-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Pineapple Pizza Mafia |OT| The War On Fruit Pizza
- Thread starter Sophia
- Start date
hey_monkey
Banned
Blargonaut
Banned
You're not Ordinary, Palmer, come on. Itching to use that 1-shot Vigilante kill, aren'cha
Win condition, yeah?
give it up
It's painfully obvious you're hunting someone; your soap-operatic Taunt spam? The request for the mass Role-claim? Or was that a mass Name-claim you wanted? Hmm?
You're deliberate, you don't flail.
give up, Palmer
Just give up.
Everyone here understands you
Win condition, yeah?
give it up
It's painfully obvious you're hunting someone; your soap-operatic Taunt spam? The request for the mass Role-claim? Or was that a mass Name-claim you wanted? Hmm?
You're deliberate, you don't flail.
give up, Palmer
Just give up.
Everyone here understands you
Top townies/scummies/brownies?
If you were in my position as a confirmed town, what would you do next?
Blargonaut
Banned
I love it when you use me to soft-claim what you're not, Palmer
Tell me more, Palmer
tell me more
Also, more of your idiotic logic. Did you miss the part where I was mad as hell that people were quoting their PMs? If I was hunting someone, why would I have fought against that so vehemently until I was undercut by rules changes?
You're also now accusing me of being a town role again, despite continuing to vote for me.
I'm not currently saying you're an idiot, but you do a great impersonation of one.
Good luck town. I'm likely going to keep calling a spade a spade until Sophia decides to modkill me. Nobody is listening and half the town is absent anyway, so I'm far beyond caring now. Remember Anime and what they did wrong after I was dead. I'd still appreciate a posthumous W if people get their acts together.
By this logic sawneeks is also somebody to look at given that they voted and unvoted Sexyfish on D1
hey_monkey
Banned
I would like to remind you how your feelings about me helped get me killed in anime. It'll be the same here. So maybe let's consider for a hot sec.
And if you're against going after actives at this time why am I your exception?
Thoughts on Dr. Worm:
[Would include a cute shitty image/meme from google images but google imaging your name results in lots of pregnant furry/hentai shit. Am confused.]
Playing much more quietly than Arkham, which makes sense with his claim of being busy and his desire to not get lynched as town. That would also work in favor of mafia, too, wanting to keep a low profile, though. He bought Palmer's claim almost instantly, only elaborating on his thoughts further after hey_monkey has some questions about palmer's play-style. I think being inquisitive of Natiko isn't malicious and he's just trying to ask questions. Overall I think this is a more subdued Worm, but nothing is raising red flags at the moment.
Thoughts on hey_monkey:
Very active, trying to start the ball with people, explaining framework of GAFIA. I don't know her previous playstyle but if this is consistent I don't see anything scummy yet. Did not hop on the Palmer train right away with understandable reasoning. Would like to see some of their "heavy discussion" later on. They have a lot of fluff, but I don't think that hurts anything they've said so far. Think they are onto something questioning Blarg's pairings for the read teams. Still need more.
And finally, thoughts on Blargonaut:
I honestly have no idea what the fuck is going on with you. I like the read list idea, but everything you do is just strange. Can't get any good idea off of you at the moment.
This was Sexyfish's most substantial post, I think this is what for them nightkilled
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
This is actually a narrative I can buy into.
Look, let's face it, something weird happened with Swamped. There was a total lack of interaction with other players at day end, but she changed her vote to someone who wasn't on the chopping block until the last few moments. Either protecting BB, protecting you, or trying to buy town cred by lynching WAMD, Swamped made a decision based on outside information. She went from thinking the vote was between BB and 30, to suddenly changing to WAMD. That's weird.
But i'm "100%" "confirmed" 'town"
oreomunsta
Banned
Thank you! o/
I was pretty disappointed that no one talked about my theory after I posted it, but I'm pretty sure that's because scum is doing a good job of leading the conversation in the thread
Blargonaut
Banned
yaawwwn
Oh, I don't know.
oh, I'd say... Sawneeks
hmm. and Swamped. Natiko. 30yearsofhurt. WhereAreMahDragonz?
And acohrs too; yep these top 6 individuals are my Town. Gut feelings
SkyOdin's scum, I think. And StanleyPalmtree. Probably hey_monkey and oreomunsta too. Guessing here. Gut feelings too. Who knows about the rest, at this point
And Palmer_v1's a Power Role stalling for time, dunno his Alignment. Who cares
I think that you yourself, Lifeline, are probably RIP by Tonight or Tomorrow, sry to say. Because I think that red-text 'pineapple pizza' you got there is just a fancy mod-announced Poisoning or Arsonist-dousing from last Night, and you being mod-confirmed as Town Today is just a mercifully pleasant side-effect while you enjoy your last Day(s) in-game thread, IMO
gloat more
Think you're looking in the right place, something involving sexyfish got then nightkilled.
i'm not going after you. My vote is on blarg. I just don't think I'll make it through this day phase, so it's best to voice my niggling concern now.
hey_monkey
Banned
It was discussed. Vehemently. Someone else also posted similar. I think it's not s terrible idea but equally like the idea that it just wouldn't give us anything to go on. I think we keep track of both.
But I do think we will find at least one scum in the actives. And they'll be influencing. But I think it'll be easier to find them in a day or two since right now all the actives look pretty similar. Same log as with the inactives: can't all be scum. So we gotta watch for slips and patterns.
I'm wary of sawneeks, too good at playing scum IMO
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I'm on board for a Acorn lynch tbh
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Scum
-Oreomunsta
-Dr. Worm
-WMD
-Blargo
-Palmer
Town
-McQ
-30years
-Darryl
-Hey-Monkey
Others are pretty much null to me. Sky is the one i would feel most town if i had to pick a fith but the whole voting for Oreo without reason is just weird and random.
Believe it or not I've played mafia before. Several times even. I realize how the game works. I also realize you were seeding excuses for mislynches while simultaneously trying to justify scum reading them purely off of OMGUS.
My explanation is already out there if you can bother showing up long enough to actually play. This is probably your poorest showing so far and that's saying something when your whole schtick is shit posting instead of contributing.
hey_monkey
Banned
Why now when acorns has shown back up and is doing something? Dunno yet if it'll result in anything because it looks like he's playing catch up (and was certainly shitting up that post count for a second) but what spurred you to that move just now?
In a possible bastard game, I can't take that at face value. I'm still 99% sure you are actually town though. I'm not going to actually vote for you unless you consistently "play" badly, which I don't think you are. As I told monkey, I have to voice my concern now.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
I glazed over it tbh, so I'm just realizing this. Yes, Lifeline is probably already dead unfortunately.
hey_monkey
Banned
Which brings us back to: LL, if you got any info or anything, it'd be nice to know. Town needs info. Town runs on info.
But have you played it WELL? I've ridden a horse before but that doesn't make me a fucking cowboy. Do you really think town should avoid voting for someone unless they are 100% certain about their target? i'm sure this would go super well if we just no lynched every day until scum killed all of us.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
I'm going to hesitantly agree...
hey_monkey
Banned
Good lord, you'd think this was hurtyfeels mafia instead. We've had a feelings parade up in this (& yeah, I did it too, not excluding self).
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Because I strongly believe he's been hiding in the shadows (scum chat, whatever) and just now decided to reappear when they were talking about inactives. Feels very fake to me.
I think i decoded Blarg's secret message. I 100% agree Blarg.
I'll never get it. IRL mafia is non-stop name calling in my experience. If I actually took those games personally, I'd be a wreck. We're way too carebear for my taste.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
Do you have anything we can work with? Any messages received other than the one in the OP? PR results?
Yes, I believe I have and I'm pretty sure several others would agree. I never said we should only vote on 100% scum. I pointed out that you were hedging your bets even as you made them. You're essentially setting it up so you can jump to several different players with a vote and it be "justified" because they voted for you once. If the flip town then oops, let's move to the next on the list using the thinnest reasoning imaginable. You're yelling at town to scum hunt while using poor ustification yourself.
Still my #1 scumread. I'll move if it doesn't get off the ground, but I feel like it's the most obvious scumplay we've seen.
I think it's important to get closure somehow, of some sort, for yesterday. We're left speculating on what-ifs and hurling insults wildly without a flip, and that gets us nowhere.
Anchovies are a little iffy, granted, but I felt they fit well with pineapple; the saltiness of the anchovies and the juiciness of the pineapple provide a good contrast in flavors.
Votes on WhereAreMahDragonz from SexyFish and 30yearsofhurt are justified by her role claim, I would say. That seems fairly reasonable.
Glancing at the list, it seems as though if there's scum, we would have either:
- Natiko protecting one of WhereAreMahDragonz or BlackBuzzard
- Swamped, 30yearsofhurt, possibly Sawneeks protecting BlackBuzzard or Palmer_v1
BlackBuzzard not being one of the tied votes is intriguing to me, particularly with Swamped's switch pulling out of the tie. This is why I feel as though closure is necessary.
I'm leaning towards town on Natiko, which would mean WhereAreMahDragonz wasn't being saved (and I'm certainly not forgetting hey_monkey's post-end "vote," either). Between BlackBuzzard or Palmer_v1 for scum, you all know my money's on BlackBuzzard.
There's no real read there, though.
Lets test this theory out, we already got 3 votes on Swamped, it would be far easier to pull off than going after someone else at this point.
Monkey, I'm not voting for youyou're coming off as in between Town and scum.
Sky is a bit different, enough for me to want to put my vote down for him
This is at least half of oreomunsta's non-shitposts.
Why are you homing in so much on SkyOdin? As far as I can tell, it's literally just him throwing shade at you and a vote that aligned with hey_monkey that's responsible for all of that.
Blargonaut
Banned
Personally, if I wanted a salty pizza I'd use salt
Blargonaut
Banned
Blargonaut
Banned
I don't hold your Lawful Evil disposition against you, Palmer. It's a blessing for you
That's what worries me the most - the lack of traction for BlackBuzzard, and comparative willingness for Swamped.
I would rather confirm that BlackBuzzard is scum before moving through the people who may have been trying to protect him.
My make a wish foundation wish is to lynch Dragonz.
Yeah, and from what i heard there's no cure, so don't waste a doc on me.
Yeah, and from what i heard there's no cure, so don't waste a doc on me.
Blargonaut
Banned
Don't forget your "read teams", people
We're here to play intelligently
We're here to play intelligently
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Or confirm that im town like i have been saying for the past few pages.