NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not like people got booted for voicing their opinion about a video game or movie. They were trying make the argument that some child porn isn't actually child porn or that there is nuance to it. There isn't. Child porn is child porn. The fact that it's "just a drawing" or whatever doesn't change the fact that it is still a pornographic image of a child. No amount of "Well actually..." is going to change that or make it okay.


Do you get what I'm saying?

and there's a legal precedent too, there's probably more.

 
Didn't think 3 others was that kind of guy and surprised he earned a perm, I'm hoping he just expressed himself incredibly poorly or tried to be too edgy.

Makes me think about people that get turned on by women dressing in school uniforms. Always thought that seemed a bit fucked up, that's clothing specifically designed for children that you're getting aroused by. Any threads discussing this topic?

IMO anime teens and schoolgirl fetishes are a grey area but all the permabans that I've seen weren't ever referencing that solely. Hell there's a 2D women thread in the OT.

I haven't seen anyone pull the "well ackshully it's ephebophilia" bullshit yet though. Which really just sounds like "pedophile adjacent".
 
I haven't seen anyone pull the "well ackshully it's ephebophilia" bullshit yet though. Which really just sounds like "pedophile adjacent".

Ain't gonna lie, I had to google that word. WTF at the questions and answers that came up below.


NrsYTyD.jpg
 
I am all for a zero tolerance policy on THAT subject.

I don't believe and 3 others is a pedo-(apologist) but still, never normalize that subject for discussion.

The mods on this site deserve appreciation for a lot of things but the way this is handled is particularly good.
 
This iDubbbz looking ass getting all the hotties in Michigan and I'm just here masturbating.

I haven't had a hottie since to be honest tbh. Took some time to myself afterward, got a better job, fixed my credit, COVID hit, etc.

Just bought an SUV too. I should be able to fit a cutie in there one day.

Been working on myself hella-hard tbh. That chick was young and cute but off her rocker. No thanks. I remember meeting her friends, the males in particular, and realizing that 22 year old dudes look like babies. I felt real weird after that.
 
I only skimmed some of the posts here and in the Reee thread regarding this hot topic of child porn the last few pages. My view is that it should be all trashed.

Doesn't matter if it's real life or some dude making a video game where fake kids made with pixels are doing upskirt photos. And as gross as it seems some of those weird Japanese games are ones where the better the photo you do the more points you get.

It's allowed as long as it's 18+ and because it's fake graphics. So depending on the country, it's either a-ok or considered the equivalent of real life child porn.

Not my kind of thing. And for me, either kind of media should be tossed in the garbage.
 
Last edited:
I've written replies and decided not to hit "Post Reply" a number of times.

So far, counting to 10 has served me well.

Besides, those abandoned responses just become fodder for those imaginary arguments I think of winning when I'm in the shower. It makes getting clean that much more enjoyable.
 
Last edited:
Fucking hell. This same topic again. For the new people I understand why you'd ask about it since you are new and reading 277 pages of this thread is time consuming and man you got better things to do than browse a forum. Right? But for the older members, did we not have this same topic months ago twice? Oh you want to discuss it now? Again? Want your fucking like and some quotes/reply? Tough shit you don't deserve a (you). You know why people like things in general do you not you fucking imbecile? Well let's apply some of that COMMON sense to this topic. Now let's talk about 2D and why Phil ate a ban. Liking drawings does NOT mean you fap to them, not all drawings and people that like art, scribbles or whatever they may call it are for the purpose of that. Cute art, cool art, lewd art? GETTING THE FUCKING PICTURE? I'm not gonna go into specifics here because you wouldn't fucking understand anyway you retard. Well ANYWAY, Phil was defending a person that CHOOSES to masturbate (and why would he do that again THINK) to a drawing of a child getting fucked. A drawing that can be literally anything, it can be a perfect woman because that is what 2D is (in context to this ban and the others), it is literally something that can't be achieved IRL but that guy is jerking it to kids getting fucked and you don't fucking get why defending that shit won't fly here. OFC it isn't the same thing as actual CP you fucknugget that doesn't fucking matter you absolute brainlet. Can you not put 2+2 together? Ofc you can't. Rhetorical question. Yes I have to point that out as well because you just don't get it.


tl:dr Mods made the right call this is uncomfortable shit you are defending. It is a miracle your ass isn't banned.
IMO anime teens and schoolgirl fetishes are a grey area but all the permabans that I've seen weren't ever referencing that solely. Hell there's a 2D women thread in the OT.
My thread has nothing to do with that. Hell in the last page I made fun of a guy for liking a potato over a woman. FFS.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Fucking hell. This same topic again. For the new people I understand why you'd ask about it since you are new and reading 277 pages of this thread is time consuming and man you got better things to do than browse a forum. Right? But for the older members, did we not have this same topic months ago twice? Oh you want to discuss about it now? Again? Want your fucking like and some quotes/reply? Tough shit you don't deserve a (you). You know why people like things in general do you not you fucking imbecile? Well let's apply some of that COMMON sense to this topic. Now let's talk about 2D and why Phil ate a ban. Liking drawings does NOT mean you fap to them, not all drawings and people that like art, scribbles or whatever they may call it are for the purpose of that. Cute art, cool art, lewd art? GETTING THE FUCKING PICTURE? I'm not gonna go into specifics here because you wouldn't fucking understand anyway you retard. Well ANYWAY, Phil was defending a person that CHOOSES to masturbate (and why would he do that again THINK) to a drawing of a child getting fucked. A drawing that can be literally anything, it can be a perfect woman because that is what 2D is (in context to this ban and the others), it is literally something that can't be achieved IRL but that guy is jerking it to kids getting fucked and you don't fucking get why defending that shit won't fly here. OFC it isn't the same thing as actual CP you fucknugget that doesn't fucking matter you absolute brainlet. Can you not put 2+2 together? Ofc you can't. Rhetorical question. Yes I have to point that out as well because you just don't get it.


tl:dr Mods made the right call this is uncomfortable shit you are defending. It is a miracle your ass isn't banned.

My thread has nothing to do with that. Hell in the last page I made fun of a guy for liking a potato over a woman. FFS.
Some people just want to stigmatized pure innocent Japanese animation for no good reason whatsoever.

In the past, we would call those kind of people "dirty minded" who just saw elements of sexuality in almost everything.

Next thing you know, watching Kiki's Delivery Service will mean you like underage adolescent girls. What a shame.
 
All I will say is people need to learn the difference between anime and hentai.

If hentai depicts CP, then it should be banned and called out indefinitely.

If anime depicts normal every adolescent girls in popular anime like Neon Genesis Evangelion, then it should not be banned or called out for any good reason whatsoever.

If you're uncomfortable watching Neon Genesis Evangelion because of an age gap issue you're having, don't project that shit on other who watch that anime for a plethora of other good reasons (e.g. compelling narrative, cutting-edge animation, etc).
 
All I will say is people need to learn the difference between anime and hentai.

If hentai depicts CP, then it should be banned and called out indefinitely.

If anime depicts normal every adolescent girls in popular anime like Neon Genesis Evangelion, then it should not be banned or called out for any good reason whatsoever.

If you're uncomfortable watching Neon Genesis Evangelion because of an age gap issue you're having, don't project that shit on other who watch that anime for a plethora of other good reasons (e.g. compelling narrative, cutting-edge animation, etc).
If you AREN'T uncomfortable after watching NGE for the first time you are most likely the unabomber though.
 
All I will say is people need to learn the difference between anime and hentai.

If hentai depicts CP, then it should be banned and called out indefinitely.

If anime depicts normal every adolescent girls in popular anime like Neon Genesis Evangelion, then it should not be banned or called out for any good reason whatsoever.

If you're uncomfortable watching Neon Genesis Evangelion because of an age gap issue you're having, don't project that shit on other who watch that anime for a plethora of other good reasons (e.g. compelling narrative, cutting-edge animation, etc).

How about what looks like underage looking anime girls with big tits, lingerie, short skirt schoolgirl outfits, etc?
How is any of that "projecting" thinking that this shit is promoting something wrong.

Just because it's your little kink and you want to defend it?

I am okay with zero tolerance on this and I made my peace now with 3others ban, but then I'd really urge the mods here to look into all of that smudge I have seen here posted.
 
No issues with a zero tolerance policy for that particular topic, but if that's the case then people need to be aware of it before getting nuked. Is it stated anywhere?
Was thinking about the same thing yesterday after this discussion..
Is there a list of zero tolerance topics here on GAF?

I was quite a bit surprised when the permhammer hit on those involved in that "racial IQ" discussion, for instance. I have seen stuff being written in other threads that was a lot more racist than those posts felt to me.

I start feeling a bit like on REE where I wasn't sure if expressing my a bit more extreme view on a topic might get me permed without a chance.

So, I'd like to know the topics where we have zero tolerance policy apart from CP and racial IQ.

Thanks.
 
Was thinking about the same thing yesterday after this discussion..
Is there a list of zero tolerance topics here on GAF?

I was quite a bit surprised when the permhammer hit on those involved in that "racial IQ" discussion, for instance. I have seen stuff being written in other threads that was a lot more racist than those posts felt to me.

I start feeling a bit like on REE where I wasn't sure if expressing my a bit more extreme view on a topic might get me permed without a chance.

So, I'd like to know the topics where we have zero tolerance policy apart from CP and racial IQ.

Thanks.
I think it's pretty much don't hate people because of race, don't promote sex acts with kids. Don't call out the Evilore accusations and don't criticize Sony. 😅
 
Last edited:
I think it's pretty much don't hate people because of race, don't promote sex acts with kids. Don't call out the Evilore accusations and don't criticize Sony. 😅

Don't make preggo topics, don't get salty about not being allowed them for two weeks afterwards, don't stealth preggo into other topics.
 
Don't make preggo topics, don't get salty about not being allowed them for two weeks afterwards, don't stealth preggo into other topics.
Oops I did miss the preggo and feet topics, but it looks like they arent instantly permaban.
Warning bans in effect for those.
 
All I will say is people need to learn the difference between anime and hentai.

If hentai depicts CP, then it should be banned and called out indefinitely.

If anime depicts normal every adolescent girls in popular anime like Neon Genesis Evangelion, then it should not be banned or called out for any good reason whatsoever.

If you're uncomfortable watching Neon Genesis Evangelion because of an age gap issue you're having, don't project that shit on other who watch that anime for a plethora of other good reasons (e.g. compelling narrative, cutting-edge animation, etc).

DgUwhjF.jpg
 
Don't make preggo topics, don't get salty about not being allowed them for two weeks afterwards, don't stealth preggo into other topics.

Yeah, not the best look. Like, I'd love a female foot thread here to chum around with my fellow like minded people, but to actually get upset about the "no fetish threads" thing is very odd to me.

Most things are fine here as long as you're playful and clearly in jest. Probably not the easiest to determine who is joking or not just by text alone. I dont envy the mods. They do a damn good job fwiw
 
Yeah, not the best look. Like, I'd love a female foot thread here to chum around with my fellow like minded people, but to actually get upset about the "no fetish threads" thing is very odd to me.

Most things are fine here as long as you're playful and clearly in jest. Probably not the easiest to determine who is joking or not just by text alone. I dont envy the mods. They do a damn good job fwiw
+1 on everything

Rules are rules.

(I just don't want to get permed with no chance of defense if I simply don't know a rule.)
 
Last edited:
No issues with a zero tolerance policy for that particular topic, but if that's the case then people need to be aware of it before getting nuked. Is it stated anywhere? It may not be like the @Sqorin Hammerfarf situation where he knew and did it anyway.

Pretty much. I don't think fair or reasonable to perm people for crossing a line that isn't explicitly laid out. Mods should have intervened in terms of the topic in the first place. Bad call.
 
EviLore EviLore thoughts on reaching out to @Princessmiffy to clarify intent? Lil Arcy has a point that he may have been eager to vent after escaping the asylum.
Other people manage to vent while staying classy. I don't think this is the place to shout about how much you can't stand trans people, or any other group of people.

No one is going to ban you for criticizing affirmative action, SJWs, identity politics, for saying "biological sex is real" etc. Just don't be a hateful dick.
 
How about we just ban all anime

Vegeta GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY | Anime dragon ball, Dragon ball, Dragon  ball super


Other people manage to vent while staying classy. I don't think this is the place to shout about how much you can't stand trans people, or any other group of people.

No one is going to ban you for criticizing affirmative action, SJWs, identity politics, for saying "biological sex is real" etc. Just don't be a hateful dick.

Eh I'd say that's true for the most part, but definitely not always. You will definitely catch a ban or have your creation privileges revoked if you are always railing on about a risqué topic, even if you really do your research and argue respectfully 100% of the time.

Whether that's good or bad depends on your personal preference, but it's observably true.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom