Support NeoGAF

[Wallach]

Tagalongs are top tier for sure. Samoas and Thin Mints fighting for a distant second place.

 

[Kitsunebaby]

Hell yeah, they are! I was a girl scout for 7 years, all just so I could have easier access to those cookies.

 

[ronito]

As usual I'm travelling this week. My wife surprised me by putting a sleeve of thin mints in my luggage. Aw yeah. Best wife.

 

[Zod the Bear]

Thin mints were my #1, but samoas may have eclipsed them. It's close.

Both fall behind snickerdoodles.

Spoiler

Whoever wins, my arteries lose.

 

[PsychoSoldier]

Tagalongs are the best, along with the Dulce de Leche ones and the lemon flavored ones dusted with sugar.

I just wish they made at least one gluten-free variety

 

[dekline]

Samoas>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Seriously. Samoas or nothing.

 

[UrbanRats]

I don't get that packaging, are the cookies made out of dirt? Why would you put that image on it?

 

[akira28]

Thin Mints are by far the best Girl Scout cookies, though I had Lemonades a couple years ago and they were close. However, the Andes Creme de Menthe cookies absolutely destroy Thin Mints. They're amazing.

This.
Thin Mints not so great. ThankUBerryMunch God tier.
Lemonades also better. And so are Cabana Cremes.

 

[Giard]

Chocolate + Mint = Worst combination ever. I dunno how people can manage to like it.

After Eights are the worst of them all. Ugh.

 

[FO-totality]

peanut butter patties > all

preach it, brother!

 

[Lambtron]

Chocolate + Mint = Worst combination ever. I dunno how people can manage to like it.

After Eights are the worst of them all. Ugh.

Whuuuuut. Do you hate peanut butter & jelly too? Hamburgers and bacon?

 

[Delio]

Chocolate + Mint = Worst combination ever. I dunno how people can manage to like it.

After Eights are the worst of them all. Ugh.

Um are you insane? Chocolate and Mint are amazing together.