Practical Tools for Men to Further the Feminist Revolution

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 47027
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Deleted member 47027

Unconfirmed Member
Pamela Clark, PhD Candidate in Political Science at York University, wrote this on her blog and I thought it was worth sharing. For all of you wondering "what do I do to actually HELP" this may be helpful. Here's a few snippets - find the whole post here:
http://pamelaclark.tumblr.com/post/87113711124/35-practical-tools-for-men-to-further-feminist

2. Do 50% (or more) of emotional support work in your intimate relationships and friendships. Recognize that women are disproportionately responsible for emotional labour and that being responsible for this takes away time and energy from things they find fulfilling.

4. Give women space. Many women walk around—especially at night or while alone—feeling on edge and unsafe. Being in close physical proximity to an unknown man can exacerbate this feeling. Recognize that this is not an unreasonable fear for women to have, given how many of us have experienced harassment or abuse or been made to feel unsafe by men when we are in public spaces. Also recognize that it doesn’t matter if you are the kind of man who a woman has any actual reason to fear, because a woman on the street doesn’t have a way of knowing this about you or not.

Examples: If a seat is available on public transit next to a man, take that seat rather than one next to a woman. If you are walking outside in the dark close to a woman walking alone, cross the street so that she doesn’t have to worry someone is following her. If a woman is standing alone on a subway platform, stand some distance away from her.

5. … but insert yourself into spaces where you can use your maleness to interrupt sexism.***Examples: challenge men who make sexist comments and jokes. If you see a female friend in a bar/at a party/on the subway/wherever looking uncomfortable as a man is speaking to her, try to interject in a friendly way that offers her an opportunity for an “out” if she wants it. If you see a situation where a woman looks like she may be in distress while in the company of a man, stand nearby enough that you make yourself a physical presence, monitor the situation, and be in a position to call for help if needed.

6. When a woman tells you something is sexist, believe her.

7. Educate yourself about sexual consent and make sure there is clear, unambiguous communication of consent in all your sexual relationships.

8. Be responsible for contraception. If you are in a relationship where contraception is necessary, offer to use methods that do not have health risks for women (use of hormones, surgeries, etc.) and treat these as preferable options. If your partner prefers a particular method, let her be in charge of making that decision without questioning or complaining about it. Don’t whine about condom usage, and be responsible for buying them and having them available if that’s the method you’re using.

Assume financial responsibility for any costs related to contraception. Women earn less than men, and also have to assume all the physical risk of pregnancy. Further, in instances where contraception involves any amount of physical risk, it is virtually always women who must assume this risk. As a gesture that redresses a minuscule amount of this disparity, heterosexual men should finance the whole cost of contraceptives.

12. Pay attention to and challenge informal instances of gender role enforcement. For example, if you are at a family function or dinner party, pay attention to whether it is mostly/only women who are doing food preparation/cleaning/childcare while men are socializing and relaxing. If it is, change the dynamic and implore other men to do the same.

13. Be mindful of implicit and explicit gendered power differentials in your intimate/domestic relationships with women…whether a partner or family members or roommates. Work to recognize where inherent structural power differentials based on race, class, gender, sexual orientation, age (and so on). Where you benefit from these structural imbalances, educate yourself about your privilege and work on finding ways to create a more equitable balance of power. For example, if you are in a domestic partnership where you are the primary income earner, educate yourself about the gendered wage gap, and work on dividing labour and economic resources within your household in a way that increases the economic autonomy of your partner.

14. Make sure that honesty and respect guide your romantic and sexual relationships with women. The way you treat women with whom you are in a relationship is a mirror of your values about women in general. It doesn’t work to espouse feminist theory and then treat your partners like trash. Be upfront and open about your intentions, communicate openly so that women have the ability to make informed, autonomous decisions about what they want to do.

15. Don’t be an online bystander in the face of sexism. Challenge people who make, say, or post sexist things on the internet, especially on social media.

18. Don’t ogle or make comments about women. (i.e. Keep your tongue in your mouth and comments to yourself.) Even though women may be more prone to wearing more revealing outfits than men, don’t ogle them just because you want to and can. Though you may find someone attractive, there’s a line between noticing and being creepy/disrespectful. It makes the women being ogled feel uncomfortable, as well as any women who notice the ogling or are aware of the comments.

22. Have integrity with your male friends. (i.e. Don’t be a “bro.”) When a male friend is doing something sexist (being a deadbeat dad, down-talking women, ogling women, secretly spending shared money, lying to their partner, etc) have integrity and say something to your friend. It’s not enough to think it’s wrong; let them know you think it’s wrong.

There's SO much more at the link, I highly recommend reading it.

MOD ABUSE:
I strongly encourage people to read the FAQ that goes along with this article, as it directly addresses many of the questions and complaints I've seen so far.

http://pamelaclark.tumblr.com/post/90299280044/faq-35-practical-tools-for-men-to-further-feminist
 
I read this yesterday and considered making a thread about it but decided against it. I was talking to my girlfriend about this to ask her if I'm doing some of these already lol but she gave me a thumbs up. One thing that she was iffy on was men identifying as feminist. Is it that important for a man to actively and verbally identify as a feminist?
 
Yeah actually. It is.

If you're looking to further the feminist agenda, I don't think it is. But if you're not interested in furthering it, I can see how the list sounds like way too much.
 
I was in the past, but eventually realized that I was subconsciously doing some of these things just to impress women. I think that's probably the case with other men here too.

I wonder how much of people who parrot this stuff but don't truly BELIEVE it - whether it's overall more harmful or still helpful?
 
If you're looking to further the feminist agenda, I don't think it is. But if you're not interested in furthering it, I can see how the list sounds like way too much.

People in general should learn to be nicer. Isms all develop a 'us against them' mentality which really does no one favors. As a good friend of mine once said 'its nice to be nice'.
 
The article she mentions as being too academic has less of a condescending tone, and is, at least from my point of view, far more palatable (and actually practical).
 
I have a legitimately hard time with #22:

Have integrity with your male friends. (i.e. Don’t be a “bro.”) When a male friend is doing something sexist (being a deadbeat dad, down-talking women, ogling women, secretly spending shared money, lying to their partner, etc) have integrity and say something to your friend. It’s not enough to think it’s wrong; let them know you think it’s wrong.

It's very hard to go against the grain, but I will admit I never see my friends secretly spending shared money or being a deadbeat dad. It's tough not to join in.
 
People in general should learn to be nicer. Isms all develop a 'us against them' mentality which really does no one favors. As a good friend of mine once said 'its nice to be nice'.
I don't see how this list and feminism in general creates an us versus mentality and stops people from being nice to each other.
 
This is a good read, recommend all guys to read it. It basically shows the things women have to think about and shows how much responsibility is already put on us by default.


I completely agree with guys buying the condoms, it goes on your penis so it should be you paying, considering most women pay for birth control which is ridiculously expensive.
 
I already cross the street and avoid women at all cost while seating.

I also place a firm grip on my wallet while walking when I see them coming up the street or lock my car doors if Im at a red light in a largely feminine community.
I try my best not to make eye contact eithier, and if they wanna pussy foot while crossing the street I dont say a thing but pretend I'm adjusting my car radio.
 
A lot of these comments are "jeopardize your relationship with your male friends in order to help women who don't exist". Especially number 22. Quite a few of these are very reasonable, but I'm not going to start being judgmental of men and telling them how they should give women more respect when they both know better and are past the point of no return.

I have a friend or two I would consider sexist, but no amount of me judging them is going to magically make them change their mind about how they feel about women. That's for their parents to deal with at a much earlier time.
 
This list seems like too much for you guys? In what places is it asking you to do more than you think is necessary?

I can walk where I want to in public spaces. I can sit where I want to on public transportation. I can admire and appreciate a beautiful person in public if I want to. The list is making it seem like if you don't apply these restrictions then you are a sexist creeper.
 
I just treat women with the same kind of respect that I treat men with. I'm well aware of feminist problems (street harassment, rape culture) and just...don't do those things.

I'm sorry, but this list is nuts.

Yup, that's what I do too and I feel it's more than enough. This list is too much, in my opinion

But isn't equality the goal?

That's my problem with the list. It's not asking for equality but rather seems to ask for superior treatment. I disagree with that as I personally think equality is best
 
4. Give women space. Many women walk around—especially at night or while alone—feeling on edge and unsafe. Being in close physical proximity to an unknown man can exacerbate this feeling. Recognize that this is not an unreasonable fear for women to have, given how many of us have experienced harassment or abuse or been made to feel unsafe by men when we are in public spaces. Also recognize that it doesn’t matter if you are the kind of man who a woman has any actual reason to fear, because a woman on the street doesn’t have a way of knowing this about you or not.

Examples: If a seat is available on public transit next to a man, take that seat rather than one next to a woman. If you are walking outside in the dark close to a woman walking alone, cross the street so that she doesn’t have to worry someone is following her. If a woman is standing alone on a subway platform, stand some distance away from her.

This is bullshit.

I agree with the spirit of the list, but it comes of as patronizing.

"Nagging because you're lagging."

"Be responsible financially because of women?" You should be financially responsible for yourself. This is common sense.
 
Almost all of it is just common sense but I will not believe something is sexist because a woman tells me. I won't believe anything is anything because of the gender of the person saying it to me. You don't need to be a woman to know what's sexist and the mere implication that you do is idiotic.
 
I agree with lots of stuff on the list, but the justification for paying for a woman's contraceptives (BC, IEDs, etc.) seems like it'd be a very condescending/demeaning proposal; "Hey girl, I know that because you're a woman and that we live in a patriarchal society that means I make shit tonnes more money than you so I want to pay for your birth control pills." If my GF asked me to pay for her BC, I'd be OK with it but I'm not going to ask her because of the previously mentioned reasoning the author of this list argues. I'll happily pay for condoms though.
 
This is bullshit.

I agree with the spirit of the list, but it comes of as patronizing.

"Nagging because you're lagging."

"Be responsible financially because of women? You should be financially responsible for yourself. This is common sense."

Yup, I don't see how you dismantle patriarchy by being patronizing. This list has a very negative tone.
 
The reaction in this thread to the 'give women space' list item makes me realize how nice it must be to go out in public alone without that consant fear. And then I get sad because I'm never going to be able have that. I can only hope my daughter will.
 
I don't see how this list and feminism in general creates an us versus mentality and stops people from being nice to each other.

Radical feminists are pretty gross people. Most 'movements' in general have an element that can be potentially marginalizing and off putting. But that's a different thread.I think the list has some valid points that are worth considering, some though don't even register as specifically feminist issues. As Vince stated above, the dont be a bro thing to me isn't a feminist issue. Being a deadbeat dad or cheating etc are all more 'im going to mind my own business' issues rather than 'im going to take a stance to help further the cause of feminism'.
 
I can walk where I want to in public spaces. I can sit where I want to on public transportation. I can admire and appreciate a beautiful person in public if I want to. The list is making it seem like if you don't apply these restrictions then you are a sexist creeper.
I'm not sure I'm following. In the article it's basically saying to respect others and their personal space especially that of a woman considering the precedent of woman being harassed and sexually assaulted in society. It's really not that hard of a thing to do. Respecting someone's space? You're not having you rights infringed upon here.
 
The reaction in this thread to the 'give women space' list item makes me realize how nice it must be to go out in public alone without that consant fear. And then I get sad because I'm never going to be able have that. I can only hope my daughter will.
Learning that many women carry their keys in their hands (for personal defense if needed) when walking late at night was pretty eye opening.
 
The reaction in this thread to the 'give women space' list item makes me realize how nice it must be to go out in public alone without that consant fear. And then I get sad because I'm never going to be able have that. I can only hope my daughter will.

I'll clarify for myself.

But regarding public transportation, I'm not going to look around before I take I seat just because of the person next to me is another gender. If there bus or train is near empty, I will sit as far from any person, man or women, because I like the personal space. This actually happens naturally in places with public transportation. Patrons space out in more empty buses and trains. But when the bus/train is crowded, unless you're reeking I'm going to sit next you if a seat is available--man or woman.

That was my beef.

Regarding empty streets, I really can't relate with that much living in NYC. Maybe if a lived in another locale, dark empty streets would be prevalent. I'll give you that. I avoid empty dark streets in general after being mugged.
 
Eh, I treat everyone about the same, I try and keep aware of all the people around me's circumstance and I think that's okay. My best friend, who is a woman, I think would have problems with items on this list and I would never apply it to her, so I dunno. I feel it's better to get to know people to learn how they want to be treated, or ask than narrowly working off a list.
 
3. Consume cultural products produced by women. In whatever your interests are—French cinema, astrophysics, baseball, birdwatching—ensure that women’s voices and women’s cultural products are represented in what you are consuming. If they are not, make an effort to seek them out.
]

uhhh what? so buy stuff i might not like, just because of who makes it. got it.

4. Give women space.

yeah....unless you are an elderly person or pregnant or handicapped, i'm sitting where It's more convenient. I can't take into account everyone's paranoia in a public space. I can be accommodating if i know you on a personal level, i might even nudge farther out into the streets if we are walking on the same sidewalk. but come on, that's too much being put on men.

5. … but insert yourself into spaces where you can use your maleness to interrupt sexism.***Examples: challenge men who make sexist comments and jokes. If you see a female friend in a bar/at a party/on the subway/wherever looking uncomfortable as a man is speaking to her, try to interject in a friendly way that offers her an opportunity for an “out” if she wants it. If you see a situation where a woman looks like she may be in distress while in the company of a man, stand nearby enough that you make yourself a physical presence, monitor the situation, and be in a position to call for help if needed.

makes sense.

6. When a woman tells you something is sexist, believe her.

but wat do if another woman tells me it's not sexist <_> WHO DO I BELIEVE? and only women determine when something is sexist?

8. Be responsible for contraception. If you are in a relationship where contraception is necessary, offer to use methods that do not have health risks for women (use of hormones, surgeries, etc.) and treat these as preferable options. If your partner prefers a particular method, let her be in charge of making that decision without questioning or complaining about it. Don&#8217;t whine about condom usage, and be responsible for buying them and having them available if that&#8217;s the method you&#8217;re using.

SO she picks the contraceptives, makes the decisions of which to use, and you just have no say in the manner except to pay for it? EQUALITY

10. Have progressive name politics. If you and your female partner decide that the institution of marriage is something you want to be involved with, be willing to both keep your existing surnames. If having a common surname with your spouse is important to you, be willing to change your surname and treat this as a preferable option to your spouse changing hers.

Yeah....no. I think people should be free to decide if they want to keep their names or change them. Making it so that the only choices are KEEP YOUR ORIGINAL OR CHANGE IT TO YOUR WIVE'S is...err.

12. Pay attention to and challenge informal instances of gender role enforcement. For example, if you are at a family function or dinner party, pay attention to whether it is mostly/only women who are doing food preparation/cleaning/childcare while men are socializing and relaxing. If it is, change the dynamic and implore other men to do the same.

this is commendable.

20. Ensure that some of your heroes and role models are women.

uhh.... i think that's more of a personal thing. Respect and admiration is not something that i think you can just switch on and off.

22. Have integrity with your male friends. (i.e. Don&#8217;t be a &#8220;bro.&#8221;) When a male friend is doing something sexist (being a deadbeat dad, down-talking women, ogling women, secretly spending shared money, lying to their partner, etc) have integrity and say something to your friend. It&#8217;s not enough to think it&#8217;s wrong; let them know you think it&#8217;s wrong.

I think this applies to women as well right?

23. Don&#8217;t treat your spouse like a &#8220;nag.&#8221; If she is &#8220;nagging,&#8221; you are probably lagging.

:/

35. Self-identify as a feminist. Speak about feminism as a natural, normal, uncontentious belief, because it should be. Don&#8217;t hedge and use terms like &#8220;humanist&#8221; or &#8220;feminist ally&#8221; that reinforce the idea that the F-word itself is a scary word.

:/

everything else is common sense or should be at least.
 
#33 is kind of weird. What if I work in an industry that specifically pays women an equal amount for an equal job?
 
Radical feminists are pretty gross people. Most 'movements' in general have an element that can be potentially marginalizing and off putting. But that's a different thread.I think the list has some valid points that are worth considering, some though don't even register as specifically feminist issues. As Vince stated above, the dont be a bro thing to me isn't a feminist issue. Being a deadbeat dad or cheating etc are all more 'im going to mind my own business' issues rather than 'im going to take a stance to help further the cause of feminism'.
Well if you judge every moment and political ideology by its extremists I can see how you would come to that conclusion but there should be nothing inherently marginalizing or off putting about a movement which at it's core promotes egalitarianism for all peoples or genders.
 
That's not what I'm asking though. Is it important for us to walk the walk and talk the talk ie verbally identify as feminist?

If the issue is that "feminist" is a tainted word you don't want to brand yourself with, then I wonder if people do need to see sensible non-stereotypes representing the name.

Almost all of it is just common sense but I will not believe something is sexist because a woman tells me. I won't believe anything is anything because of the gender of the person saying it to me. You don't need to be a woman to know what's sexist and the mere implication that you do is idiotic.

So you never listen to feedback people give you? Are surveys useless to you?

This is pretty much exactly the sentiment that frustrates and drives women on NeoGAF away from discussions like this. If you're not willing to listen to their perspective, and think you clearly know what's what about something you don't live through, then why should they even bother participating in threads like this?
 
It's funny, I like or love most of the ideals of feminism but hate the term. I'm for all people regardless of gender. Feminists always try to tell me that by bringing up women you're raising us all, but then why go for the confrontational label?

The nagging one is the only thing I have any true issue with. No, she probably is nagging you. It's likely because you have different priorities but nagging is nagging.
 
I just keep my head down when I see women as I know there's nothing I have that can be lorded over them and bring them to submit to me, which is what a relationship is, two bullies reciprocating pain, as laughter is pain, everyoneis happy at my expense,laughing at me.
Now I'll just frontflip into a bush or lake if I happen to notice one detects my presence. Oh, also can't forget to stop breathing as it can indicate I'm a threat.
 
4 to me seems to swing the pendulum too far in the opposite direction. It's right up there with people uneasy with men around children.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom