Saint Gregory
Member
That would require actual investigative journalism as opposed to sitting around waiting for official PRs and free games/consoles.
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
3DS XL First Impressions/Previews
- Thread starter Truth101
- Start date
- Status
That would require actual investigative journalism as opposed to sitting around waiting for official PRs and free games/consoles.
Caelestis
Member
Thanks for the heads up, got the red one pre-ordered now. I've been waiting on them since all other places have tax for me.
Some of my biggest "wants" for 3DS XL are the battery life, larger screens, smooth edges (which look far more comfortable than the standard 3DS's beveled edges,) and the increased DPI for DS games running at 1:1. (I felt let down when I first played DS games on 3DS compared to on DSi.)
So last night I borrowed a DSi XL to play around with, since I don't have access to a 3DS XL and the two units are nearly identical in size and weight. Obviously the DSi XL's DPI is terrible so I ignored that, but the screen size is generally similar I imagine (for the touchscreen at least.) My game of choice was Elite Beat Agents because I wanted to get a feel for stylus-heavy games on a larger screen, and what I found was that the heavier system combined with the larger range of motion required made the game more difficult to play. Afterward I moved on to a little NSMB just to get a feel for the system as it plays without a stylus.
Once I was done there, I set down the DSi XL and grabbed my 3DS to play the same games and compare. The moment I opened my 3DS and had it in my hands, I did a complete 180 and am now about 95% sure I don't want a 3DS XL. It all came down to comfort. The standard 3DS just felt so much lighter and the smaller size was much more comfortable for me (worth mentioning: I have fairly small hands for a guy.) It just felt "right" in my hands. I then proceeded to play some EBA and NSMB on my 3DS in both stretch mode and 1:1 and found both experiences superior to the DSi XL.
Obviously it all boils down to opinions, as I've heard tons of praise for the DSi XL and now the 3DS XL too. But for me, I felt like a little kid whose hands were far too small for the system I was trying to play (again, this was a DSi XL, not a 3DS XL.) I still want to try a 3DS XL firsthand, but I expect that will only solidify my decision to pass this time.
If you're even remotely on the fence like I was, I suggest trying to get firsthand experience before committing. Especially if you've never used a DSi XL or if you typically prefer smaller handhelds.
On the bright side, if Nintendo comes out with another revision in a year or two that's similar in size to the 3DS/DSi, I'll probably be sold in an instant.
Sorry for the wall of text.
Not in the USA. They are everywhere else in the world.
Wouldn't be surprised at all if their next revision is "3DS lite" or something, like a streamlined version of the current size with the XL's design...I wouldn't even mind having both (so I'd carry it around more often), but only if Nintendo gets over their stupid one system per user mindset. Hopefully they'll figure it out with their whole network thing by then.
flamesofchaos
Member
Yeah but it's out in a month you'd think they would start preordering by now. Is there some evidence that they aren't selling it in the US? I'd rather buy from Amazon for release date prime.
Blood Diamonds
Banned
Dream Drop Distance will look sooo goood on this 
outunderthestars
Banned
I have a feeling that t will just be offered by third parties again, and not directly through Amazon.
Dream Drop Distance will look sooo goood on this
That's what I'm waiting for. I have a 3DS but don't want to play DDD until I get the XL. Considering I am a KH fan that's gonna be an annoying wait.
August 19th is a Sunday, you can't get release date delivery for anything released on a Sunday, can you?
Electivirus
Member
Unfortunately not. Which is why I'm getting mine at Gamestop.
People in big cities got their 3DS systems on launch day via smaller couriers Amazon was using.
Wow.. that's a huge difference in colour. I'm wondering if that has to do with improved viewing angle (orig. 3DS looks slightly off angle) or if it is actually that much better?
Stealth20k
Banned
looks superior
I have a feeling that t will just be offered by third parties again, and not directly through Amazon.
Amazon Canada has them available for pre-order and will be shipped and sold by Amazon.ca
blue/black
red/black
Well, that's true. It's never a bad thing to save $200 (or more if you're in Europe).
I would like a 3DS XL myself but I am very resistant to replacing something that is working fine, so it can wait until a more appropriate time. This is not like a GBA -> GBA SP situation where it was moronic to not upgrade.
Yeah but they aren't available for pre-order. But in Canada they are releasing on the same day and amazon.ca is already taking pre-orders. see below
Evidence?
Just that NO Nintendo hardware is currently being sold by Amazon.com and it's been that way for AWHILE now.. i think almost a year. You can only buy Nintendo hardware from overpriced third party sellers on Amazon.com.
Amazon is selling Nintendo hardware in all other countries EXCEPT the US. So obviously NoA and Amazon.com have some kind of problem with each other.
A few weeks ago I had to buy the DSi XL from Newegg cause Amazon.com wasn't selling it. Unless Amazon.com and NoA kiss and makeup before the 3DS XL is released it looks like I'll be getting that from Newegg too.
Edag Plata
Banned
So pretty much silver is metallic-ish (obviously, otherwise it'd be grey), blue is the same type as silver only in a blue color, and red is solid, mickey mouse red? :-/ Why isn't red metallic-y?
They are all metallic-y.
yankee666
Member
They are all metallic, except for the white one because we havent seen a real picture of it yet
Edit: Beaten
Edag Plata
Banned
Really? Red didn't look like it was...did I miss the picture where it showed it better or was it in impressions? Is it just that its a much darker and more solid color or does the red just not show the metallic as well in pictures like blue and silver does?
I don't follow this thread closely but I was reading an article about the 3DS XL and they said it won't come with a charger?? WTF? is that true???
I'm this close to buy a 3DS XL but that article pushed me away :O
btw... I'm talking about North America and when I say North America I'm talking about US and Mexico!!
I need aswers pronto! D:
I'm this close to buy a 3DS XL but that article pushed me away :O
btw... I'm talking about North America and when I say North America I'm talking about US and Mexico!!
I need aswers pronto! D:
It comes with a charger in NA and Australia, only in EU and Japan it comes without one.
I haven't seen the XL but I agree with your line of thought and am trying to decide whether or not to upgrade. And I'm leaning toward no. I'd probably have to actually use the XL in order to change my mind. Here's my check box:
+ Bigger size would be easier on hands
+ Better battery life
+ Better build quality (I'm afraid my OG's screens will scratch themselves again)
+ Bigger screen should be nicer to have
+ DS games will be 1:1
+ Apparently better 3D effect
- My portable would be no longer portable (fit in jeans, etc)
- DPI will be lower and image quality is huge for me
- Trade in might not be worth the price difference
- Insecure about my game downloads. Might lose ambassador stuff?
I think I'll hold off for a true 3DS revision, such as a Lite model. XL might be worth it if I didn't already own a 3DS. But it's logical that with the XL, the image quality will appear worse and that it won't fit in my pocket. And those are two rather major things.
Edag Plata
Banned
Your ambassador games do go over. Everything goes over just as you had it before. Trust me, I did it when I switched my launch blue 3DS to the Zelda 3DS.
Also...this is the true 3DS revision. What else do you want?
Also...this is the true 3DS revision. What else do you want?
Stealth20k
Banned
@Glass Joe
I added some things
+ Bigger size would be easier on hands
+ Better battery life
+ Better build quality (I'm afraid my OG's screens will scratch themselves again)
+ Bigger screen should be nicer to have
+ DS games will be 1:1
+ Apparently better 3D effect
+Stylus on the side
+No more screen scratching
+3d slider is better, and clicks off
+Better Buttons all around and the home/start/select are now buttons
+The light's are better
Your cons
- My portable would be no longer portable (fit in jeans, etc) - legit but not really issue
- Trade in might not be worth the price difference ( its a 60 dollar trade in, so its basically 140)
- Insecure about my game downloads. Might lose ambassador stuff? ( you wont loose anything)
- DPI will be lower and image quality is huge for me ( This is not an issue, the game looks exactly the same
I added some things
+ Bigger size would be easier on hands
+ Better battery life
+ Better build quality (I'm afraid my OG's screens will scratch themselves again)
+ Bigger screen should be nicer to have
+ DS games will be 1:1
+ Apparently better 3D effect
+Stylus on the side
+No more screen scratching
+3d slider is better, and clicks off
+Better Buttons all around and the home/start/select are now buttons
+The light's are better
Your cons
- My portable would be no longer portable (fit in jeans, etc) - legit but not really issue
- Trade in might not be worth the price difference ( its a 60 dollar trade in, so its basically 140)
- Insecure about my game downloads. Might lose ambassador stuff? ( you wont loose anything)
- DPI will be lower and image quality is huge for me ( This is not an issue, the game looks exactly the same
Smiles and Cries
Member
I don't get the Amazon vs. Nintendo thing since Wii U is getting Amazon DD
if they don't have pre-order soon I'll go new egg
if they don't have pre-order soon I'll go new egg
Stealth20k
Banned
It has to do with policy or something
friskykillface
Banned
I think it's because so many people complained about the screen scratching thing that happened with launch units.
Shame if amazon doesn't get the XL , I have credit amazon pls
Shame if amazon doesn't get the XL , I have credit
amazon plsthere's an excellent battery test at Gamekult. They compare old 3DS, Vita and 3DS XL
4:47 with max luminosity, WIFI enabled, max 3D
4:47 with max luminosity, WIFI enabled, max 3D
3D is off, actually.
The 3D isn't on in that test.
01DragonFly
Member
Some of the comments I read regarding amazon pulling the 3ds where:
-Screen scratching
-hinge problems (non existent but people where cautions because of the DS issue)
- 3ds boxes not handle properly by amazon ( bend and scratch boxes / poor packing) <- This happened to me
-Too many exchanges /returns
-Screen scratching
-hinge problems (non existent but people where cautions because of the DS issue)
- 3ds boxes not handle properly by amazon ( bend and scratch boxes / poor packing) <- This happened to me
-Too many exchanges /returns
Except Amazon.com stopped selling ALL Nintendo hardware. So to me that suggests whatever the issue is between Amazon.com and Nintendo it goes beyond whatever issues the 3DS was having.
Why would they stop selling the Wii, and DSi, just because people returned the 3DS? Amazon had already been selling the DSi and Wii for years.
I honestly don't know why Amazon.com stopped selling Nintendo hardware.
Video Game Hardware has always been low profit for retailers, thats why you'd see stores bundle hardware with cheap crap no-one wants just so they can make more profit. ...I wonder if it's possible if Amazon.com wants a better deal on Nintendo hardware so they can make more profit selling it at retail price?
Or it could be an entirely different reason. I don't know.
Played it myself. It actually is that much better.
Tried it out at comic con as well. There really is a night and day difference in the quality of the screens and color. I couldn't even notice a difference in jaggies in MK7 when comparing it side by to side to my 3DS. I was already thinking of getting the XL in the first place, but trying out in person definitely sold it to me.
friskykillface
Banned
dat silver, why NoA , whyyyyyyyyyyyyy i wanted thatnhlducks35
Member
This is a very appropriate picture because of the silver Gamecube in the background.
Link?
lostinblue
Banned
Is there a teardown yet?
Or pics of the battery bay?
Or pics of the battery bay?
well, after thinking about it for a few hours I preordered from Newegg too. Got the blue one too.
If Amazon US and Nintendo of America patch things up and Amazon.com starts selling Nintendo hardware again before the 3DS XL release I'll just cancel and order from Amazon, as I'm sure prime shipping will probably be faster.
Last year when Amazon.com stopped selling 3DS's they put up this chart under the product description of all Nintendo handhelds... but not under Sony's handhelds.
vagabondarts
Member
My guess is Amazon is pulling Wal-Mart's game and forcing Nintendo to sell the hardware cheaper just for the benefit of having it directly sold through Amazon.
Either that or the problem they have with each other starts with R, ends in E and has EGGI in the middle.
*shrugs* it's just a guess...
- Status