So what say you Knicks-age. Who's to blame? At the office, me and my buddies simply feel bad for D'Antoni at this point. We have these extensive talks about how much we hate the Knicks. We come down to all sorts of conclusions. We've agreed on numerous, and they are: Amare is lazy. Chandler is confused. The bench has no concept of the shot clock (*cough*Walker*cough*). Melo has no support. Fields has gone flaccid. Douglas is just about the dumbest player the Knicks have had in the past 20 years.
What's the deal? Is D'Antoni to blame largely? Or is the team completely insubordinate, incapable of following orders, lazy, and lacking common sense?
70% D'Antoni, 10% Walsh/Grunwald, 20% the players.
D'Antoni is an idiot. It is clear that Steve Nash made his career, and not the other way around. He is incapable of adjusting, and knows nothing of Xs and Os short of "LET'S GO LET'S GO LET'S GO" and "SHOOT SHOOT SHOOT". He is so inflexible that he won't allow even the slightest inkling of defense - an integral part of an actual basketball team. Fuck this guy.
Walsh left a good foundation, even though he allowed us to cannibalize all of our depth for Melo. That kind of sucked, because we don't have the kind of parts that would work to fill in our holes - most notably, a point guard. Grunwald took what he had left, and while he did right to get Chandler, we still have nothing else to work with in the rest of the roster.
Some of the players I have problems with the most right now, like Fields and Douglas, are just being used wrong. Fields and Douglas should be part of the first group off the bench. They'd be assets there, ESPECIALLY if the Knicks had an adequate back-up PG so they could be in the right positions for them (SG and SF). In a perfect world, the healthy Knicks lineup would be:
Davis
Shumpert
Anthony
Stoudemire
Chandler
with (decent back-up PG), Douglas, Fields, Harrelson and Jeffries the next set, and Balkman/Jordan/Novak and whatever other crap playing rarely.
Aside from that, I wish that some players - namely Stoudemire - made the SLIGHTEST effort on D. It's ridiculous that nobody really makes effort. It's ridiculous that the Knicks are so stupid on D that they switch on every possession and get fucked over with bigs on guards, guards on forwards and centers, and people just standing confused as fat Diaw styles on them forever.
In short, firedantoni.com. Get Davis healthy. Get a real back-up PG so that people can serve as bench depth. Stop shooting goddamn 3s.