Super Smash Bros. for 3DS & Wii U Thread 7: How Can My Smash Brother Be This Cut

So... Why can't the same thing happen with Ridley?

Hell, they could easily replace him in the stage with the Nintendoland Ridley. That would be a smart and funny solution.

Edit: just in case you didn't know, Alfonzo automatically replaces Toon Link when he's selected at the character screen.

Speaking of Nintendo Land, Monita better make an appearance.
 
I think having both Ridley and Nightmare as bosses for the Pyrosphere stage would be awesome. Nightmare would make an AWESOME boss! Plus, both bosses were in Other M. Sure, Nightmare wasn't fought in the Pyrosphere, but when have details like that ever mattered in Smash Bros.? I mean, c'mon, we got Cresselia in Spear Pillar.
 
I just had an idea.. what if the character select screen music could be customised so that remixed versions of other character select screen/menu music can be used? For example:

Super Mario Bros. 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4KcY745Qbd0
Super Mario 64: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2HhdZMpSvXg
Mario Kart 64: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z3IsodCVEOc
F-Zero X: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yyPtM9Mdlyo
Zelda: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ILllSNsx2Kc
Dr. Mario: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXXteQz3PKc

And since Namco is helping, why not: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxVj2Gxv_bk

Bonus: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_IynKC6iYQM
Better yet, make alternate select menus based off past games.
 
No, the idea I'm suggesting is the shadow belongs to the stage hazard, but that a different iteration of Ridley might be playable separately, with the reasoning that as per the series, they're technically different specimens (the Other M Ridley grows from a hatchling and is technically a separate entity from the one that has historically been Samus' rival). Thus, the bait and switch works by getting us to rule out Ridley as a boss, only to be hit with this caveat where he can be a boss in one form and playable in another.

Like I said, if I were a betting man, I would NOT bet on this being the case. But still, part of me can't help but wonder why Sakurai handled this the way he did, and if it perhaps is a setup for another reversal.

So basically a Toon Link scenario?
 
Or it could be random, but always Alfonzo if Toon Link is being played as on the stage?

I could easily see the same thing happening with Ridley on Pyrosphere. Have two different stage hazards—Ridley, of course, plus another enemy. Maybe a different form of Ridley (perhaps his adolescent stage from Other M, or Meta Ridley from Prime, or even Mecha Ridley from Zero Mission), or Nightmare! Either boss would randomly appear on the stage, except when Ridley's being played as, in which case it will always be the other boss.
But ST Link or Alfonzo are not a boss. They don't affect the stage at all. RIdley being a boss does affect the stage and thus they wouldn't want it so you could switch off that effect by choosing a certain character. It really isn't the same situation.

I mean should we start saying Yellow Devil could be playable and they could just replace him with Ditto.
 
I could see if Ridley is playable and a boss metal ridley taking normal Ridley's spot if someone is playing as him without it impacting boss ridley much, but I doubt it will happen
 
But ST Link or Alfonzo are not a boss. They don't affect the stage at all. RIdley being a boss does affect the stage and thus they wouldn't want it so you could switch off that effect by choosing a certain character. It really isn't the same situation.

I mean should we start saying Yellow Devil could be playable and they could just replace him with Ditto.
How exactly is it any different than, say, Spear Pillar in Brawl, where one of three different legendary Pokémon could appear as the stage hazard? Why can't there be multiple boss characters on one stage? They could even be functionally the same, if they go with a different form of Ridley. I don't understand what the problem would be.
 
But ST Link or Alfonzo are not a boss. They don't affect the stage at all. RIdley being a boss does affect the stage and thus they wouldn't want it so you could switch off that effect by choosing a certain character. It really isn't the same situation.

I mean should we start saying Yellow Devil could be playable and they could just replace him with Ditto.

The stage hazard Ridley is the Other M Ridley, which looks WAY different from how Ridley has always looked in the past. They could have a more classic Ridley be playable while the Other M one is always a boss and if they think that is still too confusing they could replace the boss Ridley with Meta Ridley or something when Ridley is in play, but he would act exactly the same.
 
The stage hazard Ridley is the Other M Ridley, which looks WAY different from how Ridley has always looked in the past. They could have a more classic Ridley be playable while the Other M one is always a boss and if they think that is still too confusing they could replace the boss Ridley with Meta Ridley or something when Ridley is in play, but he would act exactly the same.
This is what I'm thinking. Of course, the safest bet is Ridley won't be playable, but then again, Sakurai is so appealing partly because he's full of surprises.
 
I'm pretty sure if Ridley was playable it would be the Other M Ridley for consistency. Samus and Zero Suit Samus are based off Other M and Pyrosphere is from there as well. Since Other M Ridley is most likely the boss in Pyrosphere, Ridley won't be playable.
 
How exactly is it any different than, say, Spear Pillar in Brawl, where one of three different legendary Pokémon could appear as the stage hazard? Why can't there be multiple boss characters on one stage? They could even be functionally the same, if they go with a different form of Ridley. I don't understand what the problem would be.
"except when Ridley's being played as, in which case it will always be the other boss."
If it is meant to be random they wouldn't want a method that results in a fixed outcome. You said Ridley or Nightmare thus picking Ridley will always result in Nightmare.
 
If Ridley's playable, I imagine the Ridley on Pyrosphere will -always- be Other M Ridley, which will be presented to scale with the source material (read: gigantic!) and will look quite different from playable Ridley, who will look like he did in the Prime games and be scaled down to Bowser size. So yes, playable Ridley and stage hazard Ridley could be on Pyrosphere at the same time. There'd be no risk of confusion since they're different enough in appearance and would also be different in size. And technically, in the Metroid canon they're different entities, anyways (not that it's relevant in Smash where these are figurines or caricatures come to life).
 
The stage hazard Ridley is the Other M Ridley, which looks WAY different from how Ridley has always looked in the past. They could have a more classic Ridley be playable while the Other M one is always a boss and if they think that is still too confusing they could replace the boss Ridley with Meta Ridley or something when Ridley is in play, but he would act exactly the same.

Exactly. No issue at all if Ridley was handled like this.

At this point I really don't expect him at all but I love the character so much and would love to see him playable.

If Ridley did become playable, Sakurai's handling of him will go down in history. Future Smash speculation would never ever be the same.
 
I feel like Ridley and a Wii U Metroid (or 3DS I don't care) reveal at E3 would be enough to kill me with hype.

Oh, and if Ganondorf brings the superior Flame Choke from Brawl -/+/Project M into play as well.
 
I'm pretty sure if Ridley was playable it would be the Other M Ridley for consistency. Samus and Zero Suit Samus are based off Other M and Pyrosphere is from there as well. Since Other M Ridley is most likely the boss in Pyrosphere, Ridley won't be playable.

Samus_Zero_Suit.png

main.png
Very similar, but not the same.
I'm backing Yellow Devil as a playable character because they could just replace him with Shadow Devil.
You aren't getting it are you? Yellow Devil isn't a massively requested character. Ridley has been one of the top requests since Brawl and his "reveal" as a stage hazard was very much teasing the fanbase as it wasn't really a reveal.
 
I'm backing Yellow Devil as a playable character because they could just replace him with Shadow Devil.

See now you're just poking fun and being unreasonable. Something like Yellow Devil is on a completely different level than Ridley, even if their fates are to be exactly the same this game.
 
But ST Link or Alfonzo are not a boss. They don't affect the stage at all. RIdley being a boss does affect the stage and thus they wouldn't want it so you could switch off that effect by choosing a certain character. It really isn't the same situation.

I mean should we start saying Yellow Devil could be playable and they could just replace him with Ditto.
Switch out for robot Ridley (either the Nindtendo Land one or a completed version of the Zero Mission one), no problem whatsoever.
I'm backing Yellow Devil as a playable character because they could just replace him with Shadow Devil.
I'm backing Toon Link as playable because they could just replace him with Alfonzo.
 
Well, I'm just glad the 3DS version is coming out this "summer." I guess it wouldn't be unrealistic to assume we'll know the entire roster by the end of August, which is nice.
 
this guy gets it.
seriously though Ridley isn't going to be in the game. grasping at straws here.

It's just as foolish to say he won't be playable as it is to say he will. We don't have enough information to say that either is for sure. Everyone should just accept it as being up in the air.
 
It's just as foolish to say he won't be playable as it is to say he will. We don't have enough information to say that either is for sure. Everyone should just accept it as being up in the air.
Yep, it's up in the air. It's strongly suggested that -a- Ridley will a stage hazard in Pyrosphere, given the shadow in the boss segment of the Direct. And the tail seen onscreen suggests this particular Ridley is the hatchling from Other M. But why not just definitively show him and say "he's only a boss" if he is, in fact, just a boss? Why toy with the fans that way, if not for a potential setup, a reversal, a bait-and-switch where regular Ridley is playable alongside the appearance of Other M Ridley as a stage hazard? No need for Alfonso shenanigans.

It's not the safe bet, but it's within the realm of possibility, certainly.
 
That's presumably why he hasn't shown him yet. I can't imagine stage hazards are very high on the development totem pole.

If he knew stage hazards weren't a priority he wouldn't have hinted at Ridley in September, knowing he couldn't show him until the game was near completion.

  • During the bosses-as-stage-hazards segment of the Direct, Ridley is shown hovering over the Pyrosphere stage.
  • The stage itself is where Samus fights Ridley in Other M.
  • The stage is battle damaged (crumpled pillars, et cetera).
  • There are giant holes in the wall, which Ridley creates in Other M.
Obviously Ridley's playable, you guys.

Super Metroid Ridley and Other M Ridley are different characters, as many said we're talking of an Alfonzo-Toon Link scenario here.

He didn't show Ridley because it's supposed to be a surprise. He could have showed nothing at all when he said there were other boss characters, but he showed ridley's shadow because he knows people like Ridley. It's similar to how he hinted at Ridley when Pyrosphere was first revealed.

He's getting us hyped up for a boss character he knows we want.
He didn't do that with the Yellow Devil though, or with any other possible boss, assuming there are others. He chose a highly requested character, deciding not to outright deny the fact it was gonna be playable; why is he dancing around the whole question so much?

Because Sakurai hates deconfirming characters.

He has already said in the past how it's the one thing he doesn't like doing as that leaves the rest of the roster determinable as part of a process of elimination. On top of that, revealing Ridley as a boss means showing even more of the game, and Sakurai has stated that compared to Brawl one of the things he was going to do was dial down on the amount of "talking". He most likely didn't want to show Ridley as that would spoil the surprise of actually seeing what he does in-game.

I'm not saying Ridley isn't going to be playable but there is a good chance that any "hints" in the Direct isn't going to amount to anything, and is potentially giving him too much credit. Sakurai might know how to push people's buttons but that doesn't mean there's some grand plan at play here.

Waluigi.

Also if he wanted the surprise effect he wouldn't have even hinted at Ridley, now the surprise is apparently gone, because we're supposed to know he's a boss there.
 
It's just as foolish to say he won't be playable as it is to say he will. We don't have enough information to say that either is for sure. Everyone should just accept it as being up in the air.
Yes, but it is beyond foolish to compare him to the STLink/Alfonzo situation when it's not a comparable situation.
 
It's just as foolish to say he won't be playable as it is to say he will. We don't have enough information to say that either is for sure. Everyone should just accept it as being up in the air.

we dont have enough info? sakuria basically told you Ridley was going to be a stage boss.. wow.
I bet next time Sakurai will show Ridley fighting as a boss character. And explain that he's a boss character and how he works. And people will still try to find reasons that he'll be in the game.
besides that spot should be saved for Issac, probably has a better chance of appearing then Ridley lol
 
Very similar, but not the same.

You aren't getting it are you? Yellow Devil isn't a massively requested character. Ridley has been one of the top requests since Brawl and his "reveal" as a stage hazard was very much teasing the fanbase as it wasn't really a reveal.
Samus is based off of Other M though, that's why she has the heels. Ridley is probably based off of Other M as well, that's why he's on the Pyrosphere stage.
 
we dont have enough info? sakuria basically told you Ridley was going to be a stage boss.. wow.
I bet next time Sakurai will show Ridley fighting as a boss character. And explain that he's a boss character and how he works. And people will still try to find reasons that he'll be in the game.
besides that spot should be saved for Issac, probably has a better chance of appearing then Ridley lol

Now you are being silly with Isaac. :P
 
And why didn't he just show another stage boss if Ridley was incomplete/questionable/whatever.

Exactly. It's one too many coincidences, all around one of the most requested characters left.

Because he knows people like Ridley.

He knows that, yet he makes him not playable?

Because he wants people to stop speculating if Ridley will be playable.

Then he'd have shown him, just like Waluigi, saying he was just a boss to end any discussion.

Because the other bosses aren't done yet either.

Then don't show him.

Because he already showed them (Find Mii)

I don't really get this. He ahould have shown them in the direct, in Ridley's place.

That's been talked about before. Link has been in the screenshots whenever Alfonzo is there. It seems if Toon Link or Link are playing on that stage, Alfonzo will appear.

----
I don't understand why people are talking in absolutes. There should be some room for doubt. Like I don't think Ridley's shadow only being shown will mean he is going to be playable, but I guess I see the fact it could be interpreted that way. It could also mean that Sakurai didn't want to show what Ridley does.
Seriously, there's just no absolutes yet. To say that thinking he could still be in is delusional is a little excessive: there are actual arguments supporting that possibility.
 
Waluigi.

Also if he wanted the surprise effect he wouldn't have even hinted at Ridley, now the surprise is apparently gone, become we're supposed to know he's a boss there.

Just because he had to deconfirm one or two odd characters by virtue of the existence of Assist Trophies doesn't mean that statement is any less void. It's not like Waluigi was the most campaigned and significant addition to the Mario franchise ever, so far most assist trophies have only been minor side characters.

Same goes for the Boss Battle part. By confirming Yellow Devil as a stage boss, he says that other stages will also have bosses in them and shows but a glimpse of a boss that's going to happen - not what it'll do, how it behaves and how it looks. The surprise factor is still there, and it's not like Ridley hasn't been speculated to be a stage hazard in Pyrosphere for quite some time.
 
I think Metroid is already getting a lot of love in this iteration of Smash; a boss, another assist trophy and ZSS is smoking hot.
 
Ridley could go either way. And no one side can say, "Aha, it was so obvious" if they end up right, because both sides have good cases that show either outcome is a possibility given what was (and wasn't) shown.

At any rate, I'm more interested to see Palutena. I loved Uprising so much, and she's the first character I think of when I think of that game (followed by Hades, of course).
 
Yes, but it is beyond foolish to compare him to the STLink/Alfonzo situation when it's not a comparable situation.
This post is to expand upon what BGBW said. ST Link and Alfonzo are just character swaps. They don't affect the stage beyond it changing visuals. Ridley is a stage hazard boss. What he does is something unique and not comparable to just a character swap.

Now you can say that another version of Ridley would be playable while Other M Ridley is a stage hazard. That doesn't require some complex theory.
 
]Yes, but it is beyond foolish to compare him to the STLink/Alfonzo[/B] situation when it's not a comparable situation.
Not really

we dont have enough info? sakuria basically told you Ridley was going to be a stage boss.. wow.
I bet next time Sakurai will show Ridley fighting as a boss character. And explain that he's a boss character and how he works. And people will still try to find reasons that he'll be in the game.
besides that spot should be saved for Issac, probably has a better chance of appearing then Ridley lol

No, he said there are other bosses, then showed Other M Ridley's shadow. As many have said, why not just show him? To tease us because he knows Ridley has been one of the most requested characters for almost 10 years. Also as others have said Other M Ridley is not only a DIFFERENT Ridley, but he also looks completely different from classic Ridley which they could easily base the playable Ridley off of. You shouldn't take that tease at face value. Until the Sakurai outright says that Ridley is not playable or the game comes out and he isn't playable you shouldn't dismiss him. Also no, Issac doesn't have a better chance.
 
Now you can say that another version of Ridley would be playable while Other M Ridley is a stage hazard. That doesn't require some complex theory.
If Ridley is playable, this is what I think what will happen: Other M Ridley always appears as the Pyrosphere stage hazard, even if playable Ridley is in play. Playable Ridley, meanwhile, would be another version of Ridley. The one from the NES original, the Prime games, Super Metroid -- whatever. He'd basically look like the pterodactyl/buzzard-esque beastie we know and love while the stage hazard is the pointy-nosed, blade-tailed abomination from Other M.
 
Top Bottom