Alright guys, obviously anything could change, but if this is indeed our final list of newcomers:
How do you feel Smash 4 did with it's newcomer selection? I made this picture so you try and think of the newcomers as a whole, not just the ones leaked.
Me personally? A few missed opportunities aside, fucking stoked. 15 new fighters is nothing to scoff regardless of clones, and you could even bump that number to 17 if you count the Mii Fighter as 3 different characters.
Shulk - Happy he's in, definitely one of the characters introduced between Brawl and Smash 4 that deserves to be in.
Pac Man - Super happy he's in. One of the only third party characters that really deserves to be in there. As soon as Namco was involved, I had a feeling we'd be playing as Pac Man in the new Smash.
Bowser Jr. - I always thought Bowser Jr. or Baby Bowser would be a cool choice for Smash. A smaller, quicker, more agile Bowser that hits softer. Only problem is, Bowser is hella fast in this game. Luckily, it looks like the two don't play similar at all, so that's good. Wouldn't be on my first ballot for new comers, but I'm happy to see him in the game.
Wii Fit Trainer - Amazing WTF character. As much as I'm not a fan of "games" like Wii Fit, one can't deny it's importance in Nintendo's history at this point. The game is deserving of a rep in Smash Bros, and WFT's moveset looks really unique and quirky.
Villager - Animal Crossing is slowly becoming an A-level franchise for Nintendo, so a playable rep was due. Happy with this choice.
Megaman - The most hype newcomer by far. It's fucking Mega Man. If any third party character deserves to be in based on his history with Nintendo, it's Mega Man. Even over Snake and Sonic. Dude was a superstar during the NES era, and Sakurai clearly built the character, his moveset and his movement around that specific version of the character.
Rosalina - Rosalina is great. More female reps are always a good thing, and she comes from two of the greatest games ever made. I'm okay with that.
Palutena - Kid Icarus Uprising was an awesome game. Sakurai also made it, so Palutena was one of those characters I knew was going to be in from day one. Her moveset looks cool, and she's a great character, so I'm happy she's in.
Little Mac - What was one an assist trophy is now a playable character! I never really got into Punch Out, but Little Mac has a unique moveset and brings awesome music to the game. Happy to see him in there.
Duck Hunt Dog - Another WTF character that I would have never guessed. Really curious to see how he plays. I always love seeing retro, "obscure" characters being reborn in Smash Bros, and DHD is no exception.
Lucina - I really like Lucina as a character, but all signs point to her just being a worse version of Marth... hard to get excited about that. However, I'll give her the nod since she's a clone of one of the most fun characters to play in Smash, and she's from Fire Emblem Awakening. Also, female reps! That's enough for me.
Greninja - Fucking awesome. Another character I would have never seen coming. Sakurai just chose an awesome, new Pokemon that looked like it could have a great Smash Bros moveset, and decided to go with it. Fuck popularity. I love Greninja, I love how he plays, and I love that he's in the game. My most hyped character besides Mega Man, and I think he just might be the newcomer I'll be playing the most.
Miis - Definitely deserving to be in this game. Miis represent the biggest new IP for Nintendo since the Wii dropped, the Wii _____ franchise. The have a pretty interesting gimmick, too.
Robin - Fire Emblem Awakening is an incredible game. Robin is from that game. Therefore, I'm happy Robin is in. I wouldn't have minded Chrom getting in, too. Fuck it, Fire Emblem reps for everyone. Definitely excited for this character.
Dark Pit - Ah.... so close. Sorry, fuck this guy. It's a palette swap. Dude was literally a palette swap in the last game. Not cool, Sakurai. So biased.
14/15 ain't bad. I'm pretty happy with this selection. The characters I never would have imagined getting in (Wii Fit Trainer, Duck Hunt Dog, Greninja, Robin, Lucina, Dark Pit) are all worthwhile additions IMO, the exception being Dark Pit. Everyone else I feel like would have got into Smash sooner or later, and the two third party reps were at the top of the list of "Third Party Reps that deserve to get into Smash 4".
Only problem is... there are two Nintendo characters that deserve to be in over any of the currently announced newcomers. That is, the main villain of the Metroid franchise, Ridley, and the main villain of the Donkey Kong franchise, K Rool. If they don't make it in to Smash 4 via DLC, I have to imagine they are saving them for Smash 5. They are already scraping the bottom of the barrel with some of the choices in this game, and unless Nintendo starts pumping out new IPs between now and Smash 5, I really don't know who's left. Ridley and K Rool are so obvious, they honestly should have been Melee characters, or Brawl at the latest.
But it's not that big a deal for me, I probably wouldn't have played them anyways ^_^