Super Smash Bros. for 3DS & Wii U Thread XI: Where 90% correct equals 100% wrong

Status
Not open for further replies.
Does the Terminator movies predict the future of Smash!

Does this confirm the table is entering smash?

No, sorry, its the chair.
Is that tweet real? That's a pretty funny coincidence, but totally believable.

Edit: noticed the Twitter handle a little after posting. Oh well, still cool even if arranged.
 
The idea of cutting the Ice Climbers strikes me as absurd. They're so unique and have worked just fine since Melee. Also, we've seen the polar bear and the eggplant icon. Unless there's some insurmountable technical reason they can't be in, I think they'd be back, since Sakurai values unique and fun ideas above all, and they epitomize this.

So that really weakens the believability of the "leak," although in fairness there appear to be several versions of the same leak by several different people, which line up in various ways, so maybe there's a bit of truth to some and utter falsehood in others.

When/Where did we see the Eggplant icon?
 
actually fuck the alt colors thing i'll just make a ton of unlisted pastebin posts that say "the next character to be revealed is so-and-so" and if any of them come true i'll only show that one and say my insider buddy sent it to me

i'll be a prophet in no time
 
This is what Sakurai said about the Ice Climbers back in 2013:
On the topic of the roster, Sakurai noted that the 3DS version of the game, with its hardware’s technical limitations, would likely keep the volume of the roster in check, though no characters had been cut so far, and any determination to that effect is a ways away. Which characters ultimately are included will be the result of careful consideration, ranging from which fighters have unique characteristics, equally representing franchises and how signature traits carry over well from previous games like Brawl. Sakurai did tell me that “multiple character” combatants like the Ice Climbers were proving a technical challenge on the 3DS.
http://www.ign.com/articles/2013/07/03/creating-super-smash-bros-for-wii-u-and-3ds?page=1
 
This seems like the more likely scenario. Those leaked colors were posted June 6, right? That's less than a week before E3, so it's certainly possible that he saw the demo ahead of time. That right there would explain away the only real evidence he has for his leak. Without any independent reasons to think he actually worked on the game, I'm pretty confident he only saw the demo.

Upload date: June 5. Several people had early access to the E3 booths, and Smash is right there.
Exactly like they were able to take a picture of Mario Maker before its reveal, they were able to play the latest Smash demo.

That's the upload date, the image was apparently created before that so it could be before the reasonable E3 leak period, though I can't find anything about the creation date in the EXIF data.
 
The Koopalings are all completely different sized from one another, let alone compared to Bowser Jr. Sakurai has already said that even slight differences will make a character separate.
 
I like how most of the leaks say "There will be a character reveal (either veteran or newcomer) this week!" because one of them is going to get lucky since time is counting down.
 
I should make my own leak, been right all week.

Whenever I rattle off info I just say "my preferred roster" rather than "what I expect to end up in Smash." My ideal roster and tempered expectation roster are two totally different things. I mean, if I had snuck my ideal roster in as a purported leak, people would be so upset, holy shit.
 
Nearing the end of the newcomer trailers, rather

Note there can be multiple newcomers per trailer

But yeah, I'm only letting myself expect two more newcomers
That would be so lame if they would not highlight each newcomer in their own style.
 
Whenever I rattle off info I just say "my preferred roster" rather than "what I expect to end up in Smash." My ideal roster and tempered expectation roster are two totally different things. I mean, if I had snuck my ideal roster in as a purported leak, people would be so upset, holy shit.
Tell me your ideal roster :3
 
this is just why Ice Climbers are likely untouched, rosalina and luma works somewhat the same way after all, doubt they haven't found a work around for ice climbers

If nana's AI is too much, there are solutions, like dumbing her down, or not allowing desync (which might ruin competitive ice climbers) and having nana have no need to recover (teleports to you if she gets too far away) so that the AI doesn't have to be as smart.
 
Anyone else feel like Bowser Jr. and the Koopalings are in no way cut out for Smash as individual characters? At that point I'd feel like it would be a desperation move to try and fill up the roster. I mean, Mario Kart is one thing since their inclusion mostly involves changing kart stat dynamics and giving your kart a face, but I feel like it'd be Melee clones-over-dedede levels of waste of valuable time and resources.

I also feel like while some characters are outright villains that have the capacity to hold their own (Bowser, Ganondorf, etc), in actual combat (so not karting) the Koopa Kids and Bowser Jr. have been more "villain victims" than anything. All you have to do is hit them thrice, and you win.
 
To the guy who asked -- wasn't the eggplant icon shown alongside Polar Bear in one of the Smash Run trailers? I may be misremembering...

On a side note, while I don't quite believe the leak, I love the idea of Duck Hunt Dog and a Koopa Clown Car where Bowser Jr. and the Koopalings are alts in the cockpit.

These are now my DLC requests, if nothing else, lol
 
Anyone else feel like Bowser Jr. and the Koopalings are in no way cut out for Smash as individual characters? At that point I'd feel like it would be a desperation move to try and fill up the roster. I mean, Mario Kart is one thing since their inclusion mostly involves changing kart stat dynamics and giving your kart a face, but I feel like it'd be Melee clones-over-dedede levels of waste of valuable time and resources.

If all the koopalings were in smash bros., they better as hell be different from each other.

That would be disastrous.
 
Anyone else feel like Bowser Jr. and the Koopalings are in no way cut out for Smash as individual characters? At that point I'd feel like it would be a desperation move to try and fill up the roster. I mean, Mario Kart is one thing since their inclusion mostly involves changing kart stat dynamics and giving your kart a face, but I feel like it'd be Melee clones-over-dedede levels of waste of valuable time and resources.

I also feel like while some characters are outright villains that have the capacity to hold their own (Bowser, Ganondorf, etc), in actual combat (so not karting) the Koopa Kids and Bowser Jr. have been more "villain victims" than anything. All you have to do is hit them thrice, and you win.

I'm good with Mario characters at this point, unless they add Paper Mario which is pretty much its own thing. Bowser Jr. would be a resounding meh from me.
 
Anyone else feel like Bowser Jr. and the Koopalings are in no way cut out for Smash as individual characters? At that point I'd feel like it would be a desperation move to try and fill up the roster. I mean, Mario Kart is one thing since their inclusion mostly involves changing kart stat dynamics and giving your kart a face, but I feel like it'd be Melee clones-over-dedede levels of waste of valuable time and resources.

The way it's been worded in that "leak", they're not individual characters, it just alt costumes that changes which koopaling is inside the koopa clown car which has the little bubble over it which would be the hitbox rather than the koopaling themself.


Honestly I love the idea as a way to implement the koopalings, they're all great classic mario characters and I would have rather had them than rosalina or paper mario, just because a clown car moveset sounds like a lot of fun.
 
I wouldn't mind Bowser Jr. He's certainly become a central Mario antagonist since Sunshine. I could see moves with the paintbrush, the clown car, and maybe a few moves similar to Squirtle with his shell as a small "turtle" character.
 
Anyone else feel like Bowser Jr. and the Koopalings are in no way cut out for Smash as individual characters? At that point I'd feel like it would be a desperation move to try and fill up the roster. I mean, Mario Kart is one thing since their inclusion mostly involves changing kart stat dynamics and giving your kart a face, but I feel like it'd be Melee clones-over-dedede levels of waste of valuable time and resources.

I also feel like while some characters are outright villains that have the capacity to hold their own (Bowser, Ganondorf, etc), in actual combat (so not karting) the Koopa Kids and Bowser Jr. have been more "villain victims" than anything. All you have to do is hit them thrice, and you win.
The way the Koopalings are presented in this leak, they're fighting from inside the Koopa Clown Car, possibly with the glass dome over the cockpit, which means that it's the car that's doing all of the fighting, presumably with its propeller, boxing gloves, Bullet Bills, Bob-ombs -- maybe even those steel wrecking balls it could turn upside-down to drop. It'd also be fun to see Mecha Koopas -- always loved those lil' guys. So yeah, I could see how it could work, in theory, since they'd all share the same hit-box. It'd require a lot of work to model all of the different Koopalings and their various reactions inside the car, but the car itself would be the one attacking and taking damage, and the car would only need to be designed once. It's a fun idea, if nothing else.
 
The way it's been worded in that "leak", they're not individual characters, it just alt costumes that changes which koopaling is inside the koopa clown car which has the little bubble over it which would be the hitbox rather than the koopaling themself.


Honestly I love the idea as a way to implement the koopalings, they're all great classic mario characters.

If it's true, then the character might not be called 'bowser jr.' It might switch as you change costumes, OR, the character itself is just called "Koopa Clown Car" or whatever, and then the rider changes.

180px-Bowserjr_NSMBU.png


100px-Trophy210.PNG


I assume it would just hover at low height and use boxing gloves for melee attacks. Neutral B could be throwing out mechaKoopas. Final smash might be dropping the giant canonballs.
 
If nana's AI is too much, there are solutions, like dumbing her down, or not allowing desync (which might ruin competitive ice climbers) and having nana have no need to recover (teleports to you if she gets too far away) so that the AI doesn't have to be as smart.

that and other performance issues, imagine 4 Ice climbers at once on a 3DS, we had slow-downs in the Wii when that happened, I guess the Wii U version can do just fine, but that would make Ice Climbers exclusives, a no-no for Sakurai
 
Tell me your ideal roster :3

Posted it a few days ago.

It'd be neat if a majority of the Smash franchises with playable reps each had a possible boss in Adventure Mode. That is, depending on the path you take, it could pit you against the boss of the character of the franchise whose character you're playing as. That's a place I could totally see the Koopalings and Bowser Jr. working effectively. It'd also allow you to specifically tune enemies with counters to said character's playstyles, for example King Hippo versus Little Mac, Ridley, etc.
 
If nana's AI is too much, there are solutions, like dumbing her down, or not allowing desync (which might ruin competitive ice climbers) and having nana have no need to recover (teleports to you if she gets too far away) so that the AI doesn't have to be as smart.

I don't know how this has even been spun into a potential cause for removal. Game AI typically isn't "artificial intelligence". In Nana's case, it's a set of rules and corner cases to abide by. Simple logic, like:

If not attacking, and not in attack cooldown, move towards Popo on the X-Axis, then on the Y
If near Popo, mirror his movements on a frame delay

Citing this sort of thing as the reason for their potential removal is absolutely ridiculous. Logic like that is NES stuff. If anything, Sakurai was referring to the higher vertex count in comparison with other characters, or more likely, the difficulty in distinguishing 8 individual Ice Climbers running around on a 3DS-sized screen, in addition to whatever assist trophies and pokeballs may be active.
 
that and other performance issues, imagine 4 Ice climbers at once on a 3DS, we had slow-downs in the Wii when that happened, I guess the Wii U version can do just fine, but that would make Ice Climbers exclusives, a no-no for Sakurai

You could argue that 4 rosalinas, or 4 olimars might do that, too. It's very likely the 3DS is the reason Olimar only has 3 pikmin now.

As long as their character models are simple enough, the 3DS can more than likely handle all 8 of them at the same time. I can't imagine the poly count is that different from 4 olimar. If anything, it's the AI that would cause issues, I think. Considering that pikmin are smart enough to pick up items and return them to you, I don't think nana's AI should be an issue. If it is, they can either optimize it or dumb it down.

Nana's AI definitely isn't that complicated, but if it's not really optimized, it could cause issues, but I really really doubt it, because she's as simple as a pikmin or a luma. If the game can handle them, they can handle nana.
 
To the guy who asked -- wasn't the eggplant icon shown alongside Polar Bear in one of the Smash Run trailers? I may be misremembering...

On a side note, while I don't quite believe the leak, I love the idea of Duck Hunt Dog and a Koopa Clown Car where Bowser Jr. and the Koopalings are alts in the cockpit.

These are now my DLC requests, if nothing else, lol

Was the polar bear they shown in a trailer? I thought it was only one screenshot that wasn't a pic of the day?
 
I'll believe Ice Climbers are cut when the game comes out and they are cut. No time earlier.

Does the Terminator movies predict the future of Smash!
Even the hardest of hardcore fans burned by Brawl would struggle to properly argue it is in any way comparable to fucking Terminator 3.

Although there was that comparison between Sakurai and George Lucas earlier,
 
You could argue that 4 rosalinas, or 4 olimars might do that, too. It's very likely the 3DS is the reason Olimar only has 3 pikmin now.

As long as their character models are simple enough, the 3DS can more than likely handle all 8 of them at the same time. I can't imagine the poly count is that different from 4 olimar. If anything, it's the AI that would cause issues, I think. Considering that pikmin are smart enough to pick up items and return them to you, I don't think nana's AI should be an issue. If it is, they can either optimize it or dumb it down.

Nana's AI definitely isn't that complicated, but if it's not really optimized, it could cause issues, but I really really doubt it, because she's as simple as a pikmin or a luma. If the game can handle them, they can handle nana.

I would think Popo + Nana's polycount would be a higher polycount than Rosalina + Luma and Olimar + 3 pikmin, plus they have spammable projectiles and particle effects with the ice wind and iceberg toss.


I mean, I don't want to argue for the removal of ICs, but I really do think the 3DS might end up screwing us on this one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom