Support NeoGAF

[kittoo]

The biggest requirement would be that the actress be a huge muscle hulk (and I dont mean it in a negative way, I kinda dig it). Given that its a high profile TV series, its not like they can simply take some ripped crossfit girl and be done with it. They would want her to be a known actress also. But no famous enough actress has even half the muscles Abby has. Would anyone be willing to go through the transformation, especially since that will require a lot of gym and maybe steroids/HGH?
Who do you think could play Abby in current form/after bulking up?

Emily Blunt? (Will need much bulking up)

Kate beckinsale? (Total badass, but is old and probably wont be able to bulk up much)-

Now, if they were indeed going for crossfit girls, the best fit would be the girl on which Abby's physique was actually based-

Or my personal preference, Brooke ence. Mostly because she still has a pretty face after bulking up/steroids-

Who could play Abby in your opinion?

 

[Zekra Dezivad]

John Cena? /s

 

[Jigsaah]

Yea any of those will work.

I was thinking maybe Ronda Rousey.

 

[Banjo64]

 

[skneogaf]

Brooke ence, she was in justice league so at least has a little bit of screen time.

 

[UnNamed]

 

[EDMIX]

I doubt that would be season 2. People need to remember that in games shit speeds up much more, so I expect maybe season 4 or something and even that is hopeful.

Season 1 and 2 could literally be about Joel, Tess, Fireflys, Sara flash backs etc.
Season 2 and 3 could be about meeting Elle, Tess dying, meeting the brothers etc.
Season 4 could be about joel getting hurt, Elle caring for him and fighting off those.......crazy people lol Looking at it now, yea....that shit might not be for quite a while.


I have nothing against the people in the pics but several are not even actors, I love Emily Blunt btw, but I'd never cast her. I hate to be that guy, but she is simply too old, not in general, but for this exact role. She is almost 40 right now and by the time that Abby storyline starts, she could be damn near 50.

I feel we need a child actor that can grow into the role, as in someone RIGHT NOW, that we feel in 5 or so years could be the one.

 

[kittoo]

I doubt that would be season 2. People need to remember that in games shit speeds up much more, so I expect maybe season 4 or something and even that is hopeful.

Season 1 and 2 could literally be about Joel, Tess, Fireflys, Sara flash backs etc.
Season 2 and 3 could be about meeting Elle, Tess dying, meeting the brothers etc.
Season 4 could be about joel getting hurt, Elle caring for him and fighting off those.......crazy people lol Looking at it now, yea....that shit might not be for quite a while.

They have already cast Elle, so I am sure Elle appears in season 1 itself.
There are 10 episodes of 1 hour each, so in 10 hours of first season either they will cover a lot of ground or expend stories properly or be super boring. Lets see what happens.

 

[EDMIX]

They have already cast Elle, so I am sure Elle appears in season 1 itself.
There are 10 episodes of 1 hour each, so in 10 hours of first season either they will cover a lot of ground or expend stories properly or be super boring. Lets see what happens.

ohhhhh yea.

You are correct sir.

 

[Jibran#one]

Brock Lesnar but not the current one the early 2000 Lesnar who was juiced to the gills

 

[jigglet]

 

[j0hnnix]

 

[Roufianos]

I'd put a wig on The Rock but then again he might be a bit too pretty for Abby.

 

[GymWolf]

Kayla harrison or tiger woods.

 

[bitbydeath]

Merritt Wever looks exactly like her.

Edit: Better comparison pics.

 

[G Boaty]

Merritt Wever looks exactly like her.

Edit: Better comparison pics.

This is actually a great shout if she'd be willing to put the work in to get buff.

 

[Esteldan]

 

[xrnzaaas]

The only good answer to OP's question.

I doubt that would be season 2. People need to remember that in games shit speeds up much more, so I expect maybe season 4 or something and even that is hopeful.

Season 1 and 2 could literally be about Joel, Tess, Fireflys, Sara flash backs etc.
Season 2 and 3 could be about meeting Elle, Tess dying, meeting the brothers etc.
Season 4 could be about joel getting hurt, Elle caring for him and fighting off those.......crazy people lol Looking at it now, yea....that shit might not be for quite a while.


I have nothing against the people in the pics but several are not even actors, I love Emily Blunt btw, but I'd never cast her. I hate to be that guy, but she is simply too old, not in general, but for this exact role. She is almost 40 right now and by the time that Abby storyline starts, she could be damn near 50.

I feel we need a child actor that can grow into the role, as in someone RIGHT NOW, that we feel in 5 or so years could be the one.

Unless HBO wants to milk this slowly I don't think they're going to stretch the first game to be featured in multiple seasons (like more than 2). I think GoT's scenario is more likely - the show getting ahead of the source material and starting to write its own stories.

 

[skit_data]

Jocelyn Mettler in muscle-suit is the right answer

 

[Certinty]

I somehow hope they avoid the story of the second game entirely.

 

[Putonahappyface]

Jocelyn Mettler in muscle-suit is the right answer

The pencil neck is a dead giveaway.

 

[skit_data]

The pencil neck is a dead giveaway.

Put her on a daily ”traps only” schedule for 3 months and its all good

 

[Yoboman]

It'll be funny when there is reverse outrage because whoever they cast isn't muscular enough

 

[MasterDerico]

 

[Tchu-Espresso]

Yea any of those will work.

I was thinking maybe Ronda Rousey.

That could actually work.

 

[KungFucius]

I hope it is someone with a stacked bod and very pretty face, and brick hard, yet shapely ass to fuck with the bigots.

 

[kittoo]

I hope it is someone with a stacked bod and very pretty face, and brick hard, yet shapely ass to fuck with the bigots.

In my opinion Brooke Ence fits that bill perfectly.
Though I dont know what you mean by bigots.

 

[DJTaurus]

 

[Heisenberg007]

It would be the toughest casting for them -- especially if they do flashback scenes with the same actress without using bodysuits and/or digital physical reformation.

If they do the flashback scenes with a similar looking but different actress, then the options would open up much more. Let's see who they cast, but that's still at least a year or two away.

 

[GymWolf]

That could actually work.

No it wont, rousey has the charisma and acting chops of a brick wall.

 

[Spukc]

pretty sure disney now owns the license for abby

 

[Kilau]

I hope it is someone with a stacked bod and very pretty face, and brick hard, yet shapely ass to fuck

 

[NeoIkaruGAF]

pretty sure disney now owns the license for abby

Jabby the Hutt?

 

[EviLore]

Someone who isn't up to her gills on an insane amount of steroids would be preferable, as that looks completely ridiculous in a post-apocalyptic world with her group living on subsistence rations.

Women can still get pretty strong without transitioning to male:





But pure strength was a poor conceptual choice for Abby's character. Years of MMA training would be a better direction.

 

[sircaw]

Someone who isn't up to her gills on an insane amount of steroids would be preferable, as that looks completely ridiculous in a post-apocalyptic world with her group living on subsistence rations.

Women can still get pretty strong without transitioning to male:





But pure strength was a poor conceptual choice for Abby's character. Years of MMA training would be a better direction.

Mattie Rogers Snatch? Really EviLore lol

 

[Portugeezer]

 

[EviLore]

Mattie Rogers Snatch? Really EviLore lol

The snatch is one of the main Olympic barbell lifts. Form and technique are important for success, which keeps it from devolving into a "who can abuse the most steroids without dropping dead until after the event" competition, e.g. the Crossfit Games. Weight classes help too.

 

[sircaw]

The snatch is one of the main Olympic barbell lifts. Form and technique are important for success, which keeps it from devolving into a "who can abuse the most steroids without dropping dead until after the event" competition, e.g. the Crossfit Games. Weight classes help too.

Don't you dare check out urban dictionary then lol

 

[Toots]

The pencil neck is a dead giveaway.

So much!
For some reason the middle pic reminds me of alpha doge

But pure strength was a poor conceptual choice for Abby's character. Years of MMA training would be a better direction.

That is so true it makes me blood red mad (even though it's kind of funny imagining abby rolling with some post apocalyptic Eddie Bravo in preparation of her combat jujitsu main event against team Jackson mma - pun intended -)

If you are a writer and you create a world with rules, you adhere to those rules when building your characters and story. She could have been some kind of sharpshooter too, anything else than goddam Conan the barbarian, but no it's reality that needs to bend to some hack writer will and not the other way around...

 

[EviLore]

So much!
For some reason the middle pic reminds me of alpha doge

That is so true it makes me blood red mad (even though it's kind of funny imagining abby rolling with some post apocalyptic Eddie Bravo in preparation of her combat jujitsu main event against team Jackson mma - pun intended -)

If you are a writer and you create a world with rules, you adhere to those rules when building your characters and story. She could have been some kind of sharpshooter too, anything else than goddam Conan the barbarian, but no it's reality that needs to bend to some hack writer will and not the other way around...

Sharpshooter would work, yeah.

Or a survivalist. Imagine taking inspiration from Sharni Vinson's character in You're Next. Now there's a badass heroine--someone with training and the resolve to put it to use.

 

[Shmunter]

Gina

 

[Thirty7ven]

We just need to find an actress that won’t be afraid of gaining muscle, like Jessica Biel in Blade Trinity.

Unfortunately, and this is the part nobody wants to talk about yet, it will be almost impossible to find that actress because Hollywood hasn’t changed, it has simply cranked it up. Women still have to look skinny, unless it’s a comedy movie, which is why gal gasto looked like a tooth pick in WW84, and men now have to look like super heroes regardless of what makes sense for character and the story being told.

 

[daffyduck]

Mattie Rogers Snatch? Really EviLore lol

Too pretty to be Abbie.

 

[G Boaty]

Kind of funny how you never here these complaints ("it's unrealistic to be that size in the apocalypse, there's not enough food, there's no need to be that size" etc) with regards to other characters in the game. It's only ever Abby who isn't allowed to be big.

Even though the game clearly shows that Abby lives in a healthy, sustainable camp with plenty of food to go around for everyone.

 

[Big Baller]

 

[Birdo]

Jim Sterling.

 

[Razvedka]

Kind of funny how you never here these complaints ("it's unrealistic to be that size in the apocalypse, there's not enough food, there's no need to be that size" etc) with regards to other characters in the game. It's only ever Abby who isn't allowed to be big.

Even though the game clearly shows that Abby lives in a healthy, sustainable camp with plenty of food to go around for everyone.

The amount of effort it would take a woman like Abby to get that big, the access to training, protein, and yeah probably PEDs is pretty out there. Women do not look like Abby without these things, it takes a ton of effort.

 

[OrionNebula]

What about that big lady from Mandalorian?

 

[Nigel]

Idris Elba

 

[DustQueen]