And I'm your Putin
<3
And I'm your Putin
Hahaha thank you
Looking back at my original post where I claimed knowledge, I'm pretty sure I was drunk at the time. There's a lesson here somewhere...
cab, you need to give your MVPs. I am especially interested in who got Best Neutral - tight competition there.
Yeah, analysing my own play, looking back, I needed to be a shit ton more aggressive, I think. I was overly worried that after HP, if I tried leading, people would suspect me as scum and waste a lot of time on it - that sort of happened with Ty4on this game even though I took a more laid-back role. So I was sort of a bit non-committal about really trying to drive town forward and was hoping someone else would take that role so I could slot into the picture in a more measured way. I think if I'd really taken the initiative, I could have gotten Burbeting lynched instead of Flame_AC, which at that juncture could have blown the game right open, but I was just too content to be passive. I actually didn't listen to my own advice - I was telling Ty4on the importance of not second-guessing oneself as town and then made myself play worse by second-guessing myself. Hoisted on my own petard... (as a side note for future games though, I probably will just play very aggressive regardless of my alignment ).
I also think I should have gotten Sawneeks much earlier - pretty much as soon as Kalor flipped - but I felt that Sawneeks and Burbeting were playing very similarly and moving very similarly and would probably move separately if they were scum. But in the context of that game, they didn't need to - town weren't going to call this out, and by working in tandem they herded town pretty expertly without the sort of attention that would normally bring. So it took me an extra day which I shouldn't have needed if I'd been considering the tempo of the game. It definitely wasn't one of my best games. I've not actually played any mafia really since HP so there was a lot of rust and it really showed.
Also, I need to go back and reread acohrs carefully. I thought the final scum was one of CCS/acohrs, but I couldn't quite get who it was, so well done acohrs!
I think I dropped a few hints, the most obvious being the one right at the end about splinter being proven townie. Also, the swiftness that I went on about Coppa being poisoned could have backfired, but nobody seemed to take me up on that
Sawneeks said:Two alternatives: Crab and Haly. Don't ask me 'why Haly', the idea just struck me as I was typing and my gut says it's a good idea for some reason and I like to trust my gut on these things. Crab is also a good pick: Town Read and can be the Town Leader. However, I think he has the highest likelihood of having a Doctor on him tonight and we have no idea if Poison works through a Doctor's protection.
I'm not the best in expressing my intentYeah, analysing my own play, looking back, I needed to be a shit ton more aggressive, I think. I was overly worried that after HP, if I tried leading, people would suspect me as scum and waste a lot of time on it - that sort of happened with Ty4on this game even though I took a more laid-back role. So I was sort of a bit non-committal about really trying to drive town forward and was hoping someone else would take that role so I could slot into the picture in a more measured way. I think if I'd really taken the initiative, I could have gotten Burbeting lynched instead of Flame_AC, which at that juncture could have blown the game right open, but I was just too content to be passive. I actually didn't listen to my own advice - I was telling Ty4on the importance of not second-guessing oneself as town and then made myself play worse by second-guessing myself. Hoisted on my own petard... (as a side note for future games though, I probably will just play very aggressive regardless of my alignment ).
I also think I should have gotten Sawneeks much earlier - pretty much as soon as Kalor flipped - but I felt that Sawneeks and Burbeting were playing very similarly and moving very similarly and would probably move separately if they were scum. But in the context of that game, they didn't need to - town weren't going to call this out, and by working in tandem they herded town pretty expertly without the sort of attention that would normally bring. So it took me an extra day which I shouldn't have needed if I'd been considering the tempo of the game. It definitely wasn't one of my best games. I've not actually played any mafia really since HP so there was a lot of rust and it really showed.
Also, I need to go back and reread acohrs carefully. I thought the final scum was one of CCS/acohrs, but I couldn't quite get who it was, so well done acohrs!
Sorry for tunneling so hard on you >_>Great game guys! I played primarily through mobile-GAF, so it was quite difficult to follow the timeline of events. But after Sawneeks manifesto against me, I knew she was scum. And CCS just going all in on Sawneeks made me super suspicious. I'm going to have to review each day and post more thoughts later. I must say achors played scum extremely well. I was hoping I'd have made a better case against Sawneeks, but realized that we probably would have lost the next day and I wouldn't have had any idea who to suspect as scum next. This was my first time playing online and it was quite the learning experience! Thanks for having me!
Great game guys! I played primarily through mobile-GAF, so it was quite difficult to follow the timeline of events. But after Sawneeks manifesto against me, I knew she was scum. And CCS just going all in on Sawneeks made me super suspicious. I'm going to have to review each day and post more thoughts later. I must say achors played scum extremely well. I was hoping I'd have made a better case against Sawneeks, but realized that we probably would have lost the next day and I wouldn't have had any idea who to suspect as scum next. This was my first time playing online and it was quite the learning experience! Thanks for having me!
Great game guys! I played primarily through mobile-GAF, so it was quite difficult to follow the timeline of events.
Drunk me was hoping for a counterclaim, so that I would know the person who counterclaimed is almost definitely town.Town, please
It's easy to get tunnel vision on mobile.I would recommend going through the thread on a desktop or such once a day to digest thoughts and stuff, I always find it more natural to follow threads and discussion. Mobile is for quick responses for me.
I approve. Nothing townier than claiming someone else's role.Drunk me was hoping for a counterclaim, so that I would know the person who counterclaimed is almost definitely town.
Sober me later pointed out that Beyonce could be a scum fake claim as easily as a town role.
I should have known Lord of Castamere had pre-emptively ruined this fabulous play.
Oh, and thank you LP for the wonderful flavor as always! <3
Glad you had a great time! You gave Burb and I a bit of a scare on Day 1 when you connected both of us and were able to deduce we were Scum fairly early. Unfortunately nobody really paid much attention to it but you were completely right. c:
I approve. Nothing townier than claiming someone else's role.
Think if ty4on was in the game earlier, they would have noticed the poisoning and saved coppa and that would have made it much harder.
Sorry everybody
Sorry everybody
Don't feel bad about that, I know of so many great players in this community who struggled to adjust in their first game.Sorry everybody
I missed it, not Not. It was a night action so Not didn't have the chance to submit anything.Wasn't meant to be a dig at anyone, just felt like a more experienced player would have noticed that sign better than someone with less experience. Not, this was your first game right?
Wasn't meant to be a dig at anyone, just felt like a more experienced player would have noticed that sign better than someone with less experience. Not, this was your first game right?
I missed it, not Not. It was a night action so Not didn't have the chance to submit anything.
Yeah. I guess it was an unusually slow game at first so I maybe that's why I didn't have a lot to add, plus I didn't really know what to do or what to look for. Then my thing came up, and them's the breaks. Glad Ty4on brought some much-needed life in (I'm not being sarcastic).
Damn. I just realized I edited again. Sigh. Glad the game's over.
LP turns back. "We'll see. I'm going home to play Breath of the Wild."
cabot is shocked. "Did you really just plug your next Mafia game?"
LP looks at the fourth wall. "Sure did. Sign up in January."
Sorry everybody