This isn't about which Madden player is the best (they are all pretty good, well maybe save for LiveWire or Eznark- I dunno I just find their existence simply as plot device). It's more about how people find Rorschach as some sort of "omg what an epitome of a badass MaddenGod".
I'm probably the only one who sees him as an extremist, probably racist, out-of-control guy who sees things black and white without any form of sympathy. Think of Batman without all of the positive traits. Is it because he is playing the nerd fantasies of a "guy who takes no warning from no one and beats the crap with impunity", but is really a member of Seal Team Six and likely planning Zero Dark Thirty-Two?
EDIT: Compelling is a poor word. Worshiped/very well loved should be an ideal term. Could a mod change it?