Super Smash Bros. for 3DS and Wii U Thread 5: Yarning for Yoshi

I can practically guarantee that Tom Nook won't be playable. There's just no reason for him to be included. The fact that a lot of people once thought Nook was the most likely Animal Crossing representative has always struck me as absurd. In Smash Bros., the first character to represent any given franchise is always the playable protagonist (if it has one) -- Animal Crossing's equivalent of Mario, Link, Samus, and Olimar is the avatar Villager. On the other hand, Tom Nook is a shopkeeper NPC. I suspect a big reason that people want/expect Nook is because he's a "real" character with an actual name.

I guess if you consider Pikachu and Jigglypuff the protagonists of Pokemon...
 
That would be interesting, it could be like Frank West in UMvC3, where he levels up and gets stronger/different attacks. And if he uses furniture in his moveset they could gradually make it more expensive looking as he gets more bells.

Oooh, I like that, and then for his final smash, you spend all the bells you've accumulated and just make it rain over the rest of the cast
 
Regarding the stage differences between the 3DS and Wii U versions...

Why is everyone so sure that we're going to be getting all different stages between both versions? Sakurai never said that all stages will be unique between the two versions, and clearly the boxing ring stage confirms this. Similarly, Sakurai never said that the Wii U version would only have stages from console games, while the 3DS version would only have stages from handheld games. He only said that there would be more stages based on console games on Wii U, and more stages based on handheld games on 3DS. The Palutena's Temple stage and boxing ring stage confirm this.

I imagine quite a few franchises with more limited locations for stages or less games to pull stages from will end up sharing the same stage on both versions. I could easily see franchises like Wii Fit, Ice Climber, Game & Watch, etc. only having a single stage. Maybe even franchises like Mega Man, Star Fox, F-Zero, and WarioWare, too. I could even see the Pyrosphere stage being shared across both versions, since it's appeared on 3DS in Dead or Alive Dimensions, lol.

Your comment is pretty much right on Sakurai's comments on stages however I can't really see Pikmin's Garden of Hope in 3DS version. I'm pretty sure that they are going to pick other Pikmin location for 3DS version.

I bolded specific statement. I don't see why you would use Palutena's Temple as your example since it already exists in Kid Icarus (NES). Yeah, I know your excuse is more likely to due with Palutena's Temple's visual and map are coming straight from Uprising but still. The Kid Icarus universe's visuals and worlds evolved over the generations. Of course, Sakurai would go with the latest version in the series for visual aspects.

I have a feeling that Sakurai picked Palutena's Temple because it existed in Kid Icarus, but followed Uprising's upgraded visuals.
 
I guess if you consider Pikachu and Jigglypuff the protagonists of Pokemon...
Well, in a way, they kind of are. Sure, you, the player, take the role of the Trainer, but you also command your Pokémon; they do the fighting for you, and you directly control them. It's the Pokémon that are the real stars of the game. Of course, the Pokémon/Trainer relationship is very important, and it has been represented now in Smash Bros. with Pokémon Trainer. But still, it's not quite the same situation as Animal Crossing. Pikachu has at least been a playable protagonist in Pokémon games since before Smash Bros. was existed (Hey You, Pikachu!). Tom Nook has never been playable, and likely never will be. It's the human Villager who has always been the protagonist.

Your comment is pretty much right on Sakurai's comments on stages however I can't really see Pikmin's Garden of Hope in 3DS version. I'm pretty sure that they are going to pick other Pikmin location for 3DS version.

I bolded specific statement. I don't see why you would use Palutena's Temple as your example since it already exists in Kid Icarus (NES). Yeah, I know your excuse is more likely to due with Palutena's Temple's visual and map are coming straight from Uprising but still. The Kid Icarus universe's visuals and worlds evolved over the generations. Of course, Sakurai would go with the latest version in the series for visual aspects.

I have a feeling that Sakurai picked Palutena's Temple because it existed in Kid Icarus, but followed Uprising's upgraded visuals.
I didn't mention Pikmin, and I do think we'll probably get some kind of different Pikmin stage on the 3DS, but you never know.

And Palutena's Temple really didn't exist officially before Kid Icarus: Uprising. The Palace in the Sky from the first two Kid Icarus games may arguably be the same location, but it's never specifically stated as such, and the Palutena's Temple stage is clearly taken straight out of Kid Icarus: Uprising. But it could go either way, I suppose. I can see how Sakurai may be representing the Palace in the Sky area from the NES game with updated visuals, much like the Skyword stage in Brawl. I wonder if the
Chaos Kin
will be making an appearance on the Palutena's Temple stage, though... That would make it clearly based off of Uprising.
 
You know what would be cool? If just after the game is released Sakurai starts revealing spoilers through some of the very first, seemingly nonsensical pic of the days.

Like the Luigi's nose pic is fully zoomed out to reveal someone like Little Mac was there the whole time. Or Kirby as Samus' head pic has Ridley in it. It would be kind of fun if he gave commentary on pics of the day regarding Miiverse reactions and his motives behind some of the more cryptic ones.
 
So Tom Nook is now the face of Animal Crossing?
He's one of the few characters you're guaranteed to meet the same way in every play through, unlike KK, who's admitedly a possibility as well.

Regardless of if he should be playable, I wouldn't be surprised if we got him. He was definitely hinted at, it's a popular series, we haven't seen him yet otherwise, and we've gotten characters like Lucas, Roy, and Wolf in the past.
 
He was definitely hinted at, it's a popular series, we haven't seen him yet otherwise, and we've gotten characters like Lucas, Roy, and Wolf in the past.
What do they have to do with Tom Nook? Lucas and Roy are the main characters from their respective games, and Wolf is Fox's recurring rival (who's also playable in multiplayer mode). Tom Nook is just a townsperson NPC. The genre/structure of Animal Crossing just doesn't lend itself to a playable Smash Bros. character outside of the Villager. The games don't have a "plot," and none of the other characters matter much.
 
What do they have to do with Tom Nook? Lucas and Roy are the main characters from their respective games, and Wolf is Fox's recurring rival (who's also playable in multiplayer mode). Tom Nook is just a townsperson NPC. The genre/structure of Animal Crossing just doesn't lend itself to a playable Smash Bros. character outside of the Villager. The games don't have a "plot," and none of the other characters matter much.
Roy is the second newcomer for a new series.

Lucas is a character similar to an already existing character.

Wolf is a secondary character, like Tom Nook. I'd argue Tom Nook is much more important to his series than wolf as well.
 
I wrote a while ago on another Smash thread that I predicted Tom Nook and Alph from Pikmin 3 as playable, without any evidence at all. Alph is kinda out of the game, but I still cling to Tom Nook. You'll see.
 
The rule for making the case for any playable character:

Do not use existing characters in the roster as a point for the character you're trying to make a case for. Each character has a different case. Each character has its own circumstances.

And make sure you're not trying to argue for Goku or Batman or the like, then you're crazy.
 
Tom Nook is definitely the most recognizable non-human character of AC. And half the game is about the animals of course. To say he's not as respectively important as Wolf is sorta laughable to be honest. I'm not saying he'll be in, but c'mon. When I think Animal Crossing, I think the greedy bastard raccoon.
 
Angry Bird probably has a pretty good chance of being playable. It is the best-selling third party game on 3DS (in the west), after all.
 
What do they have to do with Tom Nook? Lucas and Roy are the main characters from their respective games, and Wolf is Fox's recurring rival (who's also playable in multiplayer mode). Tom Nook is just a townsperson NPC. The genre/structure of Animal Crossing just doesn't lend itself to a playable Smash Bros. character outside of the Villager. The games don't have a "plot," and none of the other characters matter much.

Eh... AC is a big series for Nintendo now and if another character got in it would be Nook. I don't think it would be that surprising. He does have a backstory and is part of the main driving factor in the game. He is a secondary/non-playable character but that doesn't rule him out I think.

And he is more recognizable than Wolf I would say. Sakurai has thrown plenty of curveballs in the past so you can't really say what he'll make of the possibility of another AC character.
 
Tom Nook is definitely the most recognizable non-human character of AC. And half the game is about the animals of course. To say he's not as respectively important as Wolf is sorta laughable to be honest. I'm not saying he'll be in, but c'mon. When I think Animal Crossing, I think the greedy bastard raccoon.

If this were melee, I'd say he'd be a fine villager clone. I think sakurai has grown up a bit since then and realized that slapping someone else's moves onto someone else might make them feel a bit out of character. I think it'd be really hard to make a full moveset for him, though.

Also, now that I think about it, I don't even want to imagine what captain falcon would be like if he werent in the last 3 smash games. He'd be up there with little mac for 'most requested character' i'm sure, but I couldnt even begin to comprehend what his moveset would be like if sakurai had to build him from the ground up now.
 
I think this is probably the best evidence in favor of Tom Nook, from the very first trailer:

d1DUNy9.png


Could also just be hinting toward him being an assist trophy.
 
You guys realize that Tom Nook is staring at an empty envelope and not the actual invitation, right? The only reason that scene exists is so the camera can close in on the Smash Bros. logo seal.
 
It's up to interpretation varying from person to person, but for this case, cynicism should take over and make you think it is not a hint towards anything Tom Nook related.
 
I personally think Tom Nook won't happen. Would've been funny before Villager's reveal, but now that he's in, I think a playable Tom Nook would be weird/redundant.
 
Would love a new trailer about now.

The 3DS stages seem so intriguing. I need to see some more in action.

I'm half-expecting a vet. tomorrow.
 
I personally think Tom Nook won't happen. Would've been funny before Villager's reveal, but now that he's in, I think a playable Tom Nook would be weird/redundant.

*CGI cutscene of a Coin Match with 3 players*
*Villager is winning, does a victory taunt*
*Suddenly, a random piece of furniture hits him from the side, coins fly everywhere*
*TOM NOOK is COLLECTING DEBTS*
*Featuring a remix of this catchy piece of funk*
*"See you soon! Yes yes!"*

Would love a new trailer about now.

The 3DS stages seem so intriguing. I need to see some more in action.

I'm half-expecting a vet. tomorrow.

I would just love some more 3DS footage to be honest. How amazing it looks has led cynical ol' me to be a little skeptical of how well it'll run.
 
I would just love some more 3DS footage to be honest. How amazing it looks has led cynical ol' me to be a little skeptical of how well it'll run.

Yeah, it looks really good graphically.

Such as the SM3DL stage, the full moving stage, animated background, four players, it all makes me wonder how it'll actually run.

I'm really intrigued..

i8oHF5lnbEQGK.gif


Stuff like this looks SO good, I just wonder how it'll actually perform.
 
Yeah, it looks really good graphically.

Such as the SM3DL stage, the full moving stage, animated background, four players, it all makes me wonder how it'll actually run.

I'm really intrigued..

i8oHF5lnbEQGK.gif


Stuff like this looks SO good, I just wonder how it'll actually perform.

Huh...never noticed that bowser was sent flying by mario's dash attack. Tho the damage % is missing, i wonder was it buffed.
 
Because he's not fast-falling? Bowser has always been relatively floaty, otherwise his recovery would be even worse than it already is.

Bowser's definitely been in the middle of the cast in falling speed, even if he's technically closer to the Puffs of the world as opposed to Fox/Falcon/Falco/etc.
 
Honestly, I'd be ok with Villager, Tom Nook and KK all being playable characters.

Animal Crossing is what, Nintendo's third best selling franchise behind Mario and Pokemon? Definitely deserves three characters.
 
Momentum doesn't cancel out when air-dodging? game is crap confirmed, hitstun was removed, nothing but ganondorf starts, all characters awful, all six preorders canceled
 
Animal Crossing is what, Nintendo's third best selling franchise behind Mario and Pokemon? Definitely deserves three characters.
Nah, it's not quite that high. I think Mario, Pokémon, Wii Sports, Zelda, Donkey Kong, Wii Fit, Brain Age, Kirby, and Nintendogs have all sold more than Animal Crossing.
 
Here. A lot of them are sourced at the bottom. Animal Crossing's sales figures are out of date, but even after adding City Folk and New Leaf, the series is still way below the others.

The figures aren't perfectly accurate, but that's really all we have to go by.

Well obviously something like Kirby with 20 games will outsell Animal Crossing's 4.
I'm talking about a per game basis, New Leaf released in Japan and decimated the sales of everything that came before it. I remember the 'race to 2m' graphs from the sales threads, everything was slowly going up then New Leaf was basically a straight line up from 0 to 2 million.
 
Yeah, it looks really good graphically.

Such as the SM3DL stage, the full moving stage, animated background, four players, it all makes me wonder how it'll actually run.

I'm really intrigued..

i8oHF5lnbEQGK.gif


Stuff like this looks SO good, I just wonder how it'll actually perform.
Momentum doesn't cancel out when air-dodging? game is crap confirmed, hitstun was removed, nothing but ganondorf starts, all characters awful, all six preorders canceled

3DS = Brawl
Wii U = New

Seems like it might end up like that.
 
I'm talking about a per game basis, New Leaf released in Japan and decimated the sales of everything that came before it. I remember the 'race to 2m' graphs from the sales threads, everything was slowly going up then New Leaf was basically a straight line up from 0 to 2 million.
That doesn't mean it's "Nintendo's third best selling franchise behind Mario and Pokémon," though. That kind of language implies lifetime sales. New Leaf sold/is selling well, but that doesn't automatically bump the series to third place. Even on an arbitrary per-game basis, Animal Crossing is still behind series like Wii Sports, Wii Fit, Brain Age, and Nintendogs. Those series have each sold more than Animal Crossing between even fewer entries.
 
Here. A lot of them are sourced at the bottom. Animal Crossing's sales figures are out of date, but even after adding City Folk and New Leaf, the series is still way below the others.

The figures aren't perfectly accurate, but that's really all we have to go by.
Wait, how on Earth has Metroid sold 17 million copies by 2008?

Not that I'm mad about that. It's just I was always under the impression that other than the original and Prime the series didn't sell.
 
In the Little Mac trailer we see WFT air dodge and didn't lose momentum.

Maybe every time Nook lands a hit, he collects money, making him stronger, but when he gets hit, he loses them and gets weaker.

Somehow I am reminded of another character who has similar affinity on money. It can't be Scrooge though.

Nook would be hilarious if he has that mechanic and uses furniture/wallpaper/carpet for attacks... and maybe summoning a house from the air as a final smash.

I would say that would be his grab move, but damn does that sound painful. Even Links hookshot would seem tame compared to it.

Exaggerating of course, but as someone who fishes a lot... having that happen to me would be my nightmare.

I thought his grab move was the net?
 
Top Bottom