Actually, cabot, I thought this was a really well-balanced game. During it, I thought there were perhaps too many killing roles, but knowing the set-up now, I think this was actually an excellent example of how to balance killing roles well. There's a poisoner with a poison curer, which incentivizes scum to preserve poison for when they've got the poisoner, creating a risk/reward system of hoping you kill the poison curer vs. your poisoner getting lynched, and the vigilante was one-shot, which incentivizes town to preserve it until late-game when it is statisically more likely to hit scum, but not so late-game the vigilante is dead. It didn't work out like that, but I think that was because of subpar play - the actual design intent is really good. It had the right number of scum, a well thought out neutral, good flavour, balanced mafia and town roles; I'd say this was one of the best GAFIA setups to date.
