Denis Bourdain from Load Inc (developer of Mad Tracks and upcoming Things on Wheels) comments on XBLA delistings:
http://www.360sync.com/conversation/may-28-delisting-xbla-games
I think de-listing is some what natural (in small proportions), and I'm right in the eye of the cyclone having a sub 65% game since more than 6 months on the service.
What I'm more concerned about are criterias.
Metacritics lists all kind of mainstream gaming site, lots of hard core sites, 'serious' people reviewing 'serious' games most of the time. Are they the best suited to judge an XBLA title sold 4.99 or 9.99? --> not a popularity criteria!
Six months or more: here at Load Inc. we play ReVolt a couple of times a week - this game is ten years old!! --> not a popularity criteria!
Regarding conversion rate, I'm totaly with Microsoft. I trust in try before you buy, if people don't buy after the trial version, you didn't reach far enough - again, not saying it make a game bad, but that might be a popularity criteria.
I will keep defending my title and the 72.000 plus people that bought it since May 30th last year.
Happy B-Day Mad Tracks.
DenisDenis.
http://www.360sync.com/conversation/may-28-delisting-xbla-games