Winter 2012 Anime Thread of Roundcats Up in This

Status
Not open for further replies.
That sentence itself isn't very pretentuitous though.

We need to go deeper.
The closest you'll get to that is :cajun
I think :cajun rolls off the e-tongue better than hnnnnghophile anyway. How would you even standardize the number of n's in hnnghophile?
 
Are English song titles that are basically sentences pretentious? (see: Fallout Boy or Panic! At The Disco)

edit: It would be interesting to see a GAF list of what they consider to be pretentious anime. The only one that ever comes to mind for me is Ergo Proxy, as I mentioned. I used to think the original EVA TV series was like this (especially the original ending) but I reeled back on that opinion to simply hating the show.
 
Guilty Crown 8-12
RIP Lt. Dan

I'm glad Beta Shu finally got his shit together. Although the twist of his sister and his convenient memory loss felt very rushed and poorly done(Also predictable). I would like more closure between Gai and Mana, many many things are still left unexplained with them at the center.

Conveniently Gai's black trench coat survived the events unscathed, and with Shu/Inori! I predict a time-skip in which Shu don's the trench coat and becomes the bad ass we saw in episode 4.

The closure in episode 12 just didn't feel right. Maybe it was expedient pacing, maybe it was just the poorly done story dialogue, I don't know.

Guilty Crown gets a lot of shit for the writing, some of which is warranted. Guilty Crown shines when it stops trying to copy every other successful anime.
 
AnimeGAF exploring territories of language heretofore unmapped.

Like a Scout stumbling upon some Ancient Ruins, unlocking the secret to a new technology.
 
All shit anime is pretentious; because they actually created it with the intention that it was quality, how pretentious.
 
All shit anime is pretentious; because they actually created it with the intention that it was quality, how pretentious.
I don't think SHAFT ever thought they were doing quality work.

Just whatever they have to do to get that ramen money.
 
Guilty Crown 8-12
RIP Lt. Dan

I'm glad Beta Shu finally got his shit together. Although the twist of his sister and his convenient memory loss felt very rushed and poorly done(Also predictable). I would like more closure between Gai and Mana, many many things are still left unexplained with them at the center.

Conveniently Gai's black trench coat survived the events unscathed, and with Shu/Inori! I predict a time-skip in which Shu don's the trench coat and becomes the bad ass we saw in episode 4.

The closure in episode 12 just didn't feel right. Maybe it was expedient pacing, maybe it was just the poorly done story dialogue, I don't know.

Guilty Crown gets a lot of shit for the writing, some of which is warranted. Guilty Crown shines when it stops trying to copy every other successful anime.

Guilty Crown is sadly an exercise in taking a story heavily borrowing from other pieces and condensing it from a 26 episode to a 12 episode shot (thus far) and sticking in Shinji Ikari 2.0. You can't get attached to any characters, the pacing is awful and you want to punch the protagonist in the face whenever he is on screen.
 
All shit anime is pretentious; because they actually created it with the intention that it was quality, how pretentious.
TKcpH.png
 
Fairy Tail 45
Gotta say I like the show much more when isn't the Natsu show. Lucy got a good fight with Loki, Juvia was awesome and Kana was crap as usual.
Too bad, it's back to the Natsu show next episode.

It's a shame that whenever Lucy is in the show she'll inevitably have to open her mouth and the sounds that will come out are like nails on a chalkboard attached to a cat being strangled by a banshee, to my ears.
 
That reminds me. I have hte boxset of soredemo and need to watch it. The "problem" is that I also have 50 more episodes of CCS. This is a good problem though to have.
 
edit: It would be interesting to see a GAF list of what they consider to be pretentious anime. The only one that ever comes to mind for me is Ergo Proxy, as I mentioned.

Ergo Proxy explicitly reference various Philosophers and theories, calling it 'pretentious' isn't too much of a stretch.

I mean, it's called Ergo Proxy and characters have names like Proxy, Law, Real and Monad.
 
Ergo Proxy explicitly reference various Philosophers and theories, calling it 'pretentious' isn't too much of a stretch.
I think the most "pretentious" thing about Ergo Proxy is the writer actually think it's intelligently written and we are all idiots for understandably finding it boring or something.
 
It's a shame that whenever Lucy is in the show she'll inevitably have to open her mouth and the sounds that will come out are like nails on a chalkboard attached to a cat being strangled by a banshee, to my ears.

I didn't know Aya Hirano got replaced by Chiaki Omigawaah.
 
But I can keep "hipster" right? I wouldn't know what I would do without "hipster".
 
CONTROVERSY: Do pretentious and :moncole go hand in hand?

But I can keep hipster right? I wouldn't know what I would do without "hipster".

Ha. I remember a discussion about anime hipsters. Not much though, which is probably indicative of where it went.
 
Aoi Bungaku looks pretty damn good, I'm surprised to have never heard of it before. I'll be watching. Icarus, we can be impression buddies.
 
what is pretentious about Ergo Proxy?
And why does the girl look like the one from Evanescence?

Well, it seeks to discuss complex social and philosophical ideas. For example, here's how one blogger described episode 11:

This episode seemed to be heavily related to Social Constructionism especially when Ergo Proxy was talking. Not to mention, there is a ton of symbolism and external references throughout this entire episode. One of the biggest references in this episode besides the two I mentioned already is the bookstore owner quoting Jean Jacques Rousseau’s “On the Origin of Languag.” Another one is quarter-power scaling in reference to Vincent’s changing pulse and as well as Ergo Proxy’s. Needless to say, I could go on about the symbolism and references in this episode for quite awhile, but I would much rather hear what other people have to think first.
 
I still dont understand how anime can be pretetious, or how someone knows when something is being specifically pretentious.
Most of the time isn't used to judge the person itself (as normally we don't personally know them), as it is most notably used to (likely) point a disconnection between an extremely elaborated point of view and the emptiness of its proclaimed message in the eyes of the spectators. It is more a problem in reaching them accordingly.

Oh, could this be... irony, in my words?
 
All shit anime is pretentious; because they actually created it with the intention that it was quality, how pretentious.

That's not true at all, there's plenty of crap shows which show no desire to be something else.

Now, Glass Fleet is pretentious. Actually you can pretty much just list every Gonzo show.
 
Most of the time isn't used to judge the person itself (as normally we don't personally know them), as it is most notably used to (likely) point a disconnection between an extremely elaborated point of view and the emptiness of its proclaimed message in the eyes of the spectators. It is more a problem in reaching them accordingly.

Oh, could this be... irony, in my words?

We're entering uncharted territory.
Every story was done by a different production team. Even if its take on Ningen Shikkaku isn't to your liking, you should check out the rest.

And of course they're all adaptations of different stories, most of which have different authors, so it's really just a collection of different short stories.
 
Every story was done by a different production team. Even if its take on Ningen Shikkaku isn't to your liking, you should check out the rest.
I liked it, but during the season it aired I must've forgotten about it for other more :cajun things.

EDIT: Nevermind, it was the season with The Sacred Boobsmith, Nyan Koi, Kamfer and Trapeze. I remember being disillusions with anime as a whole that season (because it was preceded by the glory that is Bakemonogatari) that I stopped watching stuff regularly.
 
Most of the time isn't used to judge the person itself (as normally we don't personally know them), as it is most notably used to (likely) point a disconnection between an extremely elaborated point of view and the emptiness of its proclaimed message in the eyes of the spectators. It is more a problem in reaching them accordingly.

Oh, could this be... irony, in my words?

So basically, if someone doesnt agree with something in an anime, it is pretentious?
 
pretentious (comparative more pretentious, superlative most pretentious)

1. Marked by an unwarranted claim to importance or distinction. Their song titles are pretentious in the context of their basic lyrics.

2. Ostentatious; intended to impress others. Her dress was obviously more pretentious than comfortable.

- wiktionary

Get your real definitions outta here!
 
pretentious (comparative more pretentious, superlative most pretentious)

1. Marked by an unwarranted claim to importance or distinction. Their song titles are pretentious in the context of their basic lyrics.

2. Ostentatious; intended to impress others. Her dress was obviously more pretentious than comfortable.

- wiktionary

Ugh.. Now that we have a definition I can't use it to mean whatever I want.

Like anything I don't understand or like.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom