If everyone was an ordinary at the start, the only item that could've been Godfather was the laptop. Iirc all other prizes before Star checked Sawneeks have gone to known town members. This raises a great problem: uncertainty. While Oceanic's statement that the mason he found did not vote for Dusk could work if he won a Godfather item, gave it to scum buddy Sawneeks and then revealed Sawneeks as a mason, there is an another thing that was a complete guess. Oceanic's second scan was Karkador and Oceanic claimed he saw nothing but an Ordinary. Karkador did not dispute this.
Thus, it is then required that Karkador is scum too, otherwise scum would have to guess, based on nothing (because everyone was an ordinary at the start, that was the premise, they could have no other items at this point), who had no items at that point. They had the chances though, since they'd just have to avoid the one other existing item holder at the time. If scum team has four members in it, the chance was 1/12 or 8,333...% to hit the only bad scenario. If they had hit the item holder, the item holder might've kept quiet or revealed themselves, making them a easy kill for scum. Godfather scum team is then Oceanic, Kark, Sawneeks.
For the record, I do not support this idea. It's problem is that if everyone can win items, what use does town have for a Godfather? That just makes no sense. The price mechanic would be stupid if this was the case.
The alternative is that scum had the Godfather right from the start. We can't disprove this straight out because we've only flipped one scum so far. But it seems almost certain that scum could win items. Had scum won the alignment cop, what use would've the Godfather been? Nearly nothing, while there might be some absurd theoretical cases out there, Godfather would've been useless had scum won the alignment cop. Why then put a Godfather in the game, if it could end up being useless? I don't think certain items are earmarked for town, that'd just make the bidding mechanic a pointless smokescreen. This alternative seems just stupid to me. Unless someone else figures out a way for the Godfather to exist, there shouldn't be one.
