarg claims Komena:
Lone_Prodigy (unlynchable)
Seath (100%)
OceanicAir (90%)
and 1 of Swamped, Kyan, Dragonz
If Blarg claims not Komena:
Seath (unlynchable)
OceanicAir (90%)
and 2 of Swamped, Kyan, Dragonz
We are allowed 1 more mislynch, I think, so the second case is kind of preferable.
Personally I'm hoping for the first case for that sweet, sweet vindication.
I do struggle to reconcile Feng's claims with what Blarg is suggesting, but hopefully he'll have a proper explanation at some point.
Blarg, if you're working on a mega post can you keep it to 1 topic per post? Pls & ty
Blargonaut
Banned
...hmm?
*Splint?
I said nothing about a megapost
Just like I said nothing about being this Komena you seek
If you must know, I went to sleep
*Splint?
I said nothing about a megapost
Just like I said nothing about being this Komena you seek
If you must know, I went to sleep
Blargonaut
Banned
I'm sorry you thought you were waiting for me
Blargonaut
Banned
Royal_Flush
Member
All messages I received have been forwarded.
*sigh*
Ok, this should be easy at least:
I think we can afford both a mislynch AND a no lynch, so testing Seath won't lose us the game. I still think it makes no sense though. Even if Seath isn't Peripseros, someone on that list IS. As soon as we hit an unlynchable we would go for Seath next.
Anyone else. Opinions. Pls.
Ok, this should be easy at least:
5 players, 4 scum. 1 mislynch allowed.
I think we can afford both a mislynch AND a no lynch, so testing Seath won't lose us the game. I still think it makes no sense though. Even if Seath isn't Peripseros, someone on that list IS. As soon as we hit an unlynchable we would go for Seath next.
Anyone else. Opinions. Pls.
Giant Panda
Member
I agree Splinter that we only go after Seath if we hit another unlynchable.
Giant Panda
Member
Potatoes are terrible. So even if Kyan is scum at least he has good taste.
Blargonaut
Banned
hey, I got confirmation that my dream was real
So sayeth the great Alaundo
So sayeth the great Alaundo
I got two messages. The first was from Swamped. I do not quite get the message. She asks me to do the Kyan. I am not sure what this means. The second message was from the grand planner Blarg, reminding me of a certain watery canon.
Nothing amazing, but I'd really love to hear what Swamped's message was about.
Nothing amazing, but I'd really love to hear what Swamped's message was about.
Blargonaut
Banned
see? I remembered! 
so, what did the rest of you get
Don't say how much you spent
so, what did the rest of you get
Don't say how much you spent
EzekelRAGE
Member
I didn't get anything T_T.
Blargonaut
Banned
Blargonaut
Banned
Blargonaut
Banned
Blargonaut
Banned
Are you scum?
Blargonaut
Banned
[m] Lone_Prodigy
[m] EzekelRAGE
[m] Giant Panda
[f] Sophia
[m] Zippedpinhead
[m] OceanicAir
[f] Swamped
[m] Kyanrute
[f] WhereAreMahDragonz
[-] Seath
[m] *Splinter
[m] Blargonaut
[m] EzekelRAGE
[m] Giant Panda
[f] Sophia
[m] Zippedpinhead
[m] OceanicAir
[f] Swamped
[m] Kyanrute
[f] WhereAreMahDragonz
[-] Seath
[m] *Splinter
[m] Blargonaut
Blargonaut
Banned
nope
Blargonaut
Banned
Do you believe in scum?
Sometimes I wonder
Blargonaut
Banned
I mean, Komena and Peripseros are only allegedly among us, right
There's been no proof that they're really here
Besides, who says we can't issue these 'dictates' of theirs ourselves
amirite
There's been no proof that they're really here
Besides, who says we can't issue these 'dictates' of theirs ourselves
amirite
Blargonaut
Banned
Blargonaut
Banned
ohhhhhh, the oh-so vaunted red text
pls
From what I've seen so far?
Komena AND Peripseros are weak
powerless
and useless
We don't need them
Oh I can agree with that much.
Blargonaut
Banned
c'mon, Peripseros
strike me down right now
I'm right here, decay me
prove it
...and what is Komena gonna do?
balance me to death?
lol
strike me down right now
I'm right here, decay me
prove it
...and what is Komena gonna do?
balance me to death?
lol
Blargonaut
Banned
...see?
nothing
nothing
Blargonaut
Banned
Come to think of it. We haven't found another way to remove a God, and Star's win condition outright made it clear there's another way to kill a God, because otherwise she'd be removed from the game when she slayed one.
Blargonaut
Banned
NOW KYANRUTE
EzekelRAGE
Member
Blargonaut
Banned
NOW, KYANRUTE...
Are you scum?
Are you scum?
Zippedpinhead
Member
Beep beep beep
I'm a truck!
But seriously forks!
Flash! News at eleven!
I'm lost I really am, I have my top scum. But I don't trust my reads on town. Essentially it's why I really only trust Sophia,
Blarg, are you saying that lone_prodigy no longer exists?
I'm a truck!
But seriously forks!
Flash! News at eleven!
I'm lost I really am, I have my top scum. But I don't trust my reads on town. Essentially it's why I really only trust Sophia,
Blarg, are you saying that lone_prodigy no longer exists?
EzekelRAGE
Member
Yea, so the spell thing could be true. It was one of the things Seath tripped up in his Peri claim. What if that is what Seath is trying to bait out?
Some quick morning reads real fast.
*Splinter - He did a pretty valiant job of defending his role claim when called out on it. When questions were asked, he answered. He explained all his actions. This is actually a pretty good sign in my book. He's really active too, which I suspect scum wouldn't be if they were this late in the game... On the flipside, he's been overly critical of me, and as we've spent the remaining page or two discussing before Blarg came in, his claimed play of his role was pretty questionable.
Lone_Prodigy - Seems to have it out for Splinter, or at least did during the earlier portions of the day phase when Splinter was roleclaiming. When questioned on the possibility he was not Komera, gave a pretty wishy washy answer. When commenting on the fact that he appeared to gave a wishy washy answer, he gave an even more wishy washy answer. There's a whole lot of FUD in those two posts too. "Yes, I suppose there's a chance I'm not Komena." "If Blarg wants to cast doubt on my identity, he's allowed to do so." Like... what the hell? I think he's lying about being Komera.
EzekelRAGE - He's asking all the right questions, and has been a consistent voice of reason and scum hunter since Day 3. He's been relatively helpful and courteous too. I have no reason to suspect he's anything other than town right now.
OceanicAir - His early vote didn't look good. He seems to be popping in and out with some regularity. I could do without the aggressiveness seen in post #1344. If Splinter is cleared as town in any way, he'd be my top scum suspect.
Blargonaut - Blarg is Blarg and Blarg is gonna blarg, and not even a God would stop Blarg from doing that. We know Feng was the lightning rod, and we know the lightning rod absorbed the kill command. I believe it was Swamped who pointed this out to me that this probably makes him town, and I'm inclined to agree. He's outright suggested that LP is not the God he claims to be, among other things, but as expected we're not getting a strong answer from him.
Giant Panda, Swamped, Kyanrute - Still not sure about these three. Still feel like they're coasting. Need to check their posts over a bit. I'm sure there's scum in this group, but I doubt they're all scum, of course.
WhereAreMahDragonz - Been pretty inactive, but when given the chance to read through things today, she proved to be pretty perceptive. When we cleared up her confusion, she gave a good response in regards to Seath. Leaning slightly townie on her right now, but this could go either way.
Seath - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3TC02dxybw4
Would consider lynch: Seath, OceanicAir, Splinter, Swamped, Kyanrute, Giant Panda.
Would not lynch: EzekelRage, Dragonz, Blarg.
*Splinter - He did a pretty valiant job of defending his role claim when called out on it. When questions were asked, he answered. He explained all his actions. This is actually a pretty good sign in my book. He's really active too, which I suspect scum wouldn't be if they were this late in the game... On the flipside, he's been overly critical of me, and as we've spent the remaining page or two discussing before Blarg came in, his claimed play of his role was pretty questionable.
Lone_Prodigy - Seems to have it out for Splinter, or at least did during the earlier portions of the day phase when Splinter was roleclaiming. When questioned on the possibility he was not Komera, gave a pretty wishy washy answer. When commenting on the fact that he appeared to gave a wishy washy answer, he gave an even more wishy washy answer. There's a whole lot of FUD in those two posts too. "Yes, I suppose there's a chance I'm not Komena." "If Blarg wants to cast doubt on my identity, he's allowed to do so." Like... what the hell? I think he's lying about being Komera.
EzekelRAGE - He's asking all the right questions, and has been a consistent voice of reason and scum hunter since Day 3. He's been relatively helpful and courteous too. I have no reason to suspect he's anything other than town right now.
OceanicAir - His early vote didn't look good. He seems to be popping in and out with some regularity. I could do without the aggressiveness seen in post #1344. If Splinter is cleared as town in any way, he'd be my top scum suspect.
Blargonaut - Blarg is Blarg and Blarg is gonna blarg, and not even a God would stop Blarg from doing that. We know Feng was the lightning rod, and we know the lightning rod absorbed the kill command. I believe it was Swamped who pointed this out to me that this probably makes him town, and I'm inclined to agree. He's outright suggested that LP is not the God he claims to be, among other things, but as expected we're not getting a strong answer from him.
Giant Panda, Swamped, Kyanrute - Still not sure about these three. Still feel like they're coasting. Need to check their posts over a bit. I'm sure there's scum in this group, but I doubt they're all scum, of course.
WhereAreMahDragonz - Been pretty inactive, but when given the chance to read through things today, she proved to be pretty perceptive. When we cleared up her confusion, she gave a good response in regards to Seath. Leaning slightly townie on her right now, but this could go either way.
Seath - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3TC02dxybw4
Would consider lynch: Seath, OceanicAir, Splinter, Swamped, Kyanrute, Giant Panda.
Would not lynch: EzekelRage, Dragonz, Blarg.
Blargonaut
Banned
You're saying beep beep beep? Interesting. I was thinking that too.
Could be, could not be. Only way we're going to find out is if we see the spell in action it seems. :\
It slipped my mind until Blarg pointed it out, but we really haven't found another way to kill the Gods despite the fact that there has to be another one, or Star's win condition makes no sense.
Blargonaut
Banned
Being anachronistic is a #scumtell
I'm boring. And no.
Similar threads
- Poll