Support NeoGAF

[FStop7]

Anyone got examples of a VOD with game music only and still muted?

This one seems to be. Vice City. http://www.twitch.tv/adam_ak/b/555134005

 

[BearPawB]

"Man, I really like that song. Better find it in this 8 hour VOD and listen to it while this jergoff talks over it."

Said no one ever.

This is why its such shit.

It's fixing a scenario that never happens

 

[Mesoian]

The first 48 minutes of Dansgaming Fallout 3 marathon have been muted, and he only plays with ingame music.

What a joke.

Yup. Twitch is done.

 

[rrs]

Anyone got examples of a VOD with game music only and still muted?

Fallout 3

 

[zhorkat]

So if your video gets muted when it shouldn't have, how big of a pain is it to get Twitch to unmute it?

 

[jabuseika]

The Google-take over is real.

It's only the beginning, they'll start banning "Unauthorized Audio" during live streaming soon.

 

[fluffydelusions]

Fallout 3

GTA speedrun guy too apparently

 

[Novocaine]

Colour me 10 shades of shocked....

 

[HarryDemeanor]

The first 48 minutes of Dansgaming Fallout 3 marathon have been muted, and he only plays with ingame music.

What a joke.

And it looks like my time on Twitch is about to end.

 

[Cels]

you already weren't supposed to stream copyrighted music if you didn't have the clearances to do it. everyone knows this.

30 minute blocks is dumb though. they could have just muted the offending portions of the VOD and leave the rest.

^ but lol fallout 3 doesn't even use any licensed music right? i can see GTA streams being muted but wow those false flags

 

[Mr. X]

Thread is kind of long now so not sure if answered:

If I were to download the archive to my computer, is it no longer muted during this block?

Hear no evil.

Please be intentional.

 

[Leafhopper]

So if your video gets muted when it shouldn't have, how big of a pain is it to get Twitch to unmute it?

How much many subs you got?

 

[tci]

There goes all of the archive of a LAN event I manage. God dammit. No heads up so we could move it....

Time to look into alternatives.

 

[Foffy]

Hear no evil.

But hunt hashes in your emails! They can see those.

EDIT: Man, Cosmo is nooooot happy.

 

[Turin Turambar]

Hear no evil.

Literally. You can't hear it because it's muted!

 

[Hylian7]

Brb switching to Hitbox.

 

[Xater]

"Man, I really like that song. Better find it in this 8 hour VOD and listen to it while this jergoff talks over it."

Said no one ever.

Exactly. This whole concept is ridiculous.

 

[Ooccoo]

Twitch is done for

 

[HarryDemeanor]

Thread is kind of long now so not sure if answered:

If I were to download the archive to my computer, is it no longer muted during this block?



Please be intentional.

It will still be muted.

 

[BlackBuzzard]

EVEN LORD HELIX ISNT SAFE!

 

[EmCeeGramr]

It's already happening. RIP GTA

http://www.twitch.tv/adam_ak/b/555134005

Zelda seems to be one, according to the speedrun community.

This is gonna be fun.

The first 48 minutes of Dansgaming Fallout 3 marathon have been muted, and he only plays with ingame music.

What a joke.

EVEN LORD HELIX ISNT SAFE!

no guys you're just overreacting you already weren't supposed to play music in the abstract sense of a rarely enforced rule so this doesn't change anything

 

[Unspeakable Evil]

Hear no evil.

Evil is copyrighted? R.I.P Evilore

 

[JudgeN]

you already weren't supposed to stream copyrighted music if you didn't have the clearances to do it. everyone knows this.

30 minute blocks is dumb though. they could have just muted the offending portions of the VOD and leave the rest.

^ but lol fallout 3 doesn't even use any licensed music right? i can see GTA streams being muted but wow those false flags

Aren't the songs from the 1930 or whatever they play on the radio licensed?

 

[FStop7]

you already weren't supposed to stream copyrighted music if you didn't have the clearances to do it. everyone knows this.

30 minute blocks is dumb though. they could have just muted the offending portions of the VOD and leave the rest.

^ but lol fallout 3 doesn't even use any licensed music right? i can see GTA streams being muted but wow those false flags

Also, let's be real for a second. Does anyone sincerely believe that people streaming music on Twitch is in any way, shape or form having a negative impact on music sales? Why would anyone pirate music from Twitch when not only is there YouTube, but also any number of services like Spotify.

It's a reactionary, shotgun approach to an imaginary problem.

 

[MattPeters]

Just to follow up on Dansgaming Fallout 3 muted, (watching his stream now)

The only reason it wasnt totally muted is because he doesnt have the ingame radio playing all the time.

 

[Foffy]

no guys you're just overreacting you already weren't supposed to play music in the abstract sense of a rarely enforced rule so this doesn't change anything

I play my games with sign language, thank you very much. <3

 

[Ferrio]

&#12541;&#3900;&#3720;&#1604;&#860;&#3720;&#3901;&#65417; RIOT &#12541;&#3900;&#3720;&#1604;&#860;&#3720;&#3901;&#65417;
&#12541;&#3900;&#3720;&#1604;&#860;&#3720;&#3901;&#65417; RIOT &#12541;&#3900;&#3720;&#1604;&#860;&#3720;&#3901;&#65417;
&#12541;&#3900;&#3720;&#1604;&#860;&#3720;&#3901;&#65417; RIOT &#12541;&#3900;&#3720;&#1604;&#860;&#3720;&#3901;&#65417;
&#12541;&#3900;&#3720;&#1604;&#860;&#3720;&#3901;&#65417; RIOT &#12541;&#3900;&#3720;&#1604;&#860;&#3720;&#3901;&#65417;

 

[Blair]

RIP in pepperonis

 

[Dizzy-4U]

Hello Hitbox, you sexy little thing.

 

[Mr. Luchador]

We should have listened to Golem, we should have listened!

 

[dmr87]

It's only downhill from here.

 

[Fragamemnon]

on the upside, this basically makes arteezy's vods watchable

 

[Leafhopper]

EVEN LORD HELIX ISNT SAFE!

You gotta be kidding me.

 

[halfbeast]

ha ha ha... ha... ha.

*deletes twitch account*

 

[SerTapTap]

The comment section of that twitch post is great, bet they regret leaving comments on. It's just hundreds of "&#12541;&#3900;&#3720;&#1604;&#860;&#3720;&#3901;&#65417; RIOT &#12541;&#3900;&#3720;&#1604;&#860;&#3720;&#3901;&#65417;" posts

 

[Tomat]

This is actually a little worse than I expected it to be.

 

[Spookie]

So this will finally keep SingSing quiet? I'm ok with that.

 

[Orayn]

I take my initial post back, this system's scorched earth approach sucks. Not sure about the long term damage because I don't know how many people rely heavily on VODs with no other method of recording, but this initial implementation is really bad.

 

[Lady Siara]

Remember when people said Google wouldn't try to do this exact thing?

God damn, I was one of them. What exactly are you trying to do here? How does this benefit you, the viewers, or the service in any way?

 

[Cse]

The first 48 minutes of Dansgaming Fallout 3 marathon have been muted, and he only plays with ingame music.

What the hell?

 

[Divvy]

So this will finally keep SingSing quiet? I'm ok with that.

You heathen

 

[jabuseika]

You'd be a fool to not think this was inevitable. I just hope there aren't too many abuses and false flags, and that devs/pubs will do what they can to whitelist tracks in their games.

Yeah good luck with that.

Any and all audio that is copyrighted in games will flag the content id system. Pretty much most VOD's will be muted, unless you specifically mute all music in games.

 

[failgubbe]

 

[Ryuuga]

I've already been over at hitbox, I just need to grab a capture card now.

 

[G-Fex]

This is hilarious to learn it's affecting Dan, and other big streamers. lol

 

[hypotc]

Cosmo just got banned from Twitch apparently..

Edit: beaten

 

[RangerBAD]

Just to follow up on Dansgaming Fallout 3 muted, (watching his stream now)

The only reason it wasnt totally muted is because he doesnt have the ingame radio playing all the time.

Dan was also playing with a mod that added more songs that weren't in the original release.

 

[SerTapTap]

I've already been over at hitbox, I just need to grab a capture card now.

Don't buy yet, Elgato is teasing something new in a week

 

[Revven]

AMA Confirmed for tomorrow

Prepare yourselves, Twitch.

 

[dmr87]

It's already happening. RIP GTA

http://www.twitch.tv/adam_ak/b/555134005

Disgusting.