Support NeoGAF

[IbizaPocholo]

Welcome back to Is It Still Fun Today?, the show where we revisit classic games to see if they still hold up. Today it's the classic rap 'em up, Parappa the Rapper, released in Japan 30 years ago in 1996. This rhythm game was way ahead of its time -- but does it have the gameplay to back up its personality? Let's find out.

• (00:00–01:02) Introduction & context
  • The panel revisits Parappa the Rapper (1996), widely considered the first true rhythm game, which influenced later titles like Dance Dance Revolution and Guitar Hero.
  • Known for its unique paper-like visual style and quirky tone, it became a PlayStation mascot and a hit, especially in Japan.
• (01:02–02:49) Early impressions & nostalgia
  • Panelists recall playing it via demo discs, which helped spread its popularity pre-internet.
  • The game's Japanese-inspired style and music left a strong impression on players growing up in the '90s.
• (02:49–04:33) Gameplay criticism (even back then)
  • Rhythm mechanics are described as confusing and difficult, requiring memorization rather than reacting to visuals.
  • Compared unfavorably to later rhythm games that refined timing and responsiveness.
• (04:33–05:26) Cultural impact & accessibility
  • Demo discs made the game widely known despite its niche concept.
  • Recognized as cute, funny, and accessible in style, even if gameplay was frustrating.
• (06:11–07:33) Modern playthrough issues
  • Playing on modern systems reveals latency and synchronization problems, especially in ports (PSP/PS4).
  • Even original hardware shows inconsistencies, suggesting design flaws from the start.
• (07:33–10:10) Core gameplay flaw
  • The main issue: timing doesn't match visuals or music reliably.
  • Players often succeed by ignoring either the audio or visuals—bad for a rhythm game.
• (10:10–13:18) Design intentions vs execution
  • Developers may have intended players to "feel the rhythm" rather than follow prompts.
  • Interesting ideas like freestyle "cool mode" exist, but are poorly implemented and inconsistent.
• (13:18–16:41) Innovation & historical importance
  • As the first of its kind, it lacked tutorials and standardization.
  • Later games (e.g., Um Jammer Lammy) improved the formula significantly.
• (16:41–19:05) Presentation & charm
  • Universally praised for:
    • Art style (Rodney Greenblat)
    • Music and sampling approach
    • Humor and personality
  • Considered highly charming but mechanically flawed.
• (19:05–31:36) Final verdict
  • Consensus:
    • Still fun to watch, listen to, and appreciate historically
    • Not fun to play today due to frustrating mechanics
  • Described as more of a "museum piece" than an enjoyable modern game.

 

[Danny Dudekisser]

I'm not going to watch it but the answer is "yes". It's pretty basic, though. Umjammer Lammy is a massively better game overall, but the real best game of this general style will always be Gitaroo Man.

 

[Werewolf Jones]

CUT THE LETTUCE, CU-CUT THE LETTUCE.

GRILL THE CHEESE, GRI-GRILL THE CHEESE.

It's still good but it would not be seen as acceptable to sell it as a full price game today.

 

[Killer8]

It wasn't fun in 1997 and it still isn't today. The scoring system is so obtuse as to feel broken.

The game is remembered for the songs and the memes, not how it plays.

 

[HallowedFeast]

Daffy Duck says no.

 

[ReBurn]

I fire it up every now and then. I like it.

 

[struggler_guts]

It wasn't fun in 1997 and it still isn't today. The scoring system is so obtuse as to feel broken.

The game is remembered for the songs and the memes, not how it plays.

I remember being so frustrated trying to place this as a kid, the timing being off on a fuckin rhythm game is just unacceptable

 

[poodaddy]

The answer is no but yes.

 

[Spyxos]

I only had this on the demo disc, but i loved it.

 

[noob smokes]

Funky ass onion

 

[envyzeal]

Its all in the mind

 

[saintjules]

KICK PUNCH

 

[SomeNorseGuy]

I never did beat it, but my younger self were fascinated by this game.

Kick, punch! It's all in the mind. If you wanna test me, I'm sure you'll find. The things I teach ya is sure to beat'ya. Nevertheless you get a lesson from teacher. Now kick!

..is ingrained in my memory until the end of time.

 

[MudoSkills]

... the real best game of this general style will always be Gitaroo Man.

PaRappa to Gitaroo Man is apples to oranges in terms of gameplay. If we're opening this out to rhythm games in general then Konami was in a completely different league at this time.

 

[struggler_guts]

the real best game of this general style will always be Gitaroo Man.

 

[Bridges]

It is an all-time classic and the 4K remaster is really great too. The sequel isn't quite as good but has its moments. We need UmJammer Lammy on PS Classics ASAP

 

[KaiserBecks]

I've played it yesterday for the first time in quite a while (PS4 remake). It's fun to play and still one of my favourite games. But I have to admit, I still have no idea what's going on and how to get a "cool" rating. I play it to jam along the fantastic soundtrack, not because I want to reach some sort of high score.
Also, fuck Cheap Cheap the cooking chicken.

 

[DarkShadowXI]

I never did beat it, but my younger self were fascinated by this game.

Kick, punch! It's all in the mind. If you wanna test me, I'm sure you'll find. The things I teach ya is sure to beat'ya. Nevertheless you get a lesson from teacher. Now kick!

..is ingrained in my memory until the end of time.

You just unlocked a memory in my brain that hasn't been visited in decades. Sounds as fresh as yesterday!

 

[kpopSuperstar]

The music is amazing, the vibe and style is brilliant, but it's only a few songs and the timing on half of them is broken. I played through it 2-3 years ago and some parts are horrendous to try and get through because the timing is so off, it is absurd they shipped it like that.

 

[thicc_girls_are_teh_best]

Hell yes!!

But UmJammer Lammy is even better, and the best game in the series. Don't fight me on this; it's simply true.

...oh, also it's an IGN video. Not surprised they didn't "get" it; I don't think they even play games around there unless they're just extended tutorials. Hilarious they're saying the mechanics are "challenging"; it's literally just Simon Says set to some music. You can't memorize input patterns for 8 buttons?

Could also be them admitting they aren't comfortable with a PS controller's layout, they don't have that muscle memory. Can probably guess where they were playing games growing up then (if they played them at all ).

The music is amazing, the vibe and style is brilliant, but it's only a few songs and the timing on half of them is broken. I played through it 2-3 years ago and some parts are horrendous to try and get through because the timing is so off, it is absurd they shipped it like that.

Were you playing on emulator? I tried UmJammer back in the day on a fat PS3 and even then there were some timing issues.

Seems to me if you want accurate timing, you probably need a PS1 or maybe a PS2 to guarantee inputs are legit. Maybe one of the FPGA cores out there does an excellent job as well. And, you can always just check your emulator settings to see if something was off.

It is an all-time classic and the 4K remaster is really great too. The sequel isn't quite as good but has its moments. We need UmJammer Lammy on PS Classics ASAP

By sequel do you mean Parappa 2 or UmJammer Lammy? Because some people refer to the latter as a sequel, tho IMO it's a side game.

It wasn't fun in 1997 and it still isn't today. The scoring system is so obtuse as to feel broken.

The game is remembered for the songs and the memes, not how it plays.

i.8 million people in Japan alone disagreed/disagree with you. For context, this game sold more there than Super Mario 64 and Mario Kart 64.

Also the scoring isn't obtuse: the more presses on a bar you get right, the better your scoring. The closer on-point you get with those presses, the better your scoring.

I don't think it's very hard to grasp its scoring system; it's way simpler than some of the shmups that were out around the same time.

 

[yurinka]

Yes, it's a timeless classic still fun today

 

[Bridges]

By sequel do you mean Parappa 2 or UmJammer Lammy? Because some people refer to the latter as a sequel, tho IMO it's a side game.

I meant PaRappa 2. The music is still good but the selection is not nearly as strong as the original which is top to bottom classics in my opinion. It's also really content light, which isn't different from the first one but I would've expected a little more given the release and hardware gap.

I would love to try UmJammer Lammy but unfortunately I only know it through YouTube videos

 

[Power Pro]

I'm not going to watch it but the answer is "yes". It's pretty basic, though. Umjammer Lammy is a massively better game overall, but the real best game of this general style will always be Gitaroo Man.

 

[thicc_girls_are_teh_best]

I meant PaRappa 2. The music is still good but the selection is not nearly as strong as the original which is top to bottom classics in my opinion. It's also really content light, which isn't different from the first one but I would've expected a little more given the release and hardware gap.

I would love to try UmJammer Lammy but unfortunately I only know it through YouTube videos

Oh okay, thanks for clarifying. Yeah, Parappa 2 was a big step down; it's basically an easier game and the songs aren't as memorable (tho it has some catchy stuff for sure). I think it releasing after UmJammer made it come off worst than if UmJammer hadn't came out just a couple year earlier, IMO.

Speaking of, if you can't find a copy at a good price, there's always emulation. I had a complete disc copy of UmJammer back like a decade ago; picked it up for $10 at a flea market. Hella fun, but I shudder to think what the price for that goes for today in the collector's market :/

 

[NeoIkaruGAF]

Crack crack CRACK the EGG into the BOWL!

The disconnection between visual cues and input timing in Parappa was some of the worst BS I've ever seen. I managed to get into COOL mode just once while thinking I got the timing completely wrong. Go figure.

But I don't really care. Playing Parappa was an experience. It was fun just running through the songs like they were some kind of QTEs with severe input lag, and pressing the buttons hoping you'd get it right enough times to pass. The final stage was really bad to play, though.

But seriously, if you played this back then, you can't forget it, nor you can help loving it.

In the rain or in the snow, I got the funky flow, but now, I really got to go!

 

[Gorocketcat]

Fun is subjective. It was never fun - but it was charming as all hell and I'm glad it exists.