Fixed
Manga Discussion/News Thread |OT4| New Ch/Vols! - SEE FIRST POST FOR RULES!
- Thread starter mysticwhip
- Start date
- Status
One Piece
It's One Piece all right.
We still don't know about the rest of the Fishman Pirates who didn't join Hody (some followed Jinbei and some went off to do their own thing) especially those who went with Jinbei
There's Nami getting a new Log Pose
And a bit more random: I'm still curious about the age box Decken was talking about, and if Koala won't show up somewhere in this arc she'll probably never show up again
It's One Piece all right.
You read Kurosawa right? Can't remember.Guys, recommend me dark depressing mangas, please. Stuff like Elfen Lied or Mirai Nikki or Claymore.
But nothing too extreme like Ichi the Killer
There's still the prediction of Madam
We still don't know about the rest of the Fishman Pirates who didn't join Hody (some followed Jinbei and some went off to do their own thing) especially those who went with Jinbei
There's Nami getting a new Log Pose
And a bit more random: I'm still curious about the age box Decken was talking about, and if Koala won't show up somewhere in this arc she'll probably never show up again
I bet that the Post-Arc Party gets a little out of control and ends up wrecking the island.
One Piece C
Finally a closure to this arc. Sea kings appearing are pretty boss.
All of my "balls to wall" hate for them is completely legitimate. Maybe if you sat down and read what I'm talking about, you'd realize there is nothing wrong with my complaints. Everyone of my complaints about Naruto, Bleach, and even One Piece are perfectly valid opinions to have on the three series and are well-backed up with actual facts. I'm not just bringing up my dislike of Naruto out of anywhere either. When this chapter is shit, I'm going to point it out as I was really displeased with this chapter. My points may line up with the entire Naruto series, but they apply to this chapter too, which is what I'm talking about.
Finally a closure to this arc. Sea kings appearing are pretty boss.
You lied about what I said about One Piece, I literally never implied or said One Piece was as good as the best written series ever. That is definitely disrespectful and misinformation only to make yourself look better.
All of my "balls to wall" hate for them is completely legitimate. Maybe if you sat down and read what I'm talking about, you'd realize there is nothing wrong with my complaints. Everyone of my complaints about Naruto, Bleach, and even One Piece are perfectly valid opinions to have on the three series and are well-backed up with actual facts. I'm not just bringing up my dislike of Naruto out of anywhere either. When this chapter is shit, I'm going to point it out as I was really displeased with this chapter. My points may line up with the entire Naruto series, but they apply to this chapter too, which is what I'm talking about.
gundamkyoukai
Member
Side note i need to get this out my system , i think judging a chapter with a grade is really stupid .
Judging a Arc ,Vol with grade cool but a chapter ........
Judging a Arc ,Vol with grade cool but a chapter ........
I give this post an F.
Not enough content, too much filler with these ".....", and you are just reusing old plot elements.
I agree. It's like judging an individual chapter of a novel.
flintstryker
Banned
I have been thinking this for a while now lol.
Maleficence
Member
To be fair, manga chapters aren't released like a novel so marking them similarly is also unfair. Perhaps Manga chapters should be released as a volume rather then individually though, though the wait would be agonising!
I abandoned the idea based on thread feedback and went with an original. Letter grades are indeed poor now that I have taken the subsequent results in.
Listening is taboo ITT though.
Maybe, but saying that that's so bad it makes the HxH scribbles look like masterpieces is just going too far, even if you're exaggerating. Need I remind you how those scribbles actually look like?
No way. That looks like something I'd draw
Well one chapter may ruin the entire volume to be honest. Like if I were to read the volume revealing Madara is still alive, I would give it an F. On a chapter-by-chapter basis, only that chapter is an F.
*Makes note to make completely ambiguous reviews to confuse scy*
Your words are enough for the reader to ascertain their own "grade."
Franky not amused.
i really think that is some of Oda's best work right there. Like i would use that as my avatar if i didnt already have an awesome robot assassin.
Franky is film noir enough for me to use him though. plus too recognizable. so few people can recognize my current avatar and i like it.
you sir are a gentleman and a scholar for knowing that
Basically this.
Also, shit, we're debating grading scores. I guess review score debates are ubiquitous.
watervengeance
Member
One Piece - Am I the only one that's surprised that Luffy fainted from overuse of his Elephant Gun? And he didn't even get to destroy the ship.
I thought it was the blood loss? Either way, it was still cheesy.
I thought it was a pretty crazy attack. Jet Gatling used to be a thing, so add a Gear 3rd on that, and have it going for more than an instant, and it'll still be a thing even after 2 years.
I mean that's sorta basic math there.
Dedication Through Light
Member
One Piece
That was a pretty amazing chapter coming off the back of last weeks epicness. Oda finally resorted to the unpredictable and beat my expectations of Luffy being the one to cause Noah to rain in pieces on the island, but instead call forth the majestic creatures. I cant wait to see how huge they look in the anime. Hopefully they quickly move Noah from the island.
That was a pretty amazing chapter coming off the back of last weeks epicness. Oda finally resorted to the unpredictable and beat my expectations of Luffy being the one to cause Noah to rain in pieces on the island, but instead call forth the majestic creatures. I cant wait to see how huge they look in the anime. Hopefully they quickly move Noah from the island.
Infinite Justice
Member
it hurts even more from you Gods Beard since you're still holding Tetsuwan Girl hostage.
SolarKnight
Member
I thought it was because of blood loss.
gundamkyoukai
Member
Yep look like it was from blood loss because doing Elephant Gun made the wound open and bleed more.
One Piece 647:
That's what I meant by "-) Luffy accidentally destroying Fishman Island in some comical fashion and/or a different meaning behind the Fishman Island destruction prediction.". I'm still thinking Fishman Island will get destroyed but either by Luffy not doing it on purpose or someone else with a Straw Hat showing up.
I'm still curious about the other Fishmen too but those things aren't necessary for the arc to come to a close. They could introduce those Fishmen later on in the series.
That's what I meant by "-) Luffy accidentally destroying Fishman Island in some comical fashion and/or a different meaning behind the Fishman Island destruction prediction.". I'm still thinking Fishman Island will get destroyed but either by Luffy not doing it on purpose or someone else with a Straw Hat showing up.
I'm still curious about the other Fishmen too but those things aren't necessary for the arc to come to a close. They could introduce those Fishmen later on in the series.
Freshmaker
I am Korean.
That's a D- at worst. C'mon man.
Freshmaker
I am Korean.
Our manga reviews are better then the video game press. No shills, no bias.
Excluding the mindless fanboy posts.
There are still gems in the swarm but not much these days. Blood+, Cowboy Bebop, Elfen Lied, Eureka Seven, FMP, GitS, Ghost Hunt, Haibane, Last Exile, Mushi, My-HiME, Planetes, RahXephon, Samurai Champloo, Samurai X, Trigun, Utawarerumono, Zegapain, etc...
Yea, I'm bringing anime in the house. All the moe and penguin drums can't skip to a beat better then that mob of greatness. GG modern anime, gfg.
I used to do it once upon a time. You callin me a moron son? That's F+ behavior at best.
Phoenician_Viking
Banned
one piece
I am convinced more than ever that Shirahoshi will join the crew.
I am convinced more than ever that Shirahoshi will join the crew.
Stealth Editor
Member
Dear god no
Freshmaker
I am Korean.
Given the nature of the narrative it is strange at best to pick apart a fraction of a single story each week without any consideration for how this fragment will fit together with the whole.
So I think the practice is moronic, not necessarily the people.
Also, Eureka 7 was awful.
I cannot conceive of what people who actually think this will happen have running through their heads.
Neoriceisgood
Member
Don't be silly, everyone knows Perona and Hodi will join.
I only pick fights I can win.
I give your reasoning 6.9/10. Will buy @ $10.
Awful of pre-2007 is award winning in 2011.
Tatami Galaxy > all the shit you listed with the exception of Planetes
Seriously.TLR 42
For the past 5 chapters or so they one-upped themselves every chapter. It's crazy.
lulz
I keep forgetting I need to finish this.
Best manga OF ALL TIME.
I can't wait until you two read TLR Darkness.
- Status