So by this logic, Mario should have stayed 2D forever right? Dragon Quest too?
After all, it would have been fine for most fans... But then we would lose something new and incredible.
The Pokemon games are great, because the underlying formula is among the best gaming has to offer. Great world and characters, simple and addictive gameplay, emphasis on multiplayer and collection, surprising depth for those who seek it.
But it has remained relatively the same for over 15 years now, and being apologetic about it is wrong. The series has been on 3D-capable hardware since 2006. It's time to bring up the scale, and bring the online functionality closer to its true (and amazing) potential. This can probably only happen on the 3DS. Make it happen already!