Of course there's a limit to how tall is "good tall" before it becomes freak of nature tall. I woulndt want to be super tall either. Definitely not so tall id have to duck under the average American doorway. 6'2" to 6'5" max would be nice. I'm right at 6' or 5'11" now.One of my friends is quite tall and he has hella bad back problems. He also ducks in doorways. Not something that he values that much it seems, but other people do. Shrug.
I couldn't imagine being a short person though. I wouldn't really put stock into what dating profiles say but ignoring that there is a definite real life prejudice against little dudes. Tom cruise is Tom fucking cruise and I wouldn't want to be him (body wise).