• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Who Killed the Funk?

Status
Not open for further replies.

JohnDoe

Banned
If wasn't just about black people. A lot of the people that were listening to funk and disco were gay (well LGBT in general), blacks and hispanics. I think there's even a conspiracy that the government had something to do with the downfall of disco. I doubt it's true, but who knows these days.

Definitely not, I never said that.
 
Funk existed because there was a generation of talented black men that grew up listening to big band/jazz in their households. They had role models to emulate and went down that path of becoming musicians because it was a viable/enviable lifestyle. There was a whole infrastructure of clubs/gigs that existed to support their lifestyles as they honed their craft.

So, out of that large pool of people, amazing artists emerged and formed a new sound. The pool just isn't as big as it used to be and the infrastructure doesn't exist to make it a career choice.

Also, technology.
Definitely close to the truth. The only thing I would argue is the fact that there are PLENTY of musicians hungry, eager and able to play some funk, but there isn't a big enough demand for it. Funk just isn't valued in modern times.

I will add this on what could have been a factor, the cost of real musicians.

Looking at some of the old groups when they played live, with the big horn section, 2 full keyboard, 2 guitars, bass guitar, Drums,maybe even additional people for the rhythm section, backing singers, it must have cost a fortune to take that on the road. Then the 80's come around, you needed a turntable and a mic, or tapes and a computer, you could have as little as 2-3 people to make it work...
This is definitely true. And to add to that: For clubs, bars, weddings and proms, etc., it's so much easier to just hire one DJ, as opposed to dealing with a 12 piece band. Music isn't given a large enough value in our society. Not like it once was. It is seen as wholly disposable. I can't tell you how many stories I've heard from fellow musicians of dealing with being hired for a show by clueless people who have no idea what it takes to put on a show. Nowadays people think musicians are a jukebox and can play anything on the spot. Or that singing for 3 or more hours takes A LOT out of you, and you should pay accordingly if you expect a singer to lose his voice for your amusement.

Sorry, vent over.

At least there's still Soulive.
Hell yeah! LOVE Soulive. I go see them every chance I get. I'm surprised this article didn't mention them, though they are not very mainstream (yet they are constantly touring).
 
Will read latter but my initial thought.

Magnetic tape becoming cheaper.

Then the untrained people with an impulse for music could rip a song and then add on.

With these giant groups that started they spent years working together and to stand out in clubs it was a case of needing to turn it up to 11.
And when they did get a chance to do a record they were under the radar of the vast white pop audience so the record company didn't meddle telling them to find a safer sound to sell to whites.
 

Nyx

Member
Next to listening to classics, I also get my funk from electronic music. (House, minimal, deephouse, nu-disco....)
 

sonicfan

Venerable Member
The Brothers Johnson - Get The Funk Out Ma Face

The_Brothers_Johnson.png
 
See Victor Wooten live, he's still got that funk a-flowin. I find it in contemporary music every once in a while and proceed to cry tears of joy. I play bass, and I get funk-nasty constantly.
 
It hangs around. It's less it's own thing, and more an element mixed into any number of other genres at this point, because everyone in all those other genres recognizes there's absolutely nothing wrong with getting a little funk in your styles.

There's a bit of an early 80s funk-renaissance going on, though. Daft Punk, obviously, but I'm more closely referring to

CHROMEO

This shit is straight up Midnight Star/late-era Bar-Kays "No Parking on the Dancefloor" type shit. With Roger's talkbox thrown in for good measure.

For example: Hot Mess

edit: I guess if you had to, you could classify The Heavy's "How You Like Me Now" as a bonafide funk hit, although it's essentially just a cover song.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom