does it count as cheating in the witness if i look up a guide for solutions of puzzles i've already cleared since i don't want to backtrack all the way there to remember how those puzzles worked?
even as someone that likes mafia 1, i feel like this is probably accurateYou can certainly ignore this advice, but as someone who played both Mafia and Mafia II last year I would highly recommend skipping the first game. It doesn't hold up very well given that so many open world games have come out since that time. First of all, outside of I believe 2 missions, the driving in the game has no purpose whatsoever. You drive to a mission and get a checkpoint. There are no side activities to do in the city, so all the driving does is artificially extend the playtime. The shooting is also extremely dated and makes the missions pretty frustrating. I honestly consider this one of the worst games I've ever played - maybe if I had played it on release my opinion would be different, but games don't exist in a vacuum.
Mafia II is still worth playing at least. The driving is still not all that important but there are a couple of side activities and the driving model is a lot more fun. The beginning of the game takes place in winter and they actually modeled snow driving in the city pretty well. You also get a more modern cover shooting mechanic.
There is one reference to the first game in Mafia II but if you watch the end cinematic from Mafia you'll understand it when it happens.