• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Which is the best portable memory? (SD, Compact Flash, MS Duo, ect)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kleegamefan

K. LEE GAIDEN
I do not know anything about portable memory...

Which is best?

CompactFlash?

SD?

Memory Stick Pro?

Something else?

I am looking for some general stuff that can be used in a variety of devices...I am going to buy a new Digital Camera, a Camcorder and I am upgrading my Comp. so I would like to know what media is viable these days

Opinions?
 

signet

Member
SD

Most digital cameras and camcorders support it along with loads of mp3 players and PDAs. If you plan to stick will all Sony products Memory Stick is your only choice.

XD sucks and Compact Flash is too big and on the way out.
 

SKluck

Banned
What he said.

Memory Stick is ass, Sony only.
XD is ass, Olympus and Fuji only.

CF is dying, but is cheaper and has some meat (good or bad) to hold onto.

SD is the "standard".
 
I usually stick with Sandisk. If possible, get the biggest one you can (the 2 GB one looks really nice). You'll be able to fit a ton of stuff on it without worrying about running out of room.
 

PS2 KID

Member
Compact Flash is best and cheapest. You get larger capacities for less. Largest size-wise of the three major formats. STILL the market leader. You'll need faster cards (ie. 60-80x) to compete with some of the faster SD and MS Pro cards.

SD is 2nd in market share and growing. Possibly the most supported format. It's smaller but like Compact Flash you need something like Panasonic or Sandisk Ultra II to match MS Pro card speeds.

MS Pro. 3rd in market share and growing. Least supported. Sony, Samsung, and maybe a couple of other manufacturers. However has the fastest standardized speeds. Basically when you buy a MS Pro you're guaranteed a fast card. Higher capacity than most SD but more expensive.

Just depends on what you desire. Larger capacity? Faster speed? Smaller size? Compatibility? etc.

Also there's XD, which not well supported, smaller than SD, and smallest capacity. Just Fuji and Olympus (maybe an odd player here and there. Kodak most recently added it.), MMC which is for the most part pin compatible with SD and comparable speed wise, mini-SD a new SD format for portables and cellphones and MS Pro Duo (ditto).

Soon to come: Memory Stick High Speed (fast, read and write, improved temperature operating range , larger capacities) and Pansonic Pro High Speed (really fast, up to 20MB/s).

Sometime in the future: A Taiwanese card format meant to obliterate all others (something like up to 120MB/s and 2 TeraBytes) someday. ;)

On the way out: SmartMedia (predecessor to XD), and Memory Stick (predecessor to Memory Stick Pro, Pro Highspeed, and Pro Duo).

Still around but on the way out: Memory Stick Duo. Some Sony compact cameras and cellphones still use this currently.
 

etiolate

Banned
SD or CompactFlash. I have a fuji didicam which uses XD and its fine, but SD and CF are much cheaper. Sony memory stick is a big no-no. Expensive and pretty much sony products only.
 

retardboy

Member
I've got an Olymp camera so I gotta use XD and well... Large cards are slow as crap for me. (512) SD is great. Love it. Got a 1 giger and it goes fast as crap.
 
Compact Flash -

Cheapest, goes up to higher capacities (there's actually a 12GB CF card out there that cane be yours for only $10,000+ :)), and all my canon cameras use it. :)

You'll also find that all the high-end dSLR cameras use it. Even the higher end sony prosumer digital cameras have dual memory stick/compact flash support.

~Cris
 

fart

Savant
i didn't believe it a year ago, but SD is the emerging standard

for media, stick with the standards
 

Pochacco

asking dangerous questions
SD overtook CF several months ago as the #1-most-used format.

If you plan on using the memory in a variety of different products, then you might wanna choose your devices based on the flash memory format they support (e.g. buy a digicam that supports SD, PDA that supports SD, etc.).

But if you don't really care about reusing the memory cards in a variety of products, then just pick whichever devices regardless of what memory they use (e.g. if you want a Sony digicam, then just buy it - even though you probably won't be using that Memory Stick in a lot of other places).

Generally though, SD is the most popular. Although CF is still the #1 pick for highend digicams..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom