That review is interesting:
"The Verges Creative Director James Bareham sides with Google on this, describing the Pixel 2 XL as the phone screen tuned most closely to professional displays: it presents natural colors in terms of photos, but is a little dark, he says. But heres the real problem: James uses truly pro equipment that nobody is trying to sell to consumers; what he thinks of as accurate, what might technically be accurate, is not what the majority of us see on most of the devices we use."
So the screen is the most accurate compared to professional editing equipment and he things that is a bad thing?