Synless
Member
God damnit.Heading for landfall in the Carolinas as an incredibly intense hurricane. Florida is saved on this run. Nightmare for forecasters.....
![]()
God damnit.Heading for landfall in the Carolinas as an incredibly intense hurricane. Florida is saved on this run. Nightmare for forecasters.....
![]()
...and have it shot and scored in the style of the 2014 Godzilla movie skydiving scene...
Every single forecast for the past 48 hours has said it would immediately turn slightly north (or have done so by now) and yet as of 8pm it's still heading due west. What is it that all of these models have been missing for the past 48 hours? Why can't they adjust in a way that if they've had the forecast incorrect in a certain direction for so many forecasts in a row, that they start taking that into account?
If this thing misses us south I'll be very happy, but I'll be frustrated that for days and days we were told it was about to turn and come for us when literally every update said that actually no it was still moving west.
I know it's an imprecise science, I'm just tense. It just makes little sense to me that the forecasts can be wrong in the same direction so many times in a row.
Every single forecast for the past 48 hours has said it would immediately turn slightly north (or have done so by now) and yet as of 8pm it's still heading due west. What is it that all of these models have been missing for the past 48 hours? Why can't they adjust in a way that if they've had the forecast incorrect in a certain direction for so many forecasts in a row, that they start taking that into account?
If this thing misses us south I'll be very happy, but I'll be frustrated that for days and days we were told it was about to turn and come for us when literally every update said that actually no it was still moving west.
I know it's an imprecise science, I'm just tense. It just makes little sense to me that the forecasts can be wrong in the same direction so many times in a row.
I'm not sure what you're referring to. The models have it moving North as it reaches the Florida Keys, which won't be until the weekend. They pretty much all have it continuing on its WNW trajectory until then.
Watch these videos: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l30eClrQtCA
They do a good job of breaking down what steers a hurricane and why it can be so imprecise
I'm in the Turks and Caicos. The models have had it hitting us directly for the last three days because it was supposed to turn to the north (ie start moving WNW, which is a northernly turn), but it hasn't. So my question is why they kept predicting this turn for 48 hours or more when it just hasn't happened and doesn't seem like it's going to happen. They've scared the shit out of us with these forecasts which may end up having been totally incorrect, but more frustratingly incorrect in the same way for each one, every three hours, despite seeing that they were getting it wrong every 3 hours.
Fixes from the latest satellite and radar imagery suggest that Irma
is moving a little north of due west or 280/13 kt. A strong ridge
extending southwestward from the central Atlantic is expected to
steer Irma west-northwestward during the couple of days. A large
mid-latitude trough over the eastern United States is forecast to
lift northeastward, allowing the ridge to build westward and keep
Irma on a westward to west-northwestward heading through Friday.
Heading for landfall in the Carolinas as an incredibly intense hurricane. Florida is saved on this run. Nightmare for forecasters.....
![]()
I'm not buy any path for another 24 hours. This morning Irma was going to thread the needle into the Gulf. Now, a dramatic northern turn. Still too early to be definitive.Heading for landfall in the Carolinas as an incredibly intense hurricane. Florida is saved on this run. Nightmare for forecasters.....
![]()
How much accuracy does this hold?
![]()
Folks this is the path from the National Hurricane Service as of just now. Nothing has changed..
The NHS cone seems to be following the Euro model path
Heading for landfall in the Carolinas as an incredibly intense hurricane. Florida is saved on this run. Nightmare for forecasters.....
![]()
Irma could make landfall in the continental U.S. as a Category 4 storm, as Harvey did in August. Since 1851, there hasnt been another year in which two Category 4 storms have directly affected the continental U.S.
An average five-day track forecast is off by greater than 200 miles. Thats over 60 miles wider than the distance from St. Petersburg on the western coast of Florida to Vero Beach on the east.
The error cone exists not out of an abundance of caution by a government agency but because of real mathematical uncertainty about where the storm will go. A track that takes Irma east or west of the Florida Peninsula and anywhere in between is still possible.
The most likely track, however, remains the center of that cone, which currently passes very close to the Florida Keys.
See the NHC forecast. There is ALWAYS going to be a margin of error which is why they have the cones.I'm in the Turks and Caicos. The models have had it hitting us directly for the last three days because it was supposed to turn to the north (ie start moving WNW, which is a northernly turn), but it hasn't. So my question is why they kept predicting this turn for 48 hours or more when it just hasn't happened and doesn't seem like it's going to happen. They've scared the shit out of us with these forecasts which may end up having been totally incorrect, but more frustratingly incorrect in the same way for each one, every three hours, despite seeing that they were getting it wrong every 3 hours.
Thanks, will watch now.
Pretty good chance that Harvey & Irma will be the first time on record that two cat-4 hurricanes hit the continental US in the same year.
https://fivethirtyeight.com/feature...er-where-it-makes-landfall/?ex_cid=538twitter
Some info on hurricane tracking accuracy:
God dammit don't hit DR or PR and rest of the Islands hard plz.. Ugh.. I got fam in both..
This may be what you're looking for... Graphs of NHC margins of error in tracking and windspeed over time http://www.aoml.noaa.gov/hrd/tcfaq/F6.htmlYanks Joe, do you know any site that does a 'post mortem' on Hurricanes and their tracks? Sort of a by the numbers how did we do with certain forecasts, maybe by conglomerate model or otherwise?
When is the next update.
so is it hitting the panhandle?
https://twitter.com/TheAstroNick/status/905139947899932674
Jobs I do not want: the guy who flies a plane into the middle of a cat 5 hurricane
Disgusting how people do this shit before a category 5 storm,
![]()
Yes that advertising alcholoic beverages as emergency kits for hurricanes
Am I missing something? Irma isn't projexted to hit the gulf, right? Just left a Walmart in Mississippi and the water section was nearly cleared out.
Am I missing something? Irma isn't projexted to hit the gulf, right? Just left a Walmart in Mississippi and the water section was nearly cleared out.
It could hit anywhere at this point but Florida is probably where it will end up.
This may be what you're looking for... Graphs of NHC margins of error in tracking and windspeed over time http://www.aoml.noaa.gov/hrd/tcfaq/F6.html
![]()
![]()
If we could accurately predict the weather don't you think we would?Am I missing something? Irma isn't projexted to hit the gulf, right? Just left a Walmart in Mississippi and the water section was nearly cleared out.
161 kt wind at the surface in the North Eyewall, this storm is insane, scary to think there may stronger winds elsewhere in storm...
i would hit up a wawa fill up on gas just in case
11PM NHC update just went up. Doesn't look like much has changed
Gail the snail works at the wawa and we have mad beef!It sounds so simple.
Man if you see an empty gas station full of [out of orders] then park your bum onto one of the pumps until gas comes.
It is way faster than going into a line. It's how I got my gas. Though many don't have the time to wait.
So all set and ready for the evacuation signal. Maybe. Dunno yet.
11PM NHC update just went up. Doesn't look like much has changed in regards to their forecast cone track over the 8PM incremental update.
![]()
From the other thread:The latest GFS run could be described as Hurricane Hugo, but worse.
Why do people respect the GFS? I saw some other people talking about how the "usually reliable GFS" was way off, and I thought it was kind of funny because it's usually not as accurate as the Euro.