• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Writing-GAF: Writing, Publishing, Selling |OT|

Ah, there are them rejection letters! I was feeling so alone. NOw I'm just sad D:

Actually, one was interesting. Read something like, "I'm afraid I can't offer you representation at this time" which is way different than any of the others I've ever gotten.

Gonna assume that's a good thing and not some evil omen of me being unloved forever until I die.

Hey, Conkers, how long did you have to wait before you received the responses?
 

sirap

Member
I've also been considering picking up a Macbook (or just something affordable in general) purely as a writing computer. I have very little experience with Macs outside of grade school, though. :p Thoughts? Suggestions?

Unless you're planning on using Vellum or Ulysses, Macbooks are kinda overpriced for writing :p

Chromebooks or even cheap Windows laptops are more than adequate. I'm a big fan of Thinkpads for their crazy build quality and keyboards.
 

Nudull

Banned
Unless you're planning on using Vellum or Ulysses, Macbooks are kinda overpriced for writing :p

Chromebooks or even cheap Windows laptops are more than adequate. I'm a big fan of Thinkpads for their crazy build quality and keyboards.

I actually had some used/refurbished Macs in mind, but I see your point. :p
 
I actually have a pretty old laptop I use when I want to go somewhere to write but I may need to upgrade to something that can at least hold a charge for several hours.
 
Unless you're planning on using Vellum or Ulysses, Macbooks are kinda overpriced for writing :p

Chromebooks or even cheap Windows laptops are more than adequate. I'm a big fan of Thinkpads for their crazy build quality and keyboards.

I've been using Scrivener on my Windows 10 laptop, but honestly I need some more info on Scrivener's usefulness. I'm really just using it as a Word application, and I think it's supposed to be much more than that.

I also have a Chromebook but haven't used it for writing yet (just got it about a month ago). Are you using Google Docs for writing there or something else?
 

sirap

Member
I've been using Scrivener on my Windows 10 laptop, but honestly I need some more info on Scrivener's usefulness. I'm really just using it as a Word application, and I think it's supposed to be much more than that.

I also have a Chromebook but haven't used it for writing yet (just got it about a month ago). Are you using Google Docs for writing there or something else?

Scrivener works really well if you're big on outlining. Being able to jump to different scenes or view character dossiers while writing is incredibly useful, especially if you're working on epics or serials. You can embed photos, assign icons, set writing targets and have an infinite number of snapshots of your draft (very useful for editing). It's pretty much my digital scrapbook for writing.

Honestly, the beauty of Scrivener is that it doesn't lock you to a specific workflow. You can write everything in a single document, or separate each scene into its own dedicated folder. Just go with whatever you're comfortable with.

With Chromebooks, I've switched from Google Docs to bighugelab's Writer. Docs tend to get sluggish on older Chromebooks once I push past 30k words, and Writer has a pretty slick looking tracking tool that keeps me motivated.
 

Nudull

Banned
I've been using Scrivener on my Windows 10 laptop, but honestly I need some more info on Scrivener's usefulness. I'm really just using it as a Word application, and I think it's supposed to be much more than that.

I also have a Chromebook but haven't used it for writing yet (just got it about a month ago). Are you using Google Docs for writing there or something else?

How good are Chromebooks? I've been tempted before, but I've never heard anyone talk about them in depth.
 

JaseMath

Member
I use Ulysses myself. It's pretty no-frills, but it's easy to use. The only thing that sucks is the markdown stuff; you have to enter it manually and it's a pain in the ass.
 
OK, challenge for Writing GAF.

Give me a good name for a pioneer town in the old west. Has to be fictional ( don't say Deadwood or Dodge City, etc.)
 

zulux21

Member
Scrivener works really well if you're big on outlining. Being able to jump to different scenes or view character dossiers while writing is incredibly useful, especially if you're working on epics or serials. You can embed photos, assign icons, set writing targets and have an infinite number of snapshots of your draft (very useful for editing). It's pretty much my digital scrapbook for writing.

Honestly, the beauty of Scrivener is that it doesn't lock you to a specific workflow. You can write everything in a single document, or separate each scene into its own dedicated folder. Just go with whatever you're comfortable with.

With Chromebooks, I've switched from Google Docs to bighugelab's Writer. Docs tend to get sluggish on older Chromebooks once I push past 30k words, and Writer has a pretty slick looking tracking tool that keeps me motivated.

I only recently started using it, but is looking to be a great source to keep track of everything. I have a ton of little details, and a decent amount of lore that is riddled with incorrect details (on purpose, one character is hiding how involved he was in something and the other is merely stating the commonly known history instead of the real history, but stuff like that I need to keep track of lol)

thus it's nice to have in one location tons of different things I can pop up and do stuff like keep track in there where each character appears, and what happens to them/ what they learn as a quick reference as far to often I mean for a little thing to happen to a character that is of later importance and I can't remember if it happened because it could fit in multiple spots lol.

How good are Chromebooks? I've been tempted before, but I've never heard anyone talk about them in depth.

I've never used a chromebook but most people i know who have had one don't mind it. For the price you pay they are solid, but if you are looking for a high end laptop you would likely want to look elsewhere.

for the purpose of writing though it should be a fine pick up, especially since last I looked a number of chromebooks focused on long battery life.
 
How good are Chromebooks? I've been tempted before, but I've never heard anyone talk about them in depth.

I like mine. I picked it up a couple months ago as a replacement for my Nexus 7 (2013) tablet, especially for browsing/commenting/tweeting. Very tough to type on the tablet. When Google announced they were adding Android app support, it seemed a logical step that I'd be able to do a full replacement. I went with the Asus Flip, which is quite a handy device. The app support is still in alpha/beta stage (on the dev channel), so it's not exactly replaced the N7 yet, and the graphical fidelity is a step down (which is a bummer), but honestly I drag it around with me almost everywhere.
 

Nudull

Banned
I like mine. I picked it up a couple months ago as a replacement for my Nexus 7 (2013) tablet, especially for browsing/commenting/tweeting. Very tough to type on the tablet. When Google announced they were adding Android app support, it seemed a logical step that I'd be able to do a full replacement. I went with the Asus Flip, which is quite a handy device. The app support is still in alpha/beta stage (on the dev channel), so it's not exactly replaced the N7 yet, and the graphical fidelity is a step down (which is a bummer), but honestly I drag it around with me almost everywhere.

Android app support does sound like something I can easily take advantage of. :)

EDIT: Doing a bit of research, and I've wanted to ask; has there been any progress on getting Scrivener to work on a Chromebook, or would its absence be a potential dealbreaker? I can use Evernote, but I'd like to try the former too.
 

Woorloog

Banned
OK, challenge for Writing GAF.

Give me a good name for a pioneer town in the old west. Has to be fictional ( don't say Deadwood or Dodge City, etc.)

You could go through cities and towns in various countries and pick one you like. A settler from another country founding a city might name it after a place in his or her homeland. Add "new" if it needs to sound a bit more English or make it clear it is named after another place. (First thought i had was "Kotka", a city here in Finland, meaning "eagle", so kinda fitting for the US.)

Or are you looking for something more like those places you mention? More Old West in theme (like Red Dead Redemption having Tumbleweed and Armadillo)?

EDIT Drawing inspiration from Deadwood, and adding some mindscrew: Driftwood. No rivers or lakes anywhere near... Go figure how a place gets named Driftwood.
EDIT In case you wonder: i'm tired. I get weird ideas when i'm tired.
 

Sibylus

Banned
OK, challenge for Writing GAF.

Give me a good name for a pioneer town in the old west. Has to be fictional ( don't say Deadwood or Dodge City, etc.)

Dustbolt. A god-forsaken shanty town held together by dreams of gold, and torn apart by scant water and food pure enough to eat. Lord of the Flies with 200% more belt buckles!
 

Nudull

Banned
Dustbolt. A god-forsaken shanty town held together by dreams of gold, and torn apart by scant water and food pure enough to eat. Lord of the Flies with 200% more belt buckles!

Come to think of it, a western Battle Royale sounds kind of awesome...
 
How common is "ville" as part of a town name, anyway? Is it just a media exaggeration?

I'm no linguist, but I think the word "town" has a more recent origin, since people started to separate 'cities' from 'villages' but 'ville / village' was the norm before.

huh, apparently it's neither:
(edit: it was for France, which is probably why I made the assumption, because that's relatively nearby)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ville

Usage of -ville in the United States

According to toponymist George R. Stewart, the use of the suffix -ville for settlements in the United States did not begin until after the American Revolution. Previously, town-names did not usually use suffixes unless named after European towns in which case the name was borrowed wholly. When a suffix was needed, -town (or the word Town) was typically added (as in Charleston, South Carolina, originally Charles Town). In the middle of the 18th century the suffixes -borough (-boro) and -burgh (-burg) came into style. The use of -town (-ton) also increased, in part due to the increasing use of personal names for new settlements. Thus the settlement founded by William Trent became known as Trenton. These three suffixes, -town/-ton, -borough/-boro, and -burgh/-burg became popular before the Revolution, while -ville was almost completely unused until afterward. Its post-revolutionary popularity, along with the decline in the use of -town, was due in part to the pro-French sentiments which spread through the country after the war. The founding of Louisville, Kentucky, in 1780, for example, used not only the French suffix but the name of the French king. The popularity of -ville was most popular in the southern and western (Appalachian) regions of the new country, and less popular in New England.

A few -ville names pre-date the revolution, but most of them are named after European settlements or dukedoms. For example, Granville, Massachusetts was named for the Earl of Granville (he was named himself after Granville, Manche (Normandy)). After the revolution and the decline in the use of -borough and -town, the two suffixes -ville and -burgh/-burg became by far the most popular for many decades. A difference between the usage of the two is that -burgh/-burg was almost always appended to a personal name while -ville was appended to any word.

By the middle of the 19th century the -ville suffix began to lose its popularity, with newly popular suffixes with -wood, -hurst, -mere, -dale, and others taking over.
 

vern

Member
Any suggestions on current best practice for promoting your works?

I have like 10 short-ish stories (longest is 10k words) I've written and are up on Amazon, sales are ok, nothing crazy, but I'd like to push them more of course. I've tried countdown deals, free giveaways, tweeting shit on twitter, reddit subforums... what else am I missing? Should I just be content with my 15-20 bucks per month I get on Amazon?
 
Any suggestions on current best practice for promoting your works?

I have like 10 short-ish stories (longest is 10k words) I've written and are up on Amazon, sales are ok, nothing crazy, but I'd like to push them more of course. I've tried countdown deals, free giveaways, tweeting shit on twitter, reddit subforums... what else am I missing? Should I just be content with my 15-20 bucks per month I get on Amazon?

Tried consolidating them into a single anthology and finding a publisher?
 

vern

Member
Tried consolidating them into a single anthology and finding a publisher?

I'm not sure they are good enough to be properly published, though could be imposter syndrome kicking in. My work is well edited and has gotten decent feedback, but I'm not sure it's really all that great.

I do have a bundle on Amazon of 5 stories since they are part of a series. Kind of an episodic novel, and checks in at around 30k words. I feel like I should have some sort of established market or history of selling at least decently before I pitch it to a publisher yeah? Any "alternative" type publishers you suggest I should reach out to?
It's a realistic, erotic travel series focused on establishing a strong sense of place + sex lol
 

sirap

Member
Android app support does sound like something I can easily take advantage of. :)

EDIT: Doing a bit of research, and I've wanted to ask; has there been any progress on getting Scrivener to work on a Chromebook, or would its absence be a potential dealbreaker? I can use Evernote, but I'd like to try the former too.

Not anytime soon. They just released Scrivenor on IOS, so that's an option too if you're going for portability.
 

zulux21

Member
on the minus side I am failing to outline stuff and put all my lore in scrivenger.

on the plus side I actually broke 60k in july now.
if I can write another 1k words tomorrow night I can reach a 2k words per night on average in july. which is a pace I would love to keep up as it would mean I would finish my rough draft of the entire story in under 2 years assuming everything sticks to my overall outline o.o;
 

SolVanderlyn

Thanos acquires the fully powered Infinity Gauntlet in The Avengers: Infinity War, but loses when all the superheroes team up together to stop him.
Gold Stone
Wagon Hill
Redhill
Stillriver
Pilgrim's Respite
Heaven's Gully
Sandy Rock
 
OK, challenge for Writing GAF.

Give me a good name for a pioneer town in the old west. Has to be fictional ( don't say Deadwood or Dodge City, etc.)

circumstance of founding vs. based off landmarks...


  • Old Hand
  • Sleevesville (made colloquially over time into?) Sleeville, Sleville
  • Sicksville
  • God Man (maybe a place of breathtaking natural beauty?)
  • Circlet (had its origin in a treaty after a wagon-circle standoff?)
  • Peace Mill
  • Legging
  • Mundane
  • Oblige
  • Hard Sell (made colloquially over time into?) Harsel, Harcel
  • Nine Ton
 
You guys rock :D. Lots of great ones!

Something that's interesting about some old west town names is that they might be named after a prospector who made the find that sparked the town into becoming a boom town or a mining town. Or named after the resource he found (silver, gold, etc).
 
So I've had this novella idea for awhile that I might finally get to since not writing feels strange. Story is about a kid and his creepy imaginary friend that lives inside him.

Thing is, I want to tell it from a first person perspective as if the kid is talking. The frame work is that he's going in for experimental surgery and chatting away as he falls asleep. As the story gets more surreal, you figure he's now dreaming.

I guess the worry is that 50 or so pages of a nine year old narrating might get annoying. I'd want it in his voice from start to finish, with the occasional interruption from his imaginary friend. This means that details are going to be all over the place as he tells what he thinks is important. He'll forget conversations and probably paraphrase a lot--basically how someone would talk and tell a story off the fly.

Thoughts on how this might work? I tend to get annoyed at first person stories that feel too clean, especially when the framework is, "I'm telling this story to you." I get that it's a writing convention to keep it that way, without pauses and ums and "i forget what happened"s, but ti's also really unrealistic for me.
 

Nudull

Banned
Conker actually reminded me of a perspective question I'd like to ask.

I've been toying with the idea of making my protagonist "genderless", in the sense that readers would be able to identify with them regardless of their gender identity, as well as make up their own minds as to the character's gender. I appreciated Undertale for doing this in a way that was nice and respectable, and the fandom easily latched onto it.

What do you all think of this approach? Have there been any books or other media that has done this as well?
 
Conker actually reminded me of a perspective question I'd like to ask.

I've been toying with the idea of making my protagonist "genderless", in the sense that readers would be able to identify with them regardless of their gender identity, as well as make up their own minds as to the character's gender. I appreciated Undertale for doing this in a way that was nice and respectable, and the fandom easily latched onto it.

What do you all think of this approach? Have there been any books or other media that has done this as well?
I can't think of any. I do know that, despite being grammatically correct, seeing "they" used as a singular drives me fucking bugshit. A novel filled with that would probably make me lose my mind :p
 

aidan

Hugo Award Winning Author and Editor
Conker actually reminded me of a perspective question I'd like to ask.

I've been toying with the idea of making my protagonist "genderless", in the sense that readers would be able to identify with them regardless of their gender identity, as well as make up their own minds as to the character's gender. I appreciated Undertale for doing this in a way that was nice and respectable, and the fandom easily latched onto it.

What do you all think of this approach? Have there been any books or other media that has done this as well?

I believe that John Scalzi did something like this in his novel Lock In.

I think it's a great idea.
 
Hmm, my first decent writing idea and I've already hit a roadblock.

The narrative is that of the first documented time that magic was used in warfare. Basically, it was a giant mess and not even the strategists familiar with magic could really predict the damage. But at the same time I want to describe the positive influence that such a leap in technology would grant to two nations prior to and post war.

I understand all things begin with an idea. But I'm struggling to create to think up original characters to fit the world I'm thinking up. I'm not surprised since this is probably my first time writing a narrative like this. WritingGAF do you have any suggestions for character inspirations?
 

FlowersisBritish

fleurs n'est pas britannique
So i submitted a short story I have probably put the most work into my entire life, and I am so nervous about a rejection letter. Been through the ringer plenty of times, but it's been a long time since I put so much effort into a story and so much time since I last wore my heart on my sleeve like this. Hoping for the best. Side note, hit all my submission deadlines for the month and that never happens. Woot.

Hmm, my first decent writing idea and I've already hit a roadblock.

The narrative is that of the first documented time that magic was used in warfare. Basically, it was a giant mess and not even the strategists familiar with magic could really predict the damage. But at the same time I want to describe the positive influence that such a leap in technology would grant to two nations prior to and post war.

I understand all things begin with an idea. But I'm struggling to create to think up original characters to fit the world I'm thinking up. I'm not surprised since this is probably my first time writing a narrative like this. WritingGAF do you have any suggestions for character inspirations?

I tend to like to find unusual analogs in the real world for weird fantasy stuff. What if it worked like the stock market? Where the magic is pretty much random, but there are tons of experts who say they know how it works but all of them have different opinions and it's just a giant clusterfuck. So, look at a stock market guy and see if any of those assholes would be fun to watch dick around in your universe.
 

Nudull

Banned
I actually have been working on something involving the discovery of magic myself, though I'm not sure how weirdly it may come off. Haha
 
Hmm, my first decent writing idea and I've already hit a roadblock.

The narrative is that of the first documented time that magic was used in warfare. Basically, it was a giant mess and not even the strategists familiar with magic could really predict the damage. But at the same time I want to describe the positive influence that such a leap in technology would grant to two nations prior to and post war.

I understand all things begin with an idea. But I'm struggling to create to think up original characters to fit the world I'm thinking up. I'm not surprised since this is probably my first time writing a narrative like this. WritingGAF do you have any suggestions for character inspirations?
I tend to start with characters first and plots second, but as far as plots go, you got yourself a fucking winner. Best of luck!
 
I tend to start with characters first and plots second, but as far as plots go, you got yourself a fucking winner. Best of luck!

Thanks! My real world inspiration was a combination of the American Civil War and World War 1 and I wanted to operate on one basic rule while reading so many fantasy novels. It was that magic is effectively technology. Therefore any fantasy setting post magic in the short term would be dramatically be impacted in terms of the technological scale, economically and socially, a phenomena not unlike the Industrial Revolution, unless education or some societal function (usually class distinction) causes a roadblock. Then if a war were to occur after that...and the picture starts to make a bit more sense in terms of my thought process. There's more to that and I don't want to focus on magic entirely, but the perspective of magic within war, society and strategy. So I need to inject a human element into the narrative, and the narrative will likely mostly occur from the strategist perspective and likely a handful of soldier accounts. It's my first big writing project so I hope I haven't bit off more than I can chew.
 
Apparently, there is/was a TV adaptation of Octavia Butler's Dawn in the works.
http://io9.gizmodo.com/how-the-tv-show-of-octavia-butlers-dawn-will-stay-true-1728791278
Never read it myself, but I feel like at least one of Octavia's works should make it to a mainstream format, speaking of which a recent article from Fusion talks about this issue.
http://fusion.net/story/319408/octavia-butler-books-need-to-be-films/
I've heard stuff for a while, but nothing ever got off ground. There is a graphic novel version of Kindred coming out in January, but the art is looking pretty bad.
 

Nudull

Banned
Apparently, there is/was a TV adaptation of Octavia Butler's Dawn in the works.
http://io9.gizmodo.com/how-the-tv-show-of-octavia-butlers-dawn-will-stay-true-1728791278
Never read it myself, but I feel like at least one of Octavia's works should make it to a mainstream format, speaking of which a recent article from Fusion talks about this issue.
http://fusion.net/story/319408/octavia-butler-books-need-to-be-films/
I've heard stuff for a while, but nothing ever got off ground. There is a graphic novel version of Kindred coming out in January, but the art is looking pretty bad.

Yeah, that one-two punch of being a black creator with black protagonists means that she may as well be Tyler Perry in the eyes of Hollywood. Minorities getting categorized and written off, oh so easily. :/
 
Yeah, that one-two punch of being a black creator with black protagonists means that she may as well be Tyler Perry in the eyes of Hollywood. Minorities getting categorized and written off, oh so easily. :/

Fuck those who think that way.

True fans of sci-fi know her worth and contribution to the genre.
 
After a month and a half of agenting, I got my first bite! Doing much better statistically with the second book than the first then, since it took like four months to get a bite with that.

Problem is this one was for a straight query letter, so who knows what'll happen when she sees the writing. I hope it's good but at this point I figure everything [redacted for being a pointless, self hating rant]
 
Top Bottom