Support NeoGAF

[Yka]

1. Game of the Year - Resident Evil 4
Runner Up - Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan!

2. Best Visuals - Resident Evil 4
Runner - Shadow of the Colossus

3. Best Audio - Killer 7
Runner Up - Castlevania: Curse of Darkness

4. Best Gameplay - Resident Evil 4
Runner Up - Donkey Kong: Jungle Beat

5. Biggest surprise - Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan!
Runner Up - Donkey Kong: Jungle Beat

6. Biggest Disappointment - Conker: Live & Reloaded
Runner Up - Star Fox: Assault

 

[Son of Godzilla]

1. Game of the Year - Resident Evil 4 (Shadow of the Colossus)
2. Best Visuals - Call of Duty 2 (Guild Wars)
3. Best Audio - Shadow of the Colossus (Advance Wars: Dual Strike)
4. Best Gameplay - Meteos (Resident Evil 4)
5. Biggest surprise - Ouendan! (Trauma Center: Under The Knife)
6. Biggest Disappointment - Kirby: Canvas Curse (Starfox Assault)

 

[captain_amazo]

1. Game of the Year - Resident Evil 4
Runner Up - Shadow of the Colossus

2. Best Visuals - Resident Evil 4 (GC)
Runner Up- Splinter Cell Chaos Theory (XB)

3. Best Audio - Shadow of the Colossus
Runner Up - GTA LCS

4. Best Gameplay - Devil May Cry 3
Runner Up - Resident Evil 4

5. Biggest surprise - God of War
Runner Up - GTA LCS

6. Biggest Disappointment - Jade Empire
Runner Up - The Movies

 

[GoutPatrol]

1. Resident Evil 4
Runner Up-God of War

2. Project Gotham Racing 3
Runner Up-Resident Evil 4

3. Lumines
Runner Up-Dragon Quest VIII

4. Resident Evil 4
Runner Up-Lumines

5. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
Runner Up-Super Mario Strikers

6. Gunstar Super Heroes
Runner Up-Lunar: Dragon Song

 

[RiZ III]

1. Game of the Year - Resident Evil 4
runner up: SotC

2. Best Visuals - Resident Evil 4
runner up: SotC

3. Best Audio - SotC for intro and epilogue music. Haunting.

4. Best Gameplay - Resident Evil 4 (only game ive gone through 4 times)

5. Biggest surprise - Resident Evil 4 (didn't think it would be half as good as it turned out to be)

6. Biggest Disappointment - One Piece Grand Battle (english voice actors ruined it)

 

[Solid]

GOTY
1. God of War
Runner up: Winning Eleven 9/Pro Evo Soccer 5
VISUALS
2. God of War
Runner up: Gran Turismo 4
AUDIO
3. God of War
Runner up: Metal Gear Solid 3 (PAL version)
GAMEPLAY
4. Resident Evil 4
Runner up: Prince of Persia: The Two Thrones
SURPRISE
5. God of War
Runner up: Lumines
DISAPPOINTMENT
6. Gran Turismo 4
Runner up: Soul Calibur III

 

[EternalDarko]

1. Game of the Year: Resident Evil 4
Runner up: Shadow of the Colossus

2. Best Visuals: Resident Evil 4
Runner up: Shadow of the Colossus

3. Best Audio: Shadow of the Colossus
Runner up: Killer7

4. Best Gameplay: Resident Evil 4
Runner up: Mario Kart DS

5. Biggest surprise: DK: Jungle Beat
Runner up: God of War

6. Biggest Dissapointment: Kameo
Runner up: GT4 online/GT Mobile lies

 

[Miroku]

1. Game of the Year: Resident Evil 4
Runner up: Ninja Gaiden Black

2. Best Visuals: Oddworld: Strangers Wrath
Runner up: Resident Evil 4

3. Best Audio: Oddworld: Strangers Wrath
Runner up: Burnout Revenge

4. Best Gameplay: Ninja Gaiden Black
Runner up: God of War

5. Biggest surprise: Resident Evil 4 (complete re-invention of the franchise, gg capcom)
Runner up: God of War

6. Biggest Dissapointment: Soul Calibur 3
Runner up: America's Army: Rise of a Solder

 

[JasoNsider]

Game of the Year: RE4
RunnerUp: Shadow of the Colossus

Best Visuals: RE4
RunnerUp: Shadow of the Colossus

Best Audio: RE4
RunnerUp: Killer7

Best Gameplay: RE4
RunnerUp: Wario Ware: Twisted

Biggest Surprise: RE4
RunnerUp: Killer7

Biggest Dissapointment: Starfox
RunnerUp: God of War

 

[Sho Nuff]

Game of the Year: Spikeout: Battle Street
RunnerUp: Trackmania Sunrise

Best Visuals: Spikeout: Battle Street
RunnerUp: Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory

Best Audio: Spikeout: Battle Street
RunnerUp: Lumines

Best Gameplay: Spikeout: Battle Street
RunnerUp: Burnout Revenge

Biggest Surprise: Spikeout: Battle Street
RunnerUp: Streets of Fire

Biggest Dissapointment: Ouendan
RunnerUp: Resident Evil 4

 

[Catchpenny]

Don't own a PSP or X360 yet, so not voting on any of those games.

1. Game of the Year: Resident Evil 4 | Runner Up: Dragon Quest VIII
2. Best Visuals: Resident Evil 4 | Runner Up: Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory
3. Best Audio: Shadow of the Colossus | Runner Up: Killer 7
4. Best Gameplay: Resident Evil 4 | Runner Up: Civilization IV
5. Biggest Surprise: Phoenix Wright | Runner Up: Indigo Prophecy
6. Biggest Dissapointment: Suikoden IV | Runner Up: Psychonauts

 

[ToyMachine228]

1. Game of the Year- Resident Evil 4
Runner Up- God of War

2. Best Visuals- Resident Evil 4
Runner Up- Splinter Cell Chaos Theory

3. Best Audio- God of War
Runner Up- Resident Evil 4

4. Best Gameplay- Resident Evil 4
Runner Up- Donkey Kong: Jungle Beat

5. Biggest Surprise- King Kong
Runner Up- Killer 7

6. Biggest Disappointment- Jade Empire
Runner Up- Conker: Live & Reloaded

 

[Kuroyume]

1. Game of the Year.
RESIDENT EVIL 4
RUNNER UP: SPLINTER CELL: CT

2. Best Visuals.
RESIDENT EVIL 4
RUNNER UP: SPLINTER CELL: CT

3. Best Audio.
SPLINTER CELL: CT
RUNNER UP: RESIDENT EVIL 4

4. Best Gameplay.
SPLINTER CELL: CT
RESIDENT EVIL 4

5. Biggest surprise.
PHANTOM DUST
RUNNER UP: ?

6. Biggest Disappointment.
?
?

Cut me some slack with the ? I have only played three full games this year. The rest were demos.

 

[Chony]

1. Game of the Year. - Resident Evil 4
Runner Up - Half Life 2
2. Best Visuals. - Resident Evil 4
Runner Up - Half Life 2
3. Best Audio. - Resident Evil 4
Runner Up - Half Life 2
4. Best Gameplay. - Resident Evil 4
Runner Up - Half Life 2

 

[Prospero]

1. Game of the Year: Guitar Hero
Runner Up: Advance Wars: Dual Strike

2. Best Visuals: Digital Devil Saga 1+2
Runner Up: We Love Katamari

3. Best Audio: Guitar Hero
Runner Up: Advance Wars: Dual Strike

4. Best Gameplay: Guitar Hero
Runner Up: Advance Wars: Dual Strike

5. Biggest Surprise: Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney

6. Biggest Disappointment: Trauma Center: Under the Knife

 

[Forsete]

1. Game of the Year: God of War
Runner Up: F.E.A.R

2. Best Visuals: God of War
Runner Up: Battlefield 2

3. Best Audio: Battlefield 2
Runner Up: Splinter Cell Chaos Theory [PC]

4. Best Gameplay: God of War
Runner Up: Lumines

5. Biggest surprise: Quake 4
Runner Up: WipeOut Pure

6. Biggest Disappointment: GUN
Runner Up: Civilisation 4

 

[DCX]

1. Game of the Year.
- God of War
rp- Resident Evil 4
2. Best Visuals.
- Resident Evil 4
rp- God of War
3. Best Audio.
- God of War
rp-Shadow of the Colossus
4. Best Gameplay.
- God of War
rp-Resident Evil 4
5. Biggest surprise.
- God of War
rp- Shadow of Colossus
6. Biggest Disappointment.
- Madden 06-360
rp- 360 Launch

DCX

 

[worldrunover]

1. Game of the Year - Resident Evil 4 (GC)
Runner Up: God of War (PS2)

2. Best Visuals - Project Gotham Racing 3 (X360)
Runner Up: Resident Evil 4 (GC)

3. Best Audio - Shadow of the Colossus (PS2)
Runner Up: Fire Emblem (GC)

4. Best Gameplay - Resident Evil 4 (GC)
Runner Up: Zelda: The Minish Cap (GBA)

5. Biggest surprise - Kirby Canvas Curse (NDS)
Runner Up: Phoenix Wright (NDS)

6. Biggest Disappointment - Soulcalibur III (PS2)
Runner Up: Advance Wars (GC)