• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Polytron Hacked?

Status
Not open for further replies.

unbias

Member
Fair point, but I imagine based on the execution of the leak itself, even if Fish was better secured a lot of important shit would still have got leaked, the only difference (and it is a hell of a difference,) is that the hackers happened to find a bunch of shit they weren't even looking for to begin with. Well, they found a bunch of shit they weren't expecting to find to begin with. They probably were looking for it.



Am I out of the loop on this? I thought the game was confirmed dead for at least a year now, didn't he have an epic meltdown last year that led him to cancel it?

Nothing is ever completely safe, but hacking into multi verification is very hard to hack into. You have to be a pro to get into a lot of it if people secure shit properly. Unfortunately many people dont understand what "secure" means in today's world(its like people being confused why you would use mozilla over chrome). Hopefully this sends a strong message to other indie devs who have hit it big, secure your fucking shit.
 

Nephrahim

Member
Fair point, but I imagine based on the execution of the leak itself, even if Fish was better secured a lot of important shit would still have got leaked, the only difference (and it is a hell of a difference,) is that the hackers happened to find a bunch of shit they weren't even looking for to begin with. Well, they found a bunch of shit they weren't expecting to find to begin with. They probably were looking for it.



Am I out of the loop on this? I thought the game was confirmed dead for at least a year now, didn't he have an epic meltdown last year that led him to cancel it?

Yes, it was. He jokes about canceling it again every once in a while. There was never any realistic plan for it for years, as far as I am aware.
 

Goddard

Member
I'd be shocked if they were. Any excuse to hack, it really can be addictive, I mean how else could you explain wardriving?

I didn't think hackers were so damn upset about Fish.

I means he's no better than your Youtube comment troll sometime, no need to go and try to ruin his life.

I think all the evidence you need to prove that their motivation wasn't about being pissed off is the fact that contained within the front page of the leak is either /v/ trolling /v/ trolling /v/, or someone else trolling /v/, or some variation of that. They are obviously experienced, obviously twisted as fuck, and obviously were enjoying what they were doing, so I seriously doubt it was an act of revenge as much as it was an act of pure malevolence.
 

Famassu

Member
It can be. You'd have to listen to the critique of feminism to know.

It's lazy and manipulative to try and act like anyone opposed to feminism is anti-equality. Lots of women are not feminists. Are they anti-equality?
If they are for equality, they are feminists, no matter if they want to call themselves as such. The only reason why people usually don't is because of these "anti-SJW" sprout such hateful vitrol against feminists that some people don't want to be targeted by that.
 

x3sphere

Member
Definitely the first option. Anyone who has seen things like this happen before can tell it's (relative to most of the shit that goes on when someone on 4chan tries to hack something,) masterfully executed. At least so far.

Credentials to the source code repository for Fez was posted on the Polytron site. Someone earlier said it was public facing (i.e. you could connect to it from the internet). If that's true it suggests his security was incredibly lax. Why would that not be locked down to a local network?

Hopefully, the code was not stolen, I guess we'll find out over the next few days if any more information is leaked.
 
I think all the evidence you need to prove that their motivation wasn't about being pissed off is the fact that contained within the front page of the leak is either /v/ trolling /v/ trolling /v/, or someone else trolling /v/, or some variation of that. They are obviously experienced, obviously twisted as fuck, and obviously were enjoying what they were doing, so I seriously doubt it was an act of revenge as much as it was an act of pure malevolence.
Ahh.

Still an asshole thing to do however.
 

Goddard

Member
The amount of people claiming that he did this himself is staggering and frightning.

This is pure speculation because it's been a couple hours since I last checked up on /v/, but if /v/ is known for anything it's known for it's baiting. I would put money on that a large majority of the people claiming he did it to himself are just trolling.

Nothing is ever completely safe, but hacking into multi verification is very hard to hack into. You have to be a pro to get into a lot of it if people secure shit properly. Unfortunately many people dont understand what "secure" means in today's world(its like people being confused why you would use mozilla over chrome). Hopefully this sends a strong message to other indie devs who have hit it big, secure your fucking shit.

Should be a pretty strong message to most people honestly. Pissing off the wrong person even if you aren't well known can lead to big issues if you aren't careful. I'm still too lazy honestly though, lol. I encrypt some shit, use 2 step for some other shit, but I'm too broke for extra hard drives, and my upload speed is 0.5 mbps so I never bother backing anything up. You call it irresponsible, I call it dramatic tension.
 
For now I think this is a thing that is clearly focussed on Phil Fish and will not have any more wide-reaching consequences. People hated him before this, and they hated him even more after last week because he just poured more and more fuel into the fire with his toxic tweets and insults. It's something that is very focused on him and his personality.

There are many many outspoken people out there who can handle themselves and deal with these things rationally. Fish couldn't

I think you're missing the point I'm trying to make - other developers will look at the situation, say 'f that', and retreat from any sort of public-facing activity, commenting on certain events, etc.

Why risk it? If I was a developer, I certainly wouldn't. This story terrifies me and I'm nowhere near the firing line.

The amount of people claiming that he did this himself is staggering and frightning.

It really, really is.
 

Ethelwulf

Member
So in a nutshell (I just woke up):

1-Phil pissed some hackers off by making unnecessary comments.
2-Hackers attack.
3-Phil closes Polytron down fro good?
 

unbias

Member
If they are for equality, they are feminists, no matter if they want to call themselves as such. The only reason why people usually don't is because of these "anti-SJW" sprout such hateful vitrol against feminists that some people don't want to be targeted by that.

The bold doesn't really make sense. Feminists who want equality are feminists who want equality, but you are not automatically a feminist if you want equality. The former exists without the latter, the latter can still exist without the former.
 

GamerJM

Banned
This is awful. Regardless on what you think about feminism or Phil Fish or anything (and personally I have no real qualms with feminism as a whole and sort of support it, and I don't really know Phil Fish well enough to make judgements about him), Fish definitely doesn't deserve this. I'd be surprised if this didn't eventually get resolved but it's still awful.
 

Goddard

Member
Credentials to the source code repository for Fez was posted on the Polytron site. Someone earlier said it was public facing (i.e. you could connect to it from the internet). If that's true it suggests his security was incredibly lax. Why would that not be locked down to a local network?

Hopefully, the code was not stolen, I guess we'll find out over the next few days if any more information is leaked.

Holy shit I didn't hear about that. If that's actually true, man, just facepalm +10. Like you can't be making that much money, and sirring up that much controversy in one of the biggest shitstorms of the last couple years in gaming, and not expect someone to try and hack you. I'm not trying to justify doxing someone ever, but come on.
 
Phil acts like an asshole and I wouldn't care if he left the gaming industry or not, but nobody deserves to be doxxed.

I doubt that guy who did it actually came from /v/, though.
 

Goddard

Member
i guess /V/ is kinda like the new joke? maybe trying to piss off /v/ or maybe referencing that zoe quinn hack i guess

It's not really an inside joke, it's just manipulation more or less. If you know your way around someone's head well, all you need is a week on 4chan to be able to figure out exactly how to piss everyone off without doing anything. Like one minor detail like crediting the hack to /V/ probably rustled some serious jimmies over on 4chan. There are plenty other less obvious but still pretty apparent things inside the leak that are only there for the sake of trolling.
 

unbias

Member
Phil acts like an asshole and I wouldn't care if he left the gaming industry or not, but nobody deserves to be doxxed.

I doubt that guy who did it actually came from /v/, though.

If it is it's probably the typical /r shit, where it is a brother of a friend of a cousin of an acquaintance, who decided to "pitch in".
 

Famassu

Member
That's simply not true.
If they support feminists principles, they are feminists. Again, feminism has such bad rep in some people's minds that they simply don't want to be called as such, even though they support everything that feminists are trying to achieve.
 

0xCA2

Member
Apparently other developers/people involved with indie games have been hacked as well, not just Phil and Zoe. Hackers have also been targeting people who knew Zoe personally. No word on what the extent of the hacks are/were.

This is coming from rumblings from people involved with games on twitter.
 

Nibel

Member
I just woke up, saw this, thought it was a bad joke until I've read the details.

This has nothing to do with gaming, social justice or equality; this is exactly what we as a community should avoid becoming. This should be not allowed to have a place in our hobby.

This is malicious cyber criminality that has no other intention than harming people for no reasons. Yes, for no reasons, because there is no reason to go so far and ruin somebody's life for things he says on a fucking micro-messaging website.

It's the same as terrorist groups who claim to do it for the religion: no, you don't do it to be against SJ, you did it because you are fucked up inside your head. Fucked up.
 

unbias

Member
If they support feminists principles, they are feminists. Again, feminism has such bad rep in some people's minds that they simply don't want to be called as such, even though they support everything that feminists are trying to achieve.

That still doesn't make sense. I know it is semantics, but it really doesn't make sense. That means if your ideals are aligned with any group(whether you know about them or not) you are now "insert label here". Really odd way to look at the world.
 
If they support feminists principles, they are feminists. Again, feminism has such bad rep in some people's minds that they simply don't want to be called as such, even though they support everything that feminists are trying to achieve.

Say equality is the end goal. Feminists and other egalitarians may have different means for reaching that same end goal.

That is what separates some egalitarians and feminists.

Not all egalitarians are feminists because they differ in how they pursue equality.
 
Private information from Valve, Sony, and Microsoft leaked. Personal information and contacts leaked.

This isn't something you complain about on Twitter. You go to the fucking government. Has anyone reported this to the FBI?
 

Famassu

Member
The bold doesn't really make sense. Feminists who want equality are feminists who want equality, but you are not automatically a feminist if you want equality. The former exists without the latter, the latter can still exist without the former.
The basic principle of feminism is equality of genders. You can't be a feminist and support inequality.
 

Goddard

Member
As far as we know right now it could easily be someone from /v/, intentionally giving credit to /v/ to make people on /v/ think that it's someone else, because no one ever credits hackings to the board, but when you really think about it the only person who would be motivated to piss off /v/ like that in such a specific fashion is of course someone from /v/. Or at least that's what the ebaumsworld affiliated hacker wants you to think, so it could actually go even deeper with someone not affiliated with /v/ intentionally baiting the hook and letting it go through like 4 steps of psychological inception so at the end of the line no one really has any idea what the fuck is going on.

south-park-season-15-8-ass-burgers-matrix.jpg


Or aliens or zombies or some shit, I don't know fuck you. Lol.
 

jiiikoo

Banned
Private information from Valve, Sony, and Microsoft leaked. Personal information and contacts leaked.

This isn't something you complain about on Twitter. You go to the fucking government. Has anyone reported this to the FBI?

Yeah, my first reaction wouldn't be complaining about it on twitter. I would be on the phone with the police the second something like this happened to me. And after that with the banks and other institutions and maybe after all of those phone calls I would considering saying something about it over on Twitter/Facebook.
 

Goddard

Member
Yeah, my first reaction wouldn't be complaining about it on twitter. I would be on the phone with the police the second something like this happened to me. And after that with the banks and other institutions and maybe after all of those phone calls I would considering saying something about it over on Twitter/Facebook.

Trust me, at least 5 people have already reported it to the FBI, don't worry about it.

Also night GAF, because of this thread I'm up till 4:10 am lol.
 

Sioen

Member
They probably hacked themselves to get more attention. Weird how his twitter wasn't hacked.. A bit too obvious for me.
 

jiiikoo

Banned
Trust me, at least 5 people have already reported it to the FBI, don't worry about it.

Also night GAF, because of this thread I'm up till 4:10 am lol.

Of course they have, but I seriously hope that Fish is one of those 5 people. If you get what I am saying.
 

unbias

Member
The basic principle of feminism is equality of genders. You can't be a feminist and support inequality.

Feminism has a lot of different movements. It is MUCH easier to just agree with someone with the same goals as you vs trying to force everyone into the same social circle.
 

Famassu

Member
That still doesn't make sense. I know it is semantics, but it really doesn't make sense. That means if your ideals are aligned with any group(whether you know about them or not) you are now "insert label here". Really odd way to look at the world.
Feminism isn't some club that you need to get into. It's like being conservative vs. liberal. If you have liberal values, you are a liberal. If you have feminist values, you are essentially a feminist, even if you don't want to be called such because you've bought into the negative stereotype about feminists.
 

unbias

Member
Or someone wanted to make it look that way. Which is kind of scary, if they put that much thought into it.

I'll admit, as someone who never does this, when I noticed all the stuff that was taken but he still had his personal twitter I had to do a double take. I mean, I cant be the only guy who works in network security who thought... "Well that's odd". Until I know it for a fact though, I'm going to assume he did not do that, since it would be incredibly stupid and very conspiracy theory like. The more realistic explination, I'm guessing, is that the hacker wanted a way to talk to Phil.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom