• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

NAACP Leader Exposed as White Woman in Blackface

Status
Not open for further replies.
This thread just keeps on giving...

Sanford_Son_Laughing.gif
 
Wag said:
This thread is awesome. As a Jew nobody would want to fake that, so this gives me a chuckle. 😀
Click to expand...

Not to derail the thread but there are some conspiracy theorists that say the Jews in Israel may not be the genuine articles.

But back to this thread, this is hilarious. Reminds me of the old WWF character Akeem (One Man Gang).
 
ryutaro's mama said:
And to add to this, if she ever decides she is done with the charade, she gets to return to being a White woman and have all the societal benefits associated with it. Ethnically Black people have no such choice. I mean, MJ lightened his skin and yet he was NEVER considered a White man, even if he decided to claim being one (which of course he never did in public).

Being Black isn't some fucking fashion trend.
Click to expand...

Wasn't that due to the Pepsi accident and his skin condition caused by stress?

Altough did't he keep the Ghosts cosutume and walk around outside

exhibit-1147.jpg
 
Spiderjericho said:
Not to derail the thread but there are some conspiracy theorists that say the Jews in Israel may not be the genuine articles.

But back to this thread, this is hilarious. Reminds me of the old WWF character Akeem (One Man Gang).
Click to expand...

Who's considered ethnically Jewish is probably as divisive a debate as any American one dealing with race, probably.
 
KingK said:
I had to look over the OP like 3 times before i was convinced this wasn't an onion article Lol. Wow.

I read some of the debate regarding whether transracial is an actual thing on the last couple pages. I intuitively feel like it isn't comparable to transgender, but i can't really point out where the difference in the logic is. I admit I'm not very knowledgeable about trans issues, so if someone with more knowledge wants to give an explanation to why something like this is unacceptable and completely different from being transgender, please do. Again, i instinctively feel like they're different situations, but i can't really formulate a logical argument as to why.

When Crab and others ask how the situations are different, the only responses I've seen are "it just is. And if you disagree you're either racist and/or transphobic."
Click to expand...
I think the difference is that there is no heritage involved in being transgender. You aren't transgender because your parents were transgender. Your parents and your grandparents and your great grandparents don't share a cultural history of being transgender and your place in life is not defined by what they went through because of it. If being Trans racial is really something that exists, which I doubt, then at best you would have to define yourself as black but with no black heritage. This woman seems to have just lied to create an actual heritage that doesn't exist.
 
Fox318 said:
Wasn't that due to the Pepsi accident and his skin condition caused by stress?

Altough did't he keep the Ghosts cosutume and walk around outside

exhibit-1147.jpg
Click to expand...

Wat?

That's like saying when Eddie Murphy was in makeup as an old Jewish guy in Coming to America, he was accepted as White. C'mon bro...

I am saying when MJ's skin (regardless of the reason) became significantly lighter, he didn't get any special White privilege--in fact, he was ridiculed, called Jacko and shit like that. He was still a Black man.

That is why people trying to give this woman a pass bothers me.
 
poppabk said:
I think the difference is that there is no heritage involved in being transgender. You aren't transgender because your parents were transgender. Your parents and your grandparents and your great grandparents don't share a cultural history of being transgender and your place in life is not defined by what they went through because of it. If being Trans racial is really something that exists, which I doubt, then at best you would have to define yourself as black but with no black heritage. This woman seems to have just lied to create an actual heritage that doesn't exist.
Click to expand...

I think this is key and pretty much exactly where I stand.
 
VanMardigan said:
The Hispanic delegation is questioning the existing contract with Vin Diesel and reserves the right to veto any deal that could further obfuscate the legitimacy of their claim.
Click to expand...

This does illuminate a problem with the previously discussed trade, as the Jewish delegation maintains a partial claim to Drake, not the White delegation. White delegation lacks authorization to trade Aubrey's rights.

We remain deeply interested in not reclaiming Rachel Dolezal's rights, however, and will seek different avenues to ensure a deal is reached, including taking back Stacey Dash and Raven Symone and Flo Rida. We will even keep Yelawolf.
 
Opto said:
Seriously, I think she has some kind of identity crisis
Click to expand...

It's interesting to see the same people online that fall all over themselves to defend transgender people turn around and claim that this woman is mentally ill.

what if she "identifies" as a black woman?
 
EdibleKnife said:
I think this is key and pretty much exactly where I stand.
Click to expand...

She kind of has to, though. Suppose she said "I have chosen to be black, but my parents are white". She'd have been ridiculed... exactly like she's being in this thread. Either she's a liar or a joke, neither is comfortable situation to be in.
 
poppabk said:
I think the difference is that there is no heritage involved in being transgender. You aren't transgender because your parents were transgender. Your parents and your grandparents and your great grandparents don't share a cultural history of being transgender and your place in life is not defined by what they went through because of it. If being Trans racial is really something that exists, which I doubt, then at best you would have to define yourself as black but with no black heritage. This woman seems to have just lied to create an actual heritage that doesn't exist.
Click to expand...
I was struggling to put into words exactly why I don't like the comparison but I think you've just nailed it.
 
SmokyDave said:
Back one page:
Click to expand...

The poster he was talking about tried to twist the argument to what he percieved was a "PC line" of this being cool because there is no such thing as race, the concept of color blindness is in fact a form of racism.

He wasnt even calling that poster a racist because the original comment Dennis make was a joke, but he correctly pointed out that those that think that way are.
 
Crab said:
She kind of has to, though. Suppose she said "I have chosen to be black, but my parents are white". She'd have been ridiculed... exactly like she's being in this thread. Either she's a liar or a joke, neither is comfortable situation to be in.
Click to expand...

Lord forbid she's called out on a lifetime of deceit and offensive appropriation of black culture. We gotta consider HER feelings in all this!!!
 
poppabk said:
I think the difference is that there is no heritage involved in being transgender. You aren't transgender because your parents were transgender. Your parents and your grandparents and your great grandparents don't share a cultural history of being transgender and your place in life is not defined by what they went through because of it. If being Trans racial is really something that exists, which I doubt, then at best you would have to define yourself as black but with no black heritage. This woman seems to have just lied to create an actual heritage that doesn't exist.
Click to expand...

This is kinda what I've been fumbling towards since last night, basically.
 
Crab said:
She kind of has to, though. Suppose she said "I have chosen to be black, but my parents are white". She'd have been ridiculed... exactly like she's being in this thread. Either she's a liar or a joke, neither is comfortable situation to be in.
Click to expand...

I think lying has done more damage to her work as an activists than pretending ever could. I mean, she lied about hate crimes in order to make herself "more authentic" (I guess). That crosses any respect for the people she supposedly sympathizes with into parodying them.
 
Fuchsdh said:
Who's considered ethnically Jewish is probably as divisive a debate as any American one dealing with race, probably.
Click to expand...

Race is always a sensitive matter, but the thing about Judaism is that not only is it a race but it's a religion too. It's pretty exclusive in that case.

As far as conspiracy theories go I usually don't buy into most of them, especially ones involving the Jews.
 
EdibleKnife said:
I think lying has done more damage to her work as an activists than pretending ever could. I mean, she lied about hate crimes in order to make herself "more authentic" (I guess). That crosses any respect for the people she supposedly sympathizes with into parodying them.
Click to expand...

I sort of agree here. In an ideal world, she'd just have said "I am black/choose to be black", and everyone would have known. A lot of people would have ridiculed her or ostracized her or made her life very uncomfortable; but there have to be other people out there like Dolezal who feel similarly or are even doing the same thing and someone has to be the first to be open about it. The trouble is, calling her out for that is... difficult. It's pretty understandable she was afraid of being ridiculed and ostracized; that's a hell of a difficult place to be in. So, I think it's wrong that she lied to try and fit in, but I think how wrong it is is constrained by her situation.
 
Slayven said:
yet no one ever talks about black people's feelings.
Click to expand...

Nothing matters until it affects white people. Just look at this thread. So many people don't even have the first clue, admit it's weird and they don't know what to believe BUT... followed by a full on full court press defense of her. There's literally nothing now, that you can say they cannot do. Even if they want to be black, who are you to judge the identity they want to see themselves as.
 
Madness said:
Nothing matters until it affects white people. Just look at this thread. So many people don't even have the first clue, admit it's weird and they don't know what to believe BUT... followed by a full on full court press defense of her. There's literally nothing now, that you can say they cannot do. Even if they want to be black, who are you to judge the identity they want to see themselves as.
Click to expand...

It just so rage inducing that people want to cheer her on her brave decision to be black. I been black every day of my life, where is my cheer section? Where was ll these supportive people when that little girl got dragged and beaten at that pool party?
 
Madness said:
Nothing matters until it affects white people. Just look at this thread. So many people don't even have the first clue, admit it's weird and they don't know what to believe BUT... followed by a full on full court press defense of her. There's literally nothing now, that you can say they cannot do. Even if they want to be black, who are you to judge the identity they want to see themselves as.
Click to expand...

This is such a strange argument you're making here. I am entirely comfortable with who I am. More than that, I am very fortunate to be actively happy about the person I am. There are facets of me I'd change, but they're relatively limited. I'm not arguing because I feel if I defend this woman, I can follow in her footsteps. I also have no particular dispensation towards to white people. I don't care about white people specifically any more than I care about any other people. I specifically don't have any reason to care about Rachel Dolezal, a woman who I've never met and probably have very little in common in.

The reason I care, is because if she's not pretending, and she wakes up in the morning and looks in the mirror and sees a skin that isn't hers and thinks, "that's wrong/that's not me/that's not who I am"; and she finds a body she's comfortable living in, and other people tell her that's wrong and try to force her into a body she's not comfortable in and into being a person she isn't, then there is something *wrong* going on, and someone is being hurt.

Of course, if, deep down, she hates pretending to be black and only does it for the NAACP salary, is or ambivalent and does it for attention, then you're right entirely - it' deeply offensive and she is wrong. But, assuming for the time being that's not why she does it, I have reason to care.
 
poppabk said:
I think the difference is that there is no heritage involved in being transgender. You aren't transgender because your parents were transgender. Your parents and your grandparents and your great grandparents don't share a cultural history of being transgender and your place in life is not defined by what they went through because of it. If being Trans racial is really something that exists, which I doubt, then at best you would have to define yourself as black but with no black heritage. This woman seems to have just lied to create an actual heritage that doesn't exist.
Click to expand...

I was going to post something along these lines but you beat me to it. But yeah, the very natures of sex and gender are different than race and heritage in that regard and those realities need to be factored into the discussion of this woman's case.
 
JDSN said:
Plenty of explanations given, but then again if you are saying that users are accusing others of racism (link some posts) then there seems to be an issue on your end.
Click to expand...

I mean, all of those posts you linked could easily have the same arguments some women use against transgender women. That's the point Crab and a couple others were making earlier. Like I said, I feel like the situations are different too, as an initial reaction. But I don't have a clear, logical explanation for why "transracial" people like this are at best mentally ill while transgender is a completely different and accepted concept. I can't articulate any reasons and I haven't seen anyone else convincingly do so either. And again, this may be due to my lack of knowledge on trans issues, which is why I was asking for somebody who knows more to clearly explain why they're different.

As for the latter point;

excelsiorlef said:
Dear people comparing this to trans folk. Knock it off right now. You are hurting both trans folk (and people of colour). This comparison has been used to discredit trans folk for ages and to see people using it seriously (and using as a means to be more progressive than thou) is fucking infuriating. You undermine trans rights with your stupid shit. Get that through your head you are hurting trans people. We don't need your kind of help so kindly fuck off

- A Trans Person



Right and those people are racists of a different kind. I get the feeling we are mostly on the same page and are arguing semantics which honestly is boring.
Click to expand...


You yourself seem to have accused her "defense force" of being diet racists and police brutality apologists:

JDSN said:
I can tell this girl is white not because of her color of her skin, but because of the amazing defense of her bullshit actions in the same manner people do with murderous cops, #alllivesmatter people and diet racists. She gets the be black and also an army of devil's advocates that have the same superficial understanding of reality as hers.
Click to expand...
 
Cagey said:
This does illuminate a problem with the previously discussed trade, as the Jewish delegation maintains a partial claim to Drake, not the White delegation. White delegation lacks authorization to trade Aubrey's rights.

We remain deeply interested in not reclaiming Rachel Dolezal's rights, however, and will seek different avenues to ensure a deal is reached, including taking back Stacey Dash and Raven Symone and Flo Rida. We will even keep Yelawolf.
Click to expand...
The black delegation would also like to bar Chet Haze from requesting change of committee. I also request that Teena Marie be posthumously inducted into the black delegation....oh and Jon B too.
 
JDSN said:
The poster he was talking about tried to twist the argument to what he percieved was a "PC line" of this being cool because there is no such thing as race, the concept of color blindness is in fact a form of racism.

He wasnt even calling that poster a racist because the original comment Dennis make was a joke, but he correctly pointed out that those that think that way are.
Click to expand...
I dig that, but it was the 'of a different kind' that made me raise that comment in particular. I get why the dude you were talking to perceives a minefield. This topic is offending people like crazy.

Thing is, this woman hasn't even come out and said she 'feels' black as far as I'm aware. Kinda renders the whole thing moot. I do think that the conversations around 'new' trans labels are coming though, soon enough. First it will be be transable (because if you're smashing up your own limbs you obviously have some sort of 'real' issue) and then it'll be transethnic / transracial. I'll be sitting back and listening with interest because I really don't get any of this stuff at all.

Again though, even if there was going to be a conversation, this woman should not be a catalyst. This is more like some weird disguise gone wrong.
 
You can either see her as someone who is a deceitful fraud or someone who is pretty damn messed up but ultimately well meaning. I see her as the former not the later. She hasn't really hurt anyone here, so I don't know why anyone would actually be mad at her.
 
Slayven said:
It just so rage inducing that people want to cheer her on her brave decision to be black. I been black every day of my life, where is my cheer section? Where was all these supportive people when that little girl got dragged and beaten at that pool party?
Click to expand...

Probably posting about free speech and how the teacher shouldn't have been fired for her Facebook post, how the cop was under stress and made a mistake, or positing about why so and so crime went unacknowledged by the media etc. There is this pervasive 'white is right' mentality that is taking hold everywhere and it's gets so frustrating.
 
Slayven said:
It just so rage inducing that people want to cheer her on her brave decision to be black. I been black every day of my life, where is my cheer section? Where was ll these supportive people when that little girl got dragged and beaten at that pool party?
Click to expand...

This is also really frustrating. You have my support. I don't know how to best express it, but you have it and you can count on it. I'm not American; that poor little girl isn't something I can actively do anything about (unless you have any suggestions), but I have written about how badly the American police system and justice system, and to be honest, political system in general needs massive reforms; in many threads other than this one. Why are you supposing this is the only issue I care about?
 
Slayven said:
yet no one ever talks about black people's feelings.
Click to expand...

Not exactly surprising. All of these people defense-forcing this behavior and bringing up terrible analogies to transgender acceptance movements are only concerned about letting this woman do what SHE wants to do. Black people find this offensive? "You shouldn't, you should be FLATTERED someone is willing to 'go backwards' (actual words said in this thread) to help you out! Live and let live! But she's doing good with her lies, deceit, and dishonesty toward the people she's supposed to represent!"
 
Has she released a statement? I'm wondering what she'll say. I honestly can't believe this story is real. Like other posters said, it reads like an Onion article.
 
KingK said:
I mean, all of those posts you linked could easily have the same arguments some women use against transgender women. That's the point Crab and a couple others were making earlier. Like I said, I feel like the situations are different too, as an initial reaction. But I don't have a clear, logical explanation for why "transracial" people like this are at best mentally ill while transgender is a completely different and accepted concept.
Click to expand...

Nothing is as entertaining as seeing liberals eat each other.
 
Crab said:
The reason I care, is because if she's not pretending, and she wakes up in the morning and looks in the mirror and sees a skin that isn't hers and thinks, "that's wrong/that's not me/that's not who I am"; and she finds a body she's comfortable living in, and other people tell her that's wrong and try to force her into a body she's not comfortable in and into being a person she isn't, then there is something *wrong* going on, and someone is being hurt.
Click to expand...


Well, I've heard it all on GAF, official.
 
Veritigo_X said:
Has she released a statement? I'm wondering what she'll say. I honestly can't believe this story is real. Like other posters said, it reads like an Onion article.
Click to expand...

She literally peaced the fuck out of an interview when he questioned if she was African-American, whether the black man she claims was her father actually was. She said something about how we're all from Africa originally and then just bailed on the interview. She knows the jig is up now. No more pretending.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Tarantino to write and direct 6 part miniseries set in the 1930s in black and white. Stallone to co-direct.
38
359
bitbydeath replied
Japanese woman marries her AI boyfriend
2
64
3K
Zacfoldor replied
Spider-Noir | Authentic Black & White Teaser Trailer
15
318
GateofD replied
  • Locked
A transwoman named jammie booker just won the title of 'World's Strongest Woman' at the World’s Strongest Woman competition in Arlington, Texas.
News Drama 
8
411
TommyCronin6969 replied
Irish woman awarded £23,000 after English boss calls her a potato
2
52
386
Solarstrike replied
Top Bottom