brandonh83
Banned
It makes absolutely no sense for Rey to be Leia's kid. What, Leia just lost her baby like a set of speeder keys, then went "Welp..."
We know nothing that has happened in that thirty year gap.
It makes absolutely no sense for Rey to be Leia's kid. What, Leia just lost her baby like a set of speeder keys, then went "Welp..."
I have a feeling they are going to try and replicate a big surprise/twist to match the whole " Luke I am your father". I'm pretty sure of this. I just hope it's good and not forced just for the sake of having it.
It makes absolutely no sense for Rey to be Leia's kid. What, Leia just lost her baby like a set of speeder keys, then went "Welp..."?
Luke, OTOH, could have knocked a chick up and not even known about it.
Oh wow. It's all part of what is arguably the most well known scene in all of Star Wars. Luke is fighting Vader, and Vader lightsabers his hand off right before getting Luke to realize he's his father. Luke then drops off the bridge thingy and out the exhaust shoot where he's picked up by Leia and co. Cut to scene of him in the 'sick bay' testing out his new cybernetic hand. Pretty sure it basically then rolls credits for Empire.
It's funny how memory works. It seems most people just remember 'Luke, I am your father' which isn't even the right quote to begin with lol.
expect luke's new hand wasn't a creepy robot one.
It was robotic, he either removed the skin graft or it weathered off.
It was robotic, he either removed the skin graft or it weathered off.
Not to mention it (the skin anyway) got damaged in ROTJ. Perhaps he never bothered to fix the skin or just ripped it off.
If she's the leader of the Resistance, maybe she wanted her daughter to live a peaceful life away from all the fighting or something. I don't know.
I'm pretty sure it was always supposed to just be a synthetic covering over the robotic hand. If the wrist is entirely robotic underneath the 'skin', logically the hand is as well.expect luke's new hand wasn't a creepy robot one.
None of you guys have any clue what the material in the skin graft is made of. So saying it weathered off seems really weird.
I didn't say weather off, I suggested it was damaged and removed. But there could be all sorts of explanations.None of you guys have any clue what the material in the skin graft is made of. So saying it weathered off seems really weird.
None of you guys have any clue what the material in the skin graft is made of. So saying it weathered off seems really weird.
None of you guys have any clue what the material in the skin graft is made of. So saying it weathered off seems really weird.
I didn't say you did, "you guys" is a pretty general statement. Sou Da did, however I definitely remember at least one other post saying the same earlier in this thread.I didn't say weather off, I suggested it was damaged and removed. But there could be all sorts of explanations.
Yes we don't know what it is made of, but we know it's not living tissue.
Or as injurai mentioned, it could simply be a full-on replacement.
It's possible Luke had the skin removed so that, in constantly being reminded of its artificiality, he will remember the example of his father (who also had a synthetic hand), and how easy it is to fall. See the end of his final duel with Vader in ROTJ.
It's possible Luke had the skin removed so that, in constantly being reminded of its artificiality, he will remember the example of his father (who also had a synthetic hand), and how easy it is to fall. See the end of his final duel with Vader in ROTJ.
lando is on the Star Wars stream now. He hasn't seen the trailer yet so the audience yell that they show him the trailer now lol. He is a smooth guy even in his old age. I truly hope he is in one of the new Star Wars films!!
Hell no. Despite everything Lando has done post Ep V (inc. his EU exploits), I still can't forgive that guy for selling out Han like that. It's irrational I know, but even now all these years later, I still don't trust Lando.
What, really? He was redeemed in that very movie, and then risked life and limb to save Han in Episode VI. You really hold a grudge!Hell no. Despite everything Lando has done post Ep V (inc. his EU exploits), I still can't forgive that guy for selling out Han like that. It's irrational I know, but even now all these years later, I still don't trust Lando.
The First Order is a dumb name. Just call them The Empire
The First Order is a dumb name. Just call them The Empire
I was under the impression that The First Order was the Rebellion and the Resistance would be The Empire.
Because, you know, that would make sense. Guess not.
What about that makes sense? The Empire wasn't destroyed, merely destabilized.
Didn't the DLC for the new Battlefront that takes place after Return of the Jedi call them the New Republic? What happened to that?I don't like Rebel Alliance --> Resistance though. That name change seems like a lateral move, or even a downgrade; as if they didn't make any kind of progress over 30 years to be still be considered a resistance movement instead of a legit government.
Civilizations are destroyed in mere seconds. 30 years is quite a long time to be destabilized no matter how big of an organization.
How many years did it take for Rome to die?
Civilizations are destroyed in mere seconds. 30 years is quite a long time to be destabilized no matter how big of an organization.
The First Order is a dumb name. Just call them The Empire
A moisture farmer collects water during the night and morning from dew. Where it would otherwise sink into the sand and evaporate before it could be collected. I always thought it was decently self-explanatory as they are on a desert planet.
-We don't how close he was to them. He didn't seem to have much contact.
-Fair enough. Although I think that their interactions/dialogue indicates that ANH wasn't the FIRST time that Luke and Obi Wan had met. It seemed pretty clear to me even as a kid that they'd met before and knew each other at least a little bit. They don't talk/act like people who are just meeting each other for the first time.
-The Rebellion is made up of many different people from many different races/cultures. It's not at all hard to believe that they'd know about the Jedi/Force, especially since they don't buy into Imperial propaganda. And of course the PT/TCW establish that some of them (Bail Organa, Adm. Ackbar, Mon Mothma, etc) were around during the Clone Wars/interacting with the Jedi.
-I didn't have a problem with that. It's preferable to just leaving them to rot/get eaten by animals.
-Fair enough. But to be fair, the OT Stormies were just garden variety conscripts/volunteers, whereas we don't know the context for TFA ones yet. But yes, the Stormtroopers (that name usually tends to imply ELITE soldiers) were comically inept at lot of the time. It's why I stick up for Rebels whenever people complain about the "idiot Stormtroopers" in that show. They were ALWAYS incompetent.
Civilizations are destroyed in mere seconds. 30 years is quite a long time to be destabilized no matter how big of an organization.
I kinda always suspected this but that always seemed stupid to me. You're telling me that A) people live on a planet with very limited to no water and B) with all their crazy space magic technology they can't just fly water in or build some device that easily supplies water? But, whatever.
Why doesn't the East Coast just ship out water to California?
Because they don't live in the future (or past) where faster than light speed travel is possible and everyone drives hover crafts.
I kinda always suspected this but that always seemed stupid to me. You're telling me that A) people live on a planet with very limited to no water and B) with all their crazy space magic technology they can't just fly water in or build some device that easily supplies water? But, whatever.
Alright, buddy there's no need to try and come up with in-universe explanations for this stuff the real reason is mostly just bad writing or poor direction. Ben and Luke don't give two shits about Aunt May and Uncle Ben because their only purpose in the films is to give a reason why Luke is stuck on Tatooine and later for him to have some motivation to go against the Empire. It's also the same reason Luke is all like "What's a Jedi? Cool. I wanna follow you and be one too." The plot demands he becomes a Jedi and Lucas didn't feel like wasting time with him gradually accepting the Hero's path.
But back to my Force point, I still feel that none of the movies do a good job explaining how the general public views religion. Did they all used to worship The Force? How did the Empire suppress a galaxy wide religion? Han Solo didn't seem to know much about The Force when he was speaking with Ben and Luke, he just seemed to chalk it up to other crazy shit he's heard in the galaxy. Again, it's why I find the Rebel Alliance's adherence to The Force so strange.
Oh and I wasn't saying they should't burn the Jawas, for all we know that is how they do it in their culture, it's the casualness at which C-3PO dumps the bodies that has always made me laugh. He just drops that Jawa into the big burning pile like a sack of potatoes, not giving two shits it was a living being. And then Ben is just standing there to the side like, "you good C-3PO? I'd give you hand but I'm too old for that shit, just keep piling them on."
I also want to add one more point now that I'm on that scene, specifically Ben Kenobi just letting Luke go back to his aunt and uncle's house. Ben knows that the Empire has probably gotten to them and more than likely killed them but lets Luke go off all on his own. Now, there are a number of problems with this but the main one is that how the hell does he know the Empire has already left? They could still be there waiting for Luke, maybe his uncle gave him up under torture and they were waiting for him to come back. But, whatever you could just explain it away by saying that Ben could feel through the Force that they were dead and the Stormtroopers gone.
This has probably been posted before, but, speculative as it is, I find this somewhat interesting and funny.
This has probably been posted before, but, speculative as it is, I find this somewhat interesting and funny.
Code:[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/GB9AmFC.jpg[/IMG]