[SPOILERS] Star Wars: The Force Awakens (Thread #2) - One Thumb Up

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have never heard that. All we know is that Obi-Wan tells Anakin "if you strike me down, I will become more powerful than you can ever imagine."

Unless I missed something, which could be?

The Clone Wars series clarified that darksiders cannot learn Force ghost, and that Qui-Gon is the first Jedi to have done so. The Sith believe that death is an absolute ("Only a Sith deals in absolutes!") and their greatest/only fear in life is death. They want eternal life because they want power and they never want to relinquish it. Someone who completely gives themselves up to the Force and experiences total ego death, learning to let the Living Force guide them completely regardless of dogma or orthodoxy, can achieve eternal life as a conduit through which the Force can speak. This is why Qui-Gon was the first, and he taught it to Obi-Wan and Yoda.

If Plagueis did succeed in finding a way to "cheat death", then he's the first darksider to figure out how to do so.

It's non-existent in the Star Wars universe. All the more reason for Rey to be gay.

The new canon has been rectifying that already. Sinjir in Aftermath (as well as Snap/Temmin Wexley's aunts) are gay, as well as Moff Delian Mors.
 
BTW Daisy Ridley is the find of the decade. I thought that maybe it was just some mesmerizing Star Wars bias, but nope...she's going to be a bonafide superstar in a few years.
 
It's weird how aggressive you're being about this.
Actually, it's not. As a gay woman, people assume I'm attracted to men all the time, and it's a huge burden I deal with in my life. Hence, I noted how peculiar it was that everyone was assuming Rey is attracted to men even though the movie gives no indication that this is the case.

Couple that with Star Wars' lack of gay characters, I threw out the idea that she could be gay. Which is awesome!
 
THEORY:
Before dying, a Jedi can take on a Force Ghost form, only if they're anchored to another Jedi.

Meaning, Obi Wan was determined to guide Luke from the grave, and didn't appear to anyone else. Anakin made the same choice when he died, as did Yoda.

Qui-Gon always clashed with Yoda, and his final F.U. was to show there was another aspect of the Force.. that and he was so wrapped up in the Sith conspiracy, he wanted to get through to the most powerful Jedi he knew -- Yoda.

I like that idea a lot, to be honest. It gives the ability some much-needed limitations.
 
THEORY:
Before dying, a Jedi can take on a Force Ghost form, only if they're anchored to another Jedi.

Meaning, Obi Wan was determined to guide Luke from the grave, and didn't appear to anyone else. Anakin made the same choice when he died, as did Yoda.

Qui-Gon always clashed with Yoda, and his final F.U. was to show there was another aspect of the Force.. that and he was so wrapped up in the Sith conspiracy, he wanted to get through to the most powerful Jedi he knew -- Yoda.

Again. Entire arc about Yoda learning the force ghost technique in TCW.
 
THEORY:
Before dying, a Jedi can take on a Force Ghost form, only if they're anchored to another Jedi.

Meaning, Obi Wan was determined to guide Luke from the grave, and didn't appear to anyone else. Anakin made the same choice when he died, as did Yoda.

Qui-Gon always clashed with Yoda, and his final F.U. was to show there was another aspect of the Force.. that and he was so wrapped up in the Sith conspiracy, he wanted to get through to the most powerful Jedi he knew -- Yoda.

Love it! Explains so much.
 
Its hilarious how this whole thing spun out of control

Personally I do think they will go Rey/Finn with a possible love triangle since thry talked rumors of open calls for chicks to do a "chemistry" read with Finn's character
Empire did have the romance for the non-Luke parts. They'll definitely need something to pad out that running time.
 
It's totally the sharing a letter jacket thing.. and commenting on how good he looks in his clothes.. etc :D

It must suck to be a Finn fan.. to go from thinking he's the next Jedi, to finding out he's a cowardly janitor who's been made into boyfriend material :D
 
Actually, it's not. As a gay woman, people assume I'm attracted to men all the time, and it's a huge burden I deal with in my life. Hence, I noted how peculiar it was that everyone was assuming Rey is attracted to men even though the movie gives no indication that this is the case.

There's one moment that might suggest her and Finn have a spark, I think it's after the Falcon chase when they finally learn each other's names. There's a brief moment where they both look at each other kind of smiling, like something was going to happen maybe, then the Falcon breaks, sending steam up from the floor and interrupting the moment. I think it would be really easy to read into that, but it's not really enough to definitively suggest anything. Could just be their friendship solidifying. They can very easily go any which way with the characters in the coming films.
 
betting we will see her only in a funeral scene and then the torch is passed tot he new crew

Unfortunately, I'm sure you are correct. I know everyone has been looking forward to Luke's progression post OT, but for some reason I always wanted to see what would become of Jedi Leia. I had always hoped that she would be able to combine the prestige of being a Princess/Queen with the power of being a Jedi and bring something new to the table. Instead they made her a rather boring General.
 
BTW Daisy Ridley is the find of the decade. I thought that maybe it was just some mesmerizing Star Wars bias, but nope...she's going to be a bonafide superstar in a few years.
I really hope so. She definitely looked like she belongs in Star Wars, that's for sure.

I have a friend who's positively stuck on calling her character Mary Sue Skywalker though. He wasn't a fan.
 
there is more than one hint at Rey and Finn having a romantic thing.

The Librarian, it'd be cool and all and im down with star wars gay characters, but reacting at people believing the characters to be romantically involved with "not any such indication" is silly when they get more than just one "deep stare / smile but then something happens that breaks away their attention" cliche movie moments.

c'mon.

im all for it but no need to attack people when there's plenty of reason for them to think this way beyond this "men just assume women are attracted to men!!" thing

maybe it's cool for now that we get a black possibly romantic lead with a white female?
 
I really hope so. She definitely looked like she belongs in Star Wars, that's for sure.

I have a friend who's positively stuck on calling her character Mary Sue Skywalker though. He wasn't a fan.
She was so likable though! When she makes that weird bread stuff at the beginning? Way better than Luke.

And yeah, the only thing in favor of Rey being gay was that she didn't kiss Finn on the mouth, which is nothing.
 
I really hope so. She definitely looked like she belongs in Star Wars, that's for sure.

I have a friend who's positively stuck on calling her character Mary Sue Skywalker though. He wasn't a fan.
Fuck that guy; she's a badass. She's (probably going to be) a Jedi. She's a pilot. She's has personality to spare. She's gorgeous. If she was a he, you're friend would have a new cinema hero.
 
Unfortunately, I'm sure you are correct. I know everyone has been looking forward to Luke's progression post OT, but for some reason I always wanted to see what would become of Jedi Leia. I had always hoped that she would be able to combine the prestige of being a Princess/Queen with the power of being a Jedi and bring something new to the table. Instead they made her a rather boring General.

Problem is that Carrie got irked over having to lose weight, I don't think there's a chance in Hell she'd make it to 'Jedi Queen in action sequences' mode.
 
Actually, it's not. As a gay woman, people assume I'm attracted to men all the time, and it's a huge burden I deal with in my life. Hence, I noted how peculiar it was that everyone was assuming Rey is attracted to men even though the movie gives no indication that this is the case.

Couple that with Star Wars' lack of gay characters, I threw out the idea that she could be gay. Which is awesome!

It would be cool if it happens. I just don't see anything to support either side right now, so I didn't feel like it was worth discussing.

If it does happen, I just hope it's done in a way that it doesn't consume her identity.
 
Just got home from the theater! My first reaction is that it's a really good movie, but not a great one. I liked all the characters (although Finn not as much), and Rey especially. She will be a true badass by the third movie. Ren was mopy but not emo, and came across as a believable character in the end. Weirdly enough I though Han Solo came across a little flat, not like the charming rogue I remember. I was also a bit disappointed in the overall plot. It felt a bit rushed towards the end, and the Death Star plot felt like a footnote inserted to bring the characters together to tell the REAL story. Also, does anyone know why they made the plot so similar to Episode IV? I assume it's deliberate?
 
Love it! Explains so much.

Qui Gon messes with my theory (as does TCW as I'm understanding).. as I had even wrapped midichlorians into things.

The idea was that they become midichlorians that are bonded to the Jedi they died near. Which is why Yoda, Anakin and Obi Wan are all bonded to Luke who they died in the presence of.

Qui Gon messes with that idea, but he is (presumably) the first to use the technique, and it took him a while, so maybe his midichlorians took longer to find their intended source :D (the Dark Side was clouding things according to Yoda :D)

Again -- this was just an idea I had for years for fun, until canon apparently explained it.
 
I can see us getting a real nice triangle thing with Poe, Rey and Finn in 8 for the romance fix the series needs.

I can se
ns
e Poe getting a head start with Rey leaving Finn devestated. Then while Rey is somewhere getting her training Poe will fall into the hands of the enemey being awfully disfigured in the process and Finn overcoming his saltiness getting Poe outta there.





... great, this in fanfic territory, isn't it?
 
The answer I need to know is why, if Kylo was so obsessed with his grandfather, not appear in ghost form to try and keep him away from the dark side path?

Anakin's ghost turned back to the dark side because, after RotJ, Obi Wan and Yoda ghosts continued to treat Anakin's ghost like crap and he again got fed up with them.

Anakin's ghost appears to Kylo to guide him to darkness now.
 
I can see us getting a real nice triangle thing with Poe, Rey and Finn in 8 for the romance fix the series needs.

I can se
ns
e Poe getting a head start with Rey leaving Finn devestated. Then while Rey is somewhere getting her training Poe will fall into the hands of the enemey being awfully disfigured in the process and Finn overcoming his saltiness getting Poe outta there.






... great, this in fanfic territory, isn't it?

Switch it around. Finn is upset over Rey leaving and Poe senses that Finn needs loving and moves in.
 
Fuck that guy; she's a badass. She's (probably going to be) a Jedi. She's a pilot. She's has personality to spare. She's gorgeous. If she was a he, you're friend would have a new cinema hero.
Eh, maybe. He's not really a Star Wars fan anyway but he really didn't care for much of the movie. I agree completely with you though. She was great.
 
I can see us getting a real nice triangle thing with Poe, Rey and Finn in 8 for the romance fix the series needs.

I can se
ns
e Poe getting a head start with Rey leaving Finn devestated. Then while Rey is somewhere getting her training Poe will fall into the hands of the enemey being awfully disfigured in the process and Finn overcoming his saltiness getting Poe outta there.


... great, this in fanfic territory, isn't it?

Happens to the best of us. We're all a little worked up over wondering where this is all going next, don't even sweat it.
 
Fuck that guy; she's a badass. She's (probably going to be) a Jedi. She's a pilot. She's has personality to spare. She's gorgeous. If she was a he, you're friend would have a new cinema hero.
He'd also be named Luke Skywalker. It's a shame people are projecting this onto her and have never had a problem with it in the series in the past.
 
Another interesting aspect regarding Kylo that is apparently in the novelization, is that killing Han didn't accomplish what he wanted it to for himself. He was wrecked with guilt and trying to suppress the light during that fight with Rey and Finn.

People seem fixated on the idea that Kylo Ren getting shot by Chewie was the reason he lost the lightsaber fight.

That's not it at all.

What really happened is that he's a broken shell of a man, going up against someone whose scars are much less deep, who is learning to tap into her true self for the first time and doing so out of need and not out of desire for power.

His bowcaster wound is significant, of course - it's literally the first actual thing that happens after he kills his father - but it's a physical representation of the damage he has done to himself. Him struggling with the pain of the wound during the fight? Once again, a symbol of what he's doing to himself to keep going.
 
Rey could be attracted to women even if she's attracted to Finn. It's really up to the whims of the screenwriters, and anything is possible. Makes it that much more fun to speculate.
 
Actually, it's not. As a gay woman, people assume I'm attracted to men all the time, and it's a huge burden I deal with in my life. Hence, I noted how peculiar it was that everyone was assuming Rey is attracted to men even though the movie gives no indication that this is the case.

Couple that with Star Wars' lack of gay characters, I threw out the idea that she could be gay. Which is awesome!

So what does this mean:

Unless they're of the same sex, of course.

All kind of people are shipping Finn / Poe. Nobody in this thread appears to have any kind of problem entertaining homosexuality in Star Wars.

Who would we be shipping Rey with? That other charismatic female character in this movie, _______? When has shipping even been about expressed sexuality anyway? Benedict Cumbatch Sherlock fans ship Sherlock and Watson all the time, even tho Watson's married a lady and hasn't demonstrated attraction to men. Shipping is turning on-screen chemistry into silly fan art. Rey's only on-screen chemistry (indeed, on-screen interactions) are with men.
 
she's 100% a Mary Sue

yet

im still a big fan of her

next film needs to introduce stakes, and she does need to go through some sort of struggle for a proper character arc

in this one film, outside of a trilogy, she came from nowhere, a slave, and she could:

- Fly the millenium falcon
- Fire blasters accurately
- Beat trained people on Lightsaber duels
- Jedi mind trick the shit out of a stomtrooper on first try

it's not one or the other. she can be a writer insert / mary sue and still be potentially cool and whole. I just think this movie relied a lot on her "mysterious past" to the point where the stakes were pretty low regarding her specifically and the other characters felt like her baggage.

Im sure they'll have some super badass backstory that could explain how apt she is at everything in the star wars universe, but she neeeeeeeeeds something to hold her back in her abilities and to at least struggle a bit to make me properly care as I'd like.

She's a badass character and I really enjoyed her, but I wanna be as interested in her as I am in someone like Kylo, because of his flaws and his need to overcome them.

Rey as a character so far works much better in the big picture of a trilogy thing than she did in this first movie, cause all the presentation of her as a total badass left little room for the stakes to be high and care


The way to have a cool badass female character is to hold her in the same regards as a cool male character; you'd groan at a super badass male character that could do everything right always; but you love a character who overcomes hardships to achieve their goal through learning from mistakes and ocassionally failing but ultimately succeeding.

Having a SUPER BADASS WOMAN isnt suddenly "wow they made women cool!!" they need to be treated equally, as interesting and full protagonists
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom