I tried this the past two nights on live and against bots. The complaint about it not feeling like a UT game is on the mark but it was designed that way. If you watch the developer video on the demo disk they specificaslly address this. Paraphrasing; "The first UC was a straight port and not much effort went into it to make it console friendly and that was a mistake. Because UC2 is built from the ground up for the Xbox we took many liberties to make the game the ultimate console expereince." Also, technically it is not a true FPS. From listening to him I got the feeling that Epic expects most players to use 3rd person all of the time though (paraphrasing) "everyone will play to their own style". If you look through the options all of the weapons are fully customizable so when they're equipped you automatically go to 3rd or 1st person.
The complaint about being the game being unbalanced is premature. The goods are in the characters, the weapons and the adrenaline abilities. There are so many possible permutations you as the player need to find what works and in what situation. The adrenaline abilities are sweet. I was using the female character and she had 6 abilities among which were speed (this is gonna be killer in capture the flag), nimble (jump where you normally can't), wraith (I have no idea but it looked way cool), etheral (your opponent I believe knows you are in this mode but you appear to them slightly off frm your actual position), vampire (I believe as you damge other players you channel their damge into your health) and siphon (I believe you drain health from other players, a non persistent state). Some abilities are shared while most are unique to the character.
The controller interface is well done. The abilities are easily accessible with no more than two presses of X and a press of LT, RT or A. Each press of X denotes a set of abilities.
A - Jump
B - Melee switch / Melee power attack
Y - Switch weapon
X - Adrenaline menu
LA Click - Jump (very useful not having to press A)
RA Click - Target (does not aim for you, just keeps the player in view)
RT - Fire
LT - Secondary Attack
The graphics are gorgeous. The levels are purdy and the character models are solid. The framerate, considering this is a Unreal game running on old hardware is excellent.
The matches I played were all lag free except for one. This game is shipping with an amazing 40 maps plus content download. Don't have XBL, no sweat the games I played against the bots were good and the AI is very good having multiple (the same as UT) difficulys levels. The demo had a few mutators and I'm sure the final version will have more. I was on the fence about UC2 becuase of how shitty UC was. After the demo this has moved into must get status.
Players 1-2
In-game Dolby® Digital
System Link 2-12
HDTV 480p
Communicator Headset
Content Download
Online Multiplayer
Voice
Friends